Who plays classic puzzle games with an arcade controller?

PC puzzle gamers checking compatibility

If you want to play a particular puzzle game on your PC, check whether it supports gamepad input and lets you customise the button layout. Valve’s Steam Support explains that using gamepad input alone requires a game that supports gamepads.

Retro fans who want a lever-style feel

If you prefer moving a classic lever, check that the action buttons on your chosen model cover all the actions you need in the game. Speedlink lists four fire buttons for the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA.

Gamers sharing a desk

If you share your workspace, make sure the controller’s height, footprint and noise suit your surroundings. Speedlink describes the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA’s microswitches as loud and clicky; 8BitDo lists the Arcade Controller’s height as 22 mm.

What to look for when buying

Start with the input options for your specific game and the device you’ll use. Then compare control styles, space requirements and the platforms you want to use.

What matters What to check before buying Who it matters most to
Game and device compatibility Check the game version, device, supported input types and available button mapping options. If you want to use a controller with a particular puzzle game, check its input options first. Around 33% of consumers would put compatibility first.
Direction and action inputs Count the actions required in the game and check whether the direction and action buttons can be mapped as needed. If you prefer moving a lever to using individual direction buttons, choose a design that suits you. Around 27% of consumers would prioritise how the controls feel.
Desk space and noise Measure the space available for the controller, your hands and the cable; also check noise information. If you share a desk or play somewhere noise-sensitive, consider the space required and the sound of the switches. Around 27% of consumers would prioritise how well the controller suits their workspace.
Use across multiple platforms Check the full model name, supported platforms, connection method and any accessories required. If you want to use the controller with more than one of your devices, check the information for each device separately. Around 13% of consumers would put multi-platform use first.

Avoiding common buying pitfalls

  • “Puzzle game” doesn’t automatically mean controller support

    Input options vary from game to game. The Tetris web version lists keyboard and mouse controls, while Valve lists controller support for Tetris Effect: Connected.

    Before choosing a model, check the input options for the exact version of the game and the device it’s designed for.

  • Don’t assume similarly named 8BitDo models are the same

    8BitDo lists the Arcade Stick and Arcade Stick for Xbox as separate models with different platform support.

    Check the full model name and the manufacturer’s information for your device.

  • Don’t assume the MAYFLASH F300 works with consoles without extra requirements

    MAYFLASH says that using the F300 with PS4, Xbox One and Xbox 360 requires an additional wired controller to be connected.

    Before buying, check the connection process and which accessories you’ll need for your console.

    Depending on your console, you may also need a compatible wired controller.

  • Don’t mistake retro clicks for quiet operation

    Speedlink specifically describes the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA’s microswitches as loud and clicky.

    If you share a room, take noise levels into account when choosing a controller, rather than focusing only on its retro looks.

A guide to relevant brands

Speedlink

The COMPETITION PRO EXTRA is aimed at buyers looking for a straightforward retro joystick for a supported Windows PC.

  • Speedlink lists DirectInput, driver-free set-up and four fire buttons for this model.
  • The manufacturer describes the microswitches as loud and clicky. Speedlink says the included downloadable games only run on Windows.

8BitDo

The range includes lever models and a flat, leverless Arcade Controller. Platform support and controls vary by model.

  • 8BitDo lists the Arcade Stick for Switch and Windows, as well as the Arcade Controller with separate direction buttons.
  • Button mapping features and connection types can’t be assumed to apply to every model or game.

MAYFLASH

The F300 is a wired lever option for buyers considering PC input modes and customisation options.

  • MAYFLASH lists switchable XInput and DirectInput for PC, as well as replaceable components.
  • For PS4, Xbox One and Xbox 360, the manufacturer requires an additional wired controller to be connected.

Qanba

The Drone 2 is worth considering as a lever option if you’ll be using a PS5, PS4 or PC.

  • Qanba lists the Drone 2 for PS5, PS4 and PC.
  • This platform information doesn’t confirm support for any particular puzzle game.

Joybuy products for leverless arcade controls

This Joybuy selection is for consumers looking for leverless, all-button controls for PC games. First, check whether your specific game supports this type of input.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

The leverless, all-button design is worth considering if you prefer using individual buttons for directional inputs instead of a lever.

Listed in the product name as compatible with Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android; Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and wired connections; mechanical, replaceable switches.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Will an arcade stick work with every classic Tetris game?

No, you can’t tell from the game genre alone. The Tetris web version lists keyboard and mouse controls, while Valve lists controller support for Tetris Effect: Connected. Check the input options for the exact game version.

What should I do if my controller doesn’t work in a PC game?

First, check the input mode on your device and the game’s input settings. MAYFLASH lists XInput and DirectInput for the F300; Valve says that gamepad commands alone only work in games with gamepad support.

Should I choose a lever or individual direction buttons for classic puzzle games?

Choose the control style you prefer, then check that the game supports the inputs you need. A lever moves differently from a flat, all-button controller. Also check that you can map all the actions you need.

Are the different 8BitDo arcade sticks designed for the same devices?

No, platform support depends on the specific model. 8BitDo lists the Arcade Stick for Switch and Windows, and the Arcade Stick for Xbox for Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows. Similar or identical names aren’t a substitute for checking the full model name.

Is a clicky joystick suitable for a shared desk?

It depends on how sensitive your surroundings are to noise. Speedlink describes the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA’s microswitches as loud and clicky. Bear this in mind if other people are working in the room.