Which arcade controller is right for you?

Players using a wired headset

If you want to use the controller for game audio and, where available, voice chat, check the audio socket and connection mode for the exact model. For example, Nacon lists these features for the PlayStation Daija.

Console players with a specific fighting game in mind

Check that the exact controller version works with both your console and your game. PlayStation notes that not every accessory works with every PS5 title, and recommends checking compatibility with the manufacturer.

Players deciding on a layout

Decide whether you prefer entering directions with a joystick or individual buttons. HORI describes joystick models, while Razer lists the Kitsune as a controller with four movement buttons. Check the headphone connection separately, whichever layout you choose.

What should you look for when choosing one?

First check support for your game and platform, then consider how you want to connect your headset, and finally choose your preferred input layout. This helps you avoid assuming that a suitable socket or design automatically means full compatibility.

Criteria What to check before buying Who should pay particular attention?
Headset, game audio and chat Check audio output, microphone or chat support, the 3.5 mm socket, and the supported wireless or wired connection mode for the exact model. If I want to use a wired headset connected to the controller for game audio and, where available, chat, I’ll check the socket and operating mode. Around 34% of consumers would prioritise a direct headset connection.
Game and platform compatibility Check the full model name, console generation, specific fighting game and, where applicable, firmware. If I want to play a particular 2D fighter on my console or PC, that exact combination needs to be supported. Around 33% of consumers would prioritise compatibility with their game and system.
Joystick or directional buttons Check the input style you prefer and the button layout of the exact model. If I’m choosing between joystick movements and individual directional buttons, the layout that suits the way I play is my main consideration. Around 20% of consumers would prioritise the layout.
Noise and desk space Compare the controller’s dimensions with the space available, and consider mechanical noise separately from its headset features. If I play in a shared or cramped space, I need a controller that fits and should take the noise from the joystick and buttons into account. Around 13% of consumers would prioritise space requirements and consideration for others.

Common buying misconceptions

  • A headset socket doesn’t mean audio works in every mode

    For the MAYFLASH F700 Elite, the manufacturer specifies audio and chat on PS5, PS4 and PC in XInput mode over a 2.4 GHz or wired connection. This doesn’t automatically apply to other modes.

    Check whether game audio and, where available, chat are supported for your exact model, platform and connection mode.

  • Similar model names don’t necessarily mean the same platform version

    HORI lists the Fighting Stick α SPF-013U for PlayStation and Windows, while the AB11-001U is for Xbox and Windows. The 8BitDo Arcade Stick for Switch and Windows is also distinct from the brand’s Xbox products.

    Compare the full model number and platform list, rather than relying on the brand or product series name alone.

  • A headset won’t make the joystick and buttons quieter

    A headset changes what you hear, but it won’t muffle the controller’s mechanical noise for other people in the room.

    If noise is important, consider it separately from the headset features, and don’t assume one design will be quieter than another.

  • Don’t assume older multi-platform sticks work with PS5 without checking

    MAYFLASH specifies a compatible MagicBoots-S5 adapter and firmware requirements for using the F500 Elite with PS5.

    Before buying, check the specific firmware, the adapter required and support for the game you want to play.

Key brands at a glance

Nacon

The Daija is an option for PlayStation players looking for a joystick and a direct wired headset connection.

  • Nacon lists a 3.5 mm socket for audio and chat, as well as Sanwa controls, for the PlayStation Daija.
  • These details apply to this model and aren’t an independent comparison of its performance or durability.

HORI

The Fighting Stick α range includes separate PlayStation and Xbox versions for players who prefer a joystick layout.

  • HORI lists PS5, PS4 and Windows support, plus a 3.5 mm socket, for the SPF-013U. The manufacturer says the casing can be opened for customisation and maintenance.
  • The AB11-001U is the Xbox and Windows version. The model numbers and platform lists aren’t interchangeable.

MAYFLASH

The Elite models differ in platform support and headset modes, so check the specific combination before buying.

  • For the F700 Elite, MAYFLASH lists audio and chat on PS5, PS4 and PC in XInput mode over 2.4 GHz or a wired connection. For the F500 Elite, the manufacturer lists headset audio and chat on PS4 and Xbox One.
  • According to the manufacturer, the F700 Elite isn’t compatible with Xbox Series X|S; using the F500 Elite with PS5 requires a specific adapter and firmware conditions.

8BitDo

The range includes Xbox controllers with either a joystick or an all-button layout, as well as a differently designed arcade stick for Switch and Windows.

  • 8BitDo lists a 3.5 mm socket on both the Arcade Stick for Xbox and the Arcade Controller for Xbox.
  • The Xbox features shouldn’t be assumed to apply to the separately named Arcade Stick for Switch and Windows.

Razer

The Kitsune is a leverless option for PS5 and PC players who want to enter directions using individual buttons.

  • Razer lists four movement buttons and a low-profile casing.
  • Its input style differs from a joystick model. Plan how to connect your headset separately for your particular setup.

Related products at Joybuy

This selection is for players who want a leverless, button-based layout for 2D fighters. Check how to connect your headset separately for your setup.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master leverless controller for Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller for Switch 2/Switch/PC/iOS/Android

The leverless, all-button layout is designed for players who prefer to enter directions using buttons.

The product name lists Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android as supported platforms, along with wired, Bluetooth and 2.4 GHz connections.

The product name states that the mechanical switches are hot-swappable. Check separately how to connect your headset for your setup.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Will a headset work with every arcade stick that has a 3.5 mm socket, in every connection mode?

No. A socket alone doesn’t confirm that audio works in every mode. For the F700 Elite, MAYFLASH explicitly lists audio and chat on PS5, PS4 and PC in XInput mode over 2.4 GHz and wired connections. Check the details for your model and headset type.

Can I use a PS4 arcade stick with any PS5 fighting game?

Not necessarily. PlayStation notes that not every accessory works with every PS5 title, and recommends confirming support for the specific model and game with the manufacturer.

What should I bear in mind when setting it up and replacing parts later?

Compare the casing dimensions with your desk and leave enough room for your hands and cables. HORI says the Fighting Stick α casing can be opened for customisation and maintenance; follow the instructions for your exact model when replacing parts.