If keeping button noise to a minimum is your priority when practising combos, check which buttons are fitted and, for a fightstick, the joystick too. Qanba’s “Silent” labels are the manufacturer’s descriptions, not comparable noise measurements. An all-button controller may suit you if you want separate directional buttons and a low-profile design; if you want to practise joystick movements, a traditional fightstick may be a better fit. You should also check compatibility with your console and game version, as well as the specific switches and casing.
Who are the different controllers for?
Considerate players
You practise combos while someone else in the room needs some peace and quiet, so you want to take button noise and, where applicable, joystick noise into account. Qanba describes certain buttons and the Q8’s joystick as “Silent”; this is not a measurement of noise levels in a room.
All-button beginners
You want to learn directional inputs using individual buttons and need a surface with enough room for your controller. Allow time to get used to the layout; a GameStar hands-on review notes that the thumb button for “Up” can take some getting used to in particular.
Console players
You practise on PS5 or switch between systems. Check compatibility with your exact controller model and game version rather than relying on a general platform compatibility claim.
What should you look for when buying?
First decide whether you want to keep using joystick movements or learn to use directional buttons. Then compare noise-related features, system compatibility and the space required by the specific model.
| What matters |
What to check before buying |
Who is this important to? |
| Noise when pressing repeatedly |
Check the buttons and, for a fightstick, the joystick too; “Silent” does not mean guaranteed silent play. |
If I practise in a shared room, I want to consider the noise from both types of input. Around 33% of consumers put noise reduction first. |
| Input layout for combos |
Compare the position of the directional buttons with the inputs you use most often; an all-button layout may take some getting used to, especially the thumb button for “Up”. |
If I practise certain combos repeatedly, I want a layout that suits my directional inputs. Around 27% of consumers prioritise input layout. |
| Console and game version compatibility |
Check the model, connection type, platform and game version; Mayflash limits PS5 use of the F700 FLAT Elite to fighting games. |
If I practise on a specific console, I want to be sure the controller and game version work together. Around 27% of consumers put platform compatibility first. |
| Desk space and storage |
Measure the available space and compare it with the dimensions of the specific controller; a compact design does not automatically mean less noise. |
If the controller needs to be put away after practice, I want to work out how much space it will take up beforehand. Around 13% of consumers prioritise space and storage. |
Which buying mistakes should you avoid?
-
Assuming “Silent” means silent
The label on individual components does not tell you how loud the complete controller will be during repeated combo practice in a room.
Check the buttons and joystick separately on the specific model. Before buying, find out whether you can assess the noise and feel of the buttons under the applicable returns policy.
-
Choosing an all-button controller without checking the layout
An all-button layout may take some getting used to; according to a GameStar hands-on review, this is particularly true of the thumb button for “Up”. Some circular movements may be easier with a joystick.
Consider the inputs you use most often and whether you want to switch to a different layout, rather than assuming it will automatically make combos easier to perform.
Unverified compatibility could mean you end up with a controller or adapter that does not work with your game.
Which brands are worth considering?
Qanba
The Q8 Silent is an option for PC players who want to use a joystick and buttons.
- Qanba describes the Q8’s joystick and buttons as “Silent”; Gravity-KS buttons are also available as separate components.
- These are the manufacturer’s descriptions, not comparable noise measurements. The Q8 is listed as compatible with PC.
Razer
The Kitsune is a low-profile all-button option for PS5 and PC.
- Razer lists optical switches, a cable clip and a lock switch.
- These features alone do not prove that it is quieter to use than other models.
8BitDo
The Arcade Controller is aimed at Windows and Switch players who want to use an all-button layout.
- 8BitDo lists hot-swappable switches and dimensions of 301 × 201 × 22 mm for this model.
- The manufacturer’s specifications do not list PS5 support or a measured noise level.
Mayflash
The F700 FLAT Elite is a larger all-button model; the F700 Elite is the separate joystick version.
- Mayflash lists 15 Sanwa buttons and several connection options for the FLAT Elite; the F700 Elite is listed with a Sanwa joystick.
- According to Mayflash, PS5 use of both models is limited to fighting games. The components included with each version are not the same.
Joybuy products for all-button practice
This selection is for anyone who wants to practise directional inputs for fighting games with a leverless or all-button controller.
No image available
BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller
A good fit if you want to practise directional inputs using buttons rather than a joystick.
Platforms listed in the product title: Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android.
The title lists Bluetooth, 2.4G and wired connections, as well as hot-swappable Fast Trigger mechanical switches.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Will any PS4 arcade stick work with a PS5 fighting game?
No, you cannot assume that they will. PlayStation lists support for officially licensed specialist peripherals, such as arcade sticks, with PS5 games and supported PS4 games. Even so, check the licence and the information for your specific controller and game. Mayflash explicitly limits PS5 use of the F700 FLAT Elite to fighting games.
What should I set up before my first combo practice session?
First, select the correct platform and connection mode. If your all-button controller has several SOCD modes, check how it handles simultaneous opposite directions, as Neutral and Priority modes produce different results.
Can I replace the buttons later?
For the 8BitDo Arcade Controller, the manufacturer lists a hot-swap PCB for compatible switches; Qanba sells Gravity-KS buttons as separate components. Before buying replacements, check the model, switch type and fitting dimensions. A feature on one model does not automatically apply to another.
What are my rights when shopping online in Germany?
For a distance sale of consumer goods, the statutory cancellation period is generally 14 days; for an ordinary delivery of goods, it starts when you receive them. The applicable exceptions and the specific cancellation information also matter. The Verbraucherzentrale explains that statutory consumer rights for faulty goods and a voluntary guarantee are different entitlements.
Can a faulty arcade controller go in household rubbish?
No. The German Environment Agency explains that waste electrical equipment must be collected separately; local recycling centres are one free option for disposal. If the batteries can be removed, dispose of them separately before handing the controller in.