Which option is right for you?

Garden planners using several devices

If you edit sketches or plans on several devices, a shared storage location on your own network can make them easier to access, without requiring a public cloud for storage.

Garden planners with important original files

If you want to restore plans after accidental deletion, a fault or damage at the storage location, make sure you have a separate backup and check that you can restore files from it. The Federal Office for Information Security recommends keeping backups somewhere other than the location where the original data is stored.

Small planning groups

If several authorised people need project files, make sure sharing permissions match the people who actually need access. If your association holds personal data, you should also take steps to protect it separately.

What should you look for when buying?

NAS on your own network

A good fit if: several devices or authorised users need to use the same folders of plans.

Things to consider: Drives, setup and ongoing maintenance all add to your planning; a NAS is not a substitute for a separate backup.

External USB hard drive

A good fit if: you create most of your plans on one computer and don’t need shared network storage.

Things to consider: You’ll need to connect the drive to make backups; you may also need to unplug it and connect it to other devices.

What you need What to look for when buying Who it matters most to
Local storage without the cloud Check local sharing options, setup and storage location; consider cloud synchronisation separately in relation to the way you want to work. If I want to keep plans on my own storage devices rather than with a public cloud provider, the actual storage location matters. Around 36 % of consumers put local control of their data first.
Restoring files after data loss Check how to back up files to a separate device and test restoring them. If I need important original files to remain available after deletion, a fault or damage at the storage location, a separate, restorable copy is essential. Around 29 % of consumers prioritise being able to restore their plans.
Sharing files Check support for the devices you use, as well as user accounts and folder permissions. If I want to access plans from several devices or share them with other authorised users, access and permissions should match the people who need them. Around 21 % of consumers prioritise sharing.
Storage and ongoing maintenance Check what’s included, drive compatibility, your preferred storage configuration and connections against the devices you already own. If I want suitable usable storage without too much ongoing maintenance, I need to consider the drives and storage configuration together. Around 14 % of consumers prioritise capacity and day-to-day running.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming a NAS is a complete backup solution

    Even a centrally stored file can be deleted or lost if the storage location is damaged.

    As well as storing files on your NAS, keep a separate copy and test that you can restore important plans.

    Remember to factor in a separate backup device, along with the time needed for regular backups and restore tests.

  • Assuming a ‘private cloud’ is the same as a public cloud

    Storing files locally and synchronising them with public cloud services can be separate features.

    Check where plans are stored on the model you’re considering, and which synchronisation features are enabled for the way you work.

  • Budgeting only for the NAS enclosure

    An empty enclosure does not automatically include the drives needed to store your files. UGREEN explicitly states that the NASync DH2300 requires separate hard drives.

    Before buying, check what’s included and whether the drives you want to use are compatible with the specific model.

A guide to relevant brands

Synology

The DS223j is one example of a NAS for storing files locally and accessing them from different devices.

  • Synology describes Cloud Sync as a separate feature for synchronising with public cloud services.
  • Information about the DS223j should not be taken to apply to the setup of every Synology model.

QNAP

According to QNAP, the TS-233 is a personal NAS with two drive bays, Gigabit Ethernet and a USB copy button.

  • The two bays and USB copy button may be useful for local storage and copying files.
  • According to QNAP, the TS-233’s memory cannot be upgraded.

TerraMaster

The F2-425 is a two-bay NAS with a 2.5 GbE connection, according to the manufacturer.

  • This connection may be worth considering if the rest of your network equipment supports it too.
  • The connection specification is not a measured transfer speed for your files. The F2-425 and F2-425 Plus are different models.

UGREEN

The NASync DH2300 is a two-bay model with local storage and a 1 GbE connection.

  • Alongside local storage, UGREEN describes synchronisation with cloud storage.
  • According to UGREEN, hard drives are not included. Check the setup and configure it to suit the local workflow you want.

Joybuy products

Matching products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Do I really need a NAS for allotment garden plans?

If you mainly edit files on one computer, an external hard drive can be a simple way to start making separate backup copies. A NAS is more suitable if several devices need shared storage. In either case, check that you can restore a backup.

Can I use a NAS without a public cloud?

For the DS223j, Synology describes managing your own files and synchronising with public cloud services as separate features. Check the setup for the model you choose, and don’t enable cloud synchronisation for your plan folders if you want to keep them local.

How can I protect plans against deletion or damage at the storage location?

Keep a separate copy, test restoring it and, to protect against damage to the entire storage location, keep a backup away from home. The Federal Office for Information Security recommends checking that backups can be restored.

What should I consider if other people need access to the files?

Set up sharing permissions to match the people who are authorised to access the files. If your association’s records contain personal data, the Hessian Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information explains how to protect this kind of association data from unauthorised use. The requirements that apply to your files depend on their content and how you use them; storing them locally does not, on its own, answer this question.

What changes if I access the NAS over the internet?

Remote access is an additional choice and isn’t needed if you only want to store files locally. The Federal Office for Information Security describes a VPN as an encrypted connection over the internet and notes that it may reduce speeds.