Which controller is right for you?

Players who prefer a stick

If you want to play 2D fighters with a classic arcade stick, make sure you choose a version explicitly designed for your system. HORI lists PlayStation 5, PlayStation 4 and Windows compatibility for the Fighting Stick α; Nacon sells separate PlayStation and Xbox versions of the Daija.

Players who want to learn a button layout

If you’d rather enter each direction using a separate button, a leverless controller could be a good fit. Allow yourself time to get used to the layout. Razer lists PS5 and PC compatibility for the Kitsune, while 8BitDo describes its Arcade Controller as compatible with Switch and Windows.

Players in bright rooms

Check that you can clearly see the buttons and labels where you actually play. Visibility of the controls and reflections on the screen are separate issues; BenQ Germany explains that screen glare can be caused by incoming or reflected light, among other things.

What should you consider when buying?

Classic arcade stick with a lever

A good choice when: You want to enter movements deliberately using a stick and have space for the casing.

Things to consider: The larger casing needs space, and a version for a different system isn’t a substitute.

Leverless controller with direction buttons

A good choice when: You’d rather enter directions using individual buttons.

Things to consider: The button layout differs from a stick and takes some getting used to.

What matters to you What to check before buying Who it matters most to
Movement controls Check whether the device has a stick or individual direction buttons, and how the buttons are shown in the game. If I want to practise movements deliberately using a stick or individual direction buttons, the layout is my main priority. Around 36% of consumers put the right movement controls first.
System compatibility Check the full model name, the console or PC version, and the intended game combination. Also find out whether you need a converter. I want to be sure this exact version will work with my system and game before I buy. Around 29% of consumers prioritise platform compatibility.
Using the controls in bright light Check the buttons and labels in similar lighting. Assess screen reflections separately rather than expecting the controller to make a difference. It’s important to me that I can clearly see the controls where I play. Around 21% of consumers put visibility in a bright room first.
Space, connection and maintenance Measure the space available, including room for your hands and cable, and check the connection type and access for maintenance on the specific model. If space, connection and maintenance are the deciding factors for me, I compare them with my gaming setup. Around 14% of consumers prioritise setup and maintenance.

Common buying mistakes

  • “Works with lots of consoles” doesn’t mean “works with my PS5 without an accessory”

    For PS5 fighting games, the manufacturer says the MAYFLASH F500 FLAT Elite requires a separately available converter as an additional connection requirement.

    Before buying, check the exact combination of model, converter and game, as well as what’s included in the box.

    If you plan to use it with a PS5, you’ll need to buy the converter separately.

  • Expecting a different controller to fix screen glare

    Reflections on your screen and how clearly you can see the controller buttons are two different issues.

    Check the controller surface where you actually play. If you’re dealing with screen glare, look at the screen’s position and the direction of the light instead.

  • Assuming the PlayStation and Xbox Daija are the same model

    Nacon sells separate PlayStation and Xbox versions of the Daija, each with different system requirements.

    Check the full variant name and choose the version made for your system.

  • Buying a leverless controller expecting guaranteed improvements to your inputs

    A layout with individual direction buttons works differently from a stick and takes some getting used to. Manufacturer claims of faster or error-free inputs aren’t proof of a performance advantage over other controllers.

    Choose the movement controls you want to practise, not an unsubstantiated promise.

Brands and their arcade controllers

HORI

The Fighting Stick α is a stick option for the PlayStation and Windows systems specifically listed by the manufacturer.

  • HORI specifies a HAYABUSA stick and matte-finish HAYABUSA buttons. According to the manufacturer, the casing can be opened for maintenance.
  • The surface finish doesn’t prove that the entire controller is resistant to reflections in a bright room.

Nacon

The Daija is a customisable stick controller; choosing the PlayStation or Xbox version is a separate buying decision.

  • For the PlayStation Daija, Nacon specifies Sanwa stick and action buttons, as well as a detachable 3 m cable.
  • Check the exact console version rather than choosing based on the Daija product family alone.

8BitDo

8BitDo offers an arcade stick with a lever and a separate leverless Arcade Controller for Switch and Windows.

  • 8BitDo lists three connection methods for the Arcade Stick; for the Arcade Controller, the manufacturer describes a low-profile casing and a glass front panel.
  • The glass surface doesn’t prove that it offers an advantage against reflections in a bright room. The models listed aren’t PS5 models.

Razer

The Kitsune is a leverless option with direction buttons for PS5 and PC.

  • Razer specifies a low-profile design, a detachable USB-C cable and a tournament lock.
  • The manufacturer’s claims of faster or error-free inputs aren’t an independently measured comparative advantage.

MAYFLASH

The F500 FLAT Elite is an all-button model for buyers looking to explore several connection options.

  • MAYFLASH specifies Sanwa buttons and several system modes.
  • For PS5 fighting games, the manufacturer requires a separately available converter, so a platform list alone doesn’t confirm unconditional compatibility.

Joybuy products on this topic

The Joybuy products below are for players who prefer to enter directions using individual buttons and want a leverless layout.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

The all-button layout is a good fit for players who prefer to enter directions using individual buttons.

The product name states that it’s compatible with Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android.

Connect via Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz or cable; the product name specifies hot-swappable mechanical Fast-Trigger switches.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is a “PS4” label enough for every PS5 fighting game?

No, the label alone doesn’t confirm compatibility. PlayStation Germany explains that specially licensed peripherals are supported for PS5 games and supported PS4 games. Check the exact model variant and the game you intend to play; for PS5 fighting games, MAYFLASH also specifies that the F500 FLAT Elite requires a separately available converter.

How do I set up a Daija with a PC or Xbox?

For the Xbox version, Nacon explains that you should select the system mode on the device and connect the stick using the supplied cable. For a PlayStation console, choose the Daija version specifically designed for it instead.

Will a different arcade controller get rid of reflections on my gaming screen?

No, changing controllers won’t remove screen reflections. BenQ Germany lists incoming and reflected light as possible causes of glare, so check the screen’s position and lighting separately from how clearly you can see the controller buttons.