Which controller is right for you?

Combo trainers with a specific tournament setup

If you want to use the same input method on your training setup as you do in competition, check the exact platform variant and the event organiser’s rules. PlayStation lists certain officially licensed arcade sticks as compatible with PS5 games and supported PS4 games. Compatibility still depends on the specific model and game.

Players practising in a shared room

If you practise often, consider button and lever noise separately. Manufacturers describe quieter versions of individual components, but that doesn’t mean the entire stick will be quiet in your room.

Students short on desk space

Allow room not just for the case, but also for your hands, lever movement and cables. If you want to put your controller away after practising, a specifically compact design could be handy. That alone says nothing about noise or performance in play.

What should you look for when buying?

What matters What to check before buying Who should consider it?
Compatibility Check the model number, training setup, game and any adapter or firmware requirements. If you switch between console and PC, or between different console variants, the controller needs to work with your specific setup. Around 31% of consumers would consider compatibility their most important buying concern.
Noise Assess the buttons and lever separately for the exact version; if you’re modifying it, check that replacement parts will fit. If you practise in a shared room, both button presses and lever noise could be disruptive. Around 25% of consumers would make lower noise levels their most important buying concern.
Input method Choose a lever or All-Button layout to suit how you plan to play, and check tournament rules on additional features. If you use a lever in competition, you should practise those exact movements; an All-Button layout uses a different input method. Around 25% of consumers would put a competition-ready input method first.
Space and storage Compare the case dimensions with the available desk space, and allow for your hands, lever movement and storage location. If your desk has little free space or you want to put the controller away after practising, its footprint and portability matter. Around 19% of consumers would consider space requirements their most important buying concern.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming similarly named console variants are interchangeable

    A PlayStation model isn’t automatically the right version for Xbox. The manufacturer’s stated PS5 setup for the MAYFLASH F300 Elite also requires firmware V1.15 and the MagicBoots-S5 adapter.

    Before buying, compare the full model number with your system and game.

    Depending on the setup, you may need additional hardware.

  • Assuming “silent” components make for a quiet controller

    Descriptions of quieter buttons or a quieter lever refer to different components. They don’t tell you how noisy the entire controller will be.

    Assess the buttons and lever separately. If you’re modifying the controller, check that the replacement parts fit your exact version.

    A modification may require compatible replacement parts and extra installation work.

  • Confusing programmable features with tournament approval

    Whether a feature is allowed depends on the event organiser. Among other things, Evo’s published rules prohibit hardware macros and rapid-fire.

    Read the rules for your specific tournament before practising with these features.

Brands to consider

HORI

HORI offers traditional lever sticks in separate PlayStation and Xbox versions, as well as a compact Fighting Stick Mini for PlayStation.

  • For the Fighting Stick α, HORI lists HAYABUSA components and a case with maintenance access. The manufacturer describes the Fighting Stick Mini as easy to store and carry.
  • The model number matters: SPF-013U and AB11-001U are different platform variants. The listed features don’t indicate a specific noise level.

MAYFLASH

MAYFLASH offers models including the F300 Elite, F500 Elite and F700 Elite, each with different features and platform requirements.

  • The manufacturer lists Sanwa components for the F300 Elite. Its stated PS5 setup requires firmware V1.15 and MagicBoots-S5.
  • MAYFLASH describes the F500 Elite as having a larger, heavier case. Platform compatibility for one model doesn’t automatically apply to another.

8BitDo

8BitDo offers separate arcade stick versions for Switch and Windows, and for Xbox and Windows.

  • For the Switch/Windows model, the manufacturer lists several connection options and programmable macros.
  • These features don’t demonstrate PS5 compatibility or prove that hardware macros are allowed in your tournament.

Qanba

Qanba also sells individual components for buyers considering quieter buttons.

  • Qanba describes its Gravity-KS buttons, with silicone cushioning, as a silent version.
  • The manufacturer’s description doesn’t prove that a modified controller will be quiet overall, or that the buttons will fit every case.

Razer

Razer’s Kitsune is an All-Button controller listed as compatible with PS5 and PC.

  • The manufacturer describes it as having four directional buttons and optical switches.
  • The claimed reduction in input errors is the manufacturer’s own claim, not independent evidence that it will improve your combos.

Related products from Joybuy

This selection includes a leverless controller for practising with separate directional buttons.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

The All-Button layout is a good fit if you use separate directional buttons instead of a lever in tournaments.

Supported platforms: Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android.

Connections: Bluetooth, 2.4G and wired; hot-swappable fast-trigger switches.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is “PS4 compatible” enough for practising with a PS5 game?

Not necessarily. Check compatibility with the specific model and game. PlayStation lists certain officially licensed arcade sticks as compatible with PS5 games and supported PS4 games. The manufacturer’s stated PS5 setup for the MAYFLASH F300 Elite requires firmware V1.15 and MagicBoots-S5.

How can I check which inputs the game registers while I practise?

In Street Fighter 6, you can use the input history in Training Mode to check the inputs that have been registered. This shows you what the game has picked up, but doesn’t prove that a particular controller design will improve your combos.

Are programmable macros allowed in tournaments?

That depends on the event organiser. Among other things, Evo’s published rules prohibit hardware macros and rapid-fire, but allow macros from the game’s input menu. Check the rules for your specific tournament rather than assuming they apply to other events.

What should I consider when maintaining my controller or fitting quieter replacement parts?

A case that opens can make it easier to access the components, but always check the information for your specific model. Before making any changes, check the dimensions and connections of the replacement parts. Quieter buttons won’t automatically eliminate lever noise.

What basic rights apply when buying online from a trader?

In the EU, distance purchases generally come with a 14-day right to cancel, starting from delivery, subject to legal exceptions. Depending on the circumstances, you may have to pay the return postage. The statutory guarantee for goods is generally at least two years and applies against the seller; exceptions and conditions depend on the circumstances.