Which controller is right for you?

Players with limited desk space

If there’s little room beside your keyboard or screen, compare the actual footprint and allow space for your hands and cables. HORI, MAYFLASH and 8BitDo list different dimensions for their respective models.

Puzzle fans with a specific gaming device

If you play on a PC or a particular console, check the full model name and stated platform against your own device. Even if the controller is compatible with your device, that doesn’t guarantee a particular puzzle will accept the inputs you want to use.

Fans of different arcade controls

Levers, retro joysticks and directional buttons offer different designs and button layouts. The specifications from HORI, MAYFLASH, Speedlink and 8BitDo can help you check which one suits the actions your game actually requires.

What should you look for when buying?

Start with your gaming device and the space available on your desk. Then decide which inputs your puzzle needs, and whether a wired or wireless connection will work better for your setup.

Priority What to check before buying Who is it important to?
Desk space and room for your hands Available width and depth, including hand position and cable routing; dimensions of the specific model variant. If I need to fit a controller, my hands and cables on a small desk, usable space matters to me. Around 31% of consumers put footprint first.
Compatibility with your device and game Full model name, supported system, and the controller and button options available in the specific game. If I play on a particular console or PC, I want to avoid finding that my device or puzzle won’t accept the inputs. Around 25% of consumers prioritise compatibility with their device and game.
Directional and action inputs Lever or directional buttons, the action buttons you need and, where applicable, remappable inputs. If I play classic puzzles, I want to choose controls that suit the actions I actually need, rather than focusing solely on a high button count. Around 25% of consumers prioritise the type of input.
Connection and setup Suitable USB port, any wireless receiver required, and the connection method supported by your device. If I want to avoid cables on my desk or keep setup simple, I pay particular attention to the connection and any accessories needed. Around 19% of consumers prioritise connection and setup.

Common buying mistakes

  • Comparing height but not footprint

    According to the manufacturer, the 8BitDo Arcade Controller is 22 mm high, but at 301 × 201 mm it still needs a suitably large area of desk space.

    Measure the width and depth of the space you plan to use, and remember to allow room for your hands too.

  • Assuming similarly named HORI Mini versions are the same

    HORI offers separate Fighting Stick Mini versions for Nintendo Switch and PlayStation.

    Check the full model name and stated platform against your gaming device.

  • Assuming every puzzle needs eight action buttons

    Speedlink lists four fire buttons for the Competition Pro Extra USB, while the HORI and MAYFLASH models mentioned here have eight buttons. Which ones you need depends on your game’s button mapping.

    Make a note of the actions you need in the game and check how they’re assigned before choosing based on button count.

  • Updating the firmware without checking the F101 hardware version

    MAYFLASH warns that F101 devices with a newer circuit board don’t support earlier firmware versions.

    Follow the manufacturer’s instructions for the hardware version you’ve identified.

Key brands at a glance

HORI

The Fighting Stick Mini is a lever controller for space-conscious setups; the Switch and PlayStation versions are separate models.

  • HORI lists a footprint of around 8 × 6 inches, eight buttons, a cable and rubber feet for the Switch version.
  • The dimensions alone don’t tell you whether there’s enough room for your hands. Check the exact platform version and your game’s button mapping.

MAYFLASH

The F101 is for players looking for a lever and a choice of PC input modes.

  • MAYFLASH lists dimensions of 27,8 × 19,8 × 11,5 cm, USB, and XInput and DirectInput for PC.
  • Remember to allow for the footprint and cable routing when planning your setup. According to MAYFLASH, the right firmware depends on the hardware version.

8BitDo

The range includes different designs: an Arcade Stick with a lever and a low-profile Arcade Controller without one.

  • For the Arcade Stick, 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2,4 GHz and USB-C, with dimensions of 303 × 203 × 111,5 mm. The Arcade Controller uses directional buttons.
  • According to 8BitDo, the Arcade Controller measures 301 × 201 × 22 mm: its low height doesn’t mean it has a particularly small footprint. The two product designs aren’t interchangeable.

Speedlink

The Competition Pro Extra USB is a retro joystick for compatible games on Windows PCs.

  • Speedlink lists four fire buttons and DirectInput. According to the manufacturer, the included games pack is for Windows only.
  • Check whether your puzzle supports DirectInput or remappable controls; the button count alone doesn’t guarantee that the controller will work with your game.

Joybuy products for leverless arcade controls

This selection is for players looking for a low-profile, all-button arcade controller without a joystick lever.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller for Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller for Switch 2/Switch/PC/iOS/Android

The all-button hitbox design is ideal for players looking for arcade controls without a joystick lever.

The product name lists Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android. Before buying, check that your specific game and device support the inputs.

Connection options include Bluetooth, 2,4 GHz and a wired connection. The product name also mentions replaceable mechanical switches with a Fast-Trigger function.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does the word ‘Mini’ mean the controller will fit on my desk?

No. Compare the footprint of the exact model with the space available, and allow room for your hands and cables. HORI lists dimensions of around 8 × 6 inches for its Fighting Stick Mini for Nintendo Switch; MAYFLASH lists the F101 at 27,8 × 19,8 cm.

What should I check when setting up on a PC or Switch?

First, check that the exact model variant is designed for your device, then look at the game’s input options. MAYFLASH lists XInput and DirectInput for the F101 on PC; with an 8BitDo Arcade Stick, the connection type and mode need to suit your device.

Will a wireless arcade stick require ongoing extra purchases?

That depends on the specific model and what’s included in the box. 8BitDo lists a rechargeable battery and an included 2,4-GHz adapter for the Arcade Stick; before buying, check which connection and accessories your device requires.

What if a controller is faulty or an online order isn’t right for me?

If a product is faulty, you have statutory rights against the seller; these are separate from any voluntary guarantee. The Verbraucherzentrale also explains that online purchases generally come with a 14-day right to cancel, subject to conditions and exceptions.

What should I look for when it comes to product safety in Germany?

Check the information and documentation required for the specific product. For products covered by its market surveillance, the Bundesnetzagentur lists CE marking, manufacturer details and German-language instructions among the points to check. The European Union explains that CE marking is only required for products covered by relevant harmonised rules that require it.