Who these controllers are for

Players with specific input needs

If you’re practising a particular platform game, check that its required directional and button inputs match the controller and your PC or console. HORI, MAYFLASH and 8BitDo offer variants for different platforms and input modes.

Players with a small desk

If you play alongside study materials or a keyboard and want to put the controller away afterwards, check its desk footprint and height separately. 8BitDo lists the Arcade Controller as measuring 301 × 201 × 22 mm; HORI USA gives the Fighting Stick Mini’s dimensions as approximately 8 × 6 inches.

Players sharing a room

If there are other people in the room, consider the noise made by the joystick and buttons. Qanba describes components in the Q8 as ‘Silent’; this is the manufacturer’s wording, not proof of a particular noise level in your room.

What to consider when choosing

Compact joystick stick

A good fit if: you want to practise joystick movements and put the controller away afterwards. HORI’s Fighting Stick Mini models are designed for different platforms, depending on the variant.

Consider: the joystick, your hands and the cable all need space; the Mini models mentioned are wired.

All-button controller

A good fit if: you want to practise entering directions with individual buttons rather than a joystick, and your game supports this layout. 8BitDo lists Windows and Switch as platforms for some models, while Razer lists PS5 and PC for others.

Consider: getting used to directional buttons takes practice; a low-profile case doesn’t necessarily take up less desk space.

Priority What to check when buying Who it matters most to
Inputs and platform Check the game’s required actions, directional input style, exact model variant and supported system. If I’m practising a particular platform game, I want to match its inputs to the controller layout and gaming system. For around 33% of consumers, suitable inputs and platform compatibility come first.
Desk space and storage Measure the available width and depth, and allow for the wrist rest, cable routing and the height of your storage space. If I need to put the controller away after playing, I check desk space and height separately. Around 27% of consumers prioritise usable desk space and storage.
Consideration for flatmates Check the exact joystick and button variant and, if possible, assess its noise under your own room conditions. If I play in a shared room, I want to take input noise into account without assuming that a label such as ‘Silent’ means completely silent. Consideration for flatmates comes first for around 20% of consumers.
Accessories and setup Check what’s included, the connection type and any platform-specific requirements for additional accessories. If my console needs extra accessories or specific setup steps, I want to know before buying. Setup requirements and accessories come first for around 20% of consumers.

Buying decisions to check

  • Assuming ‘low-profile’ means it takes up little desk space

    According to 8BitDo, the Arcade Controller is 22 mm high, but its base measures 301 × 201 mm.

    Measure the width and depth of your gaming space, and allow room for your hands and the cable. Check the height too if you plan to store the controller away.

  • Assuming similarly named Mini sticks are for the same platforms

    HORI describes separate Fighting Stick Mini models for Switch and PC, and for PS5, PS4 and Windows.

    Check the full model name and supported platform on the relevant product page.

  • Taking ‘Silent’ to mean you can play without disturbing anyone

    Qanba uses ‘Silent’ to describe certain Q8 components; this doesn’t tell you what noise level to expect in a student room.

    Check the exact component variant and, if possible, assess the input noise under your own room conditions.

  • Overlooking the MAYFLASH F300 setup requirements

    For the PS4, Xbox One and Xbox 360, MAYFLASH requires an additional wired controller to be connected when using the F300.

    Check this requirement for your gaming system and make sure you have the necessary accessory.

Key brands at a glance

8BitDo

The range includes a joystick stick and an all-button controller, with options for different platforms and input preferences.

  • 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and wired USB-C as connection options for the Arcade Stick.
  • The Xbox model is a separate variant, not a guaranteed feature of the Switch/Windows version. According to 8BitDo, the Arcade Controller measures 301 × 201 × 22 mm.

HORI

The Fighting Stick Mini is a compact joystick option, with separate model variants for different platforms.

  • HORI USA gives the Fighting Stick Mini models’ case size as approximately 8 × 6 inches.
  • The models described are wired. According to HORI, the SPF-038U model for PlayStation and Windows doesn’t have a touchpad.

MAYFLASH

The F300 offers switchable directional input, while the F500 Elite is a larger joystick option.

  • MAYFLASH lists switchable D-pad/analogue stick mode for the F300 and Sanwa components for the F500 Elite.
  • The F300 requires an additional wired controller for PS4, Xbox One and Xbox 360. According to MAYFLASH, the F500 Elite has a base measuring 36.2 × 23.3 cm.

Qanba

The Q8 is a PC stick option for anyone specifically looking for joystick and button components described by the manufacturer as ‘Silent’.

  • Qanba lists PC compatibility for the Q8 and describes certain components as ‘Silent’.
  • The manufacturer’s wording isn’t an independent noise comparison and doesn’t prove that the controller is suitable for every console.

Razer

The Kitsune is a low-profile all-button controller for PS5 and PC.

  • Razer describes it as having four directional buttons instead of a joystick.
  • The manufacturer’s claims about input errors relate to its marketing for fighting games and don’t prove an advantage when practising platform games.

Related products from Joybuy

The selection below features a leverless all-button controller for practising with directional buttons instead of a joystick.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master leverless controller for Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller for Switch 2/Switch/PC/iOS/Android

This all-button controller is worth considering if you want to practise entering directions with buttons rather than a joystick.

Listed in the product name: Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android; Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz or wired connection; hot-swappable fast-trigger mechanical switches and RGB.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is the console listed enough to know whether it’ll work with my platform game?

No. Check the exact model variant and the inputs your game requires. HORI offers different Fighting Stick Mini models for Switch/PC and PlayStation/Windows; MAYFLASH lists switchable input modes for the F300 and requires an additional connected controller for certain consoles.

What accessories might I need for the MAYFLASH F300?

For PS4, Xbox One and Xbox 360, MAYFLASH requires an additional wired controller to be connected to the F300. Check this requirement for your system and make sure you have the necessary accessory.

How do I connect the 8BitDo Arcade Stick to a Windows PC via USB?

For a wired Windows connection, 8BitDo’s instructions say to set the mode switch to X and connect the stick via USB-C. Then check the button mapping in the game you want to play.

Can I return an arcade controller bought online?

In Germany, consumers generally have a 14-day right to cancel a distance contract with a commercial seller. For goods, the period generally starts when you receive them; exceptions and possible return costs should be checked separately. Section 312g of the German Civil Code (BGB) governs the right to cancel, and the EU consumer information site Your Europe explains when the cancellation period for goods begins.