Start by choosing a controller that suits your gaming platform and the button layout you need. For beat ’em ups with multiple actions, consider a fightstick with the right features; for simpler classics, a four-button retro joystick may be all you need. Then check support for the specific game, as well as the space available and switch noise. A compact design, wireless connection and customisation are separate priorities.
Who are the different controllers suited to?
PC retro gamers who need multiple actions
If you want to play classic beat ’em ups at your desk using a joystick and action buttons you can map to suit your needs, check the game’s input mode and button layout. 8BitDo, MAYFLASH and Speedlink offer different input options and modes.
Console gamers who stick to one platform
If you mainly play on a particular console, choose the model explicitly designed for it rather than relying on a similar product name. HORI offers separate Fighting Stick α versions for PlayStation and Xbox.
Home office gamers short on space or sensitive to noise
If you need to put your controller away after playing or be considerate of others who can hear your inputs, consider its size and switch noise separately. HORI describes the Fighting Stick Mini as compact, while Speedlink says the Competition Pro Extra USB’s microswitches make a loud clicking sound.
What should you look for when buying?
First check platform and game support, then the button layout, followed by your requirements for space, noise and customisation.
| What matters to you |
What to check before buying |
Who should pay particular attention? |
| Platform and game |
Check the model version, console or operating system, connection type and support for the specific game. |
If I want to use the stick with my main platform and a particular game, I check that it supports both. Around 36% of consumers put platform and game compatibility first. |
| Button layout |
Compare the actions you need, the number and position of the buttons, and whether they can be remapped. |
If I want to reach several actions directly and map them to suit my needs, the layout is crucial for the games I play. Around 29% of consumers prioritise button layout and an arcade-style feel. |
| Space and noise |
Check the dimensions and how much desk space it takes up. Don’t treat descriptions of noise as measured sound levels. |
If I share my desk with work equipment or want to avoid disturbing others, I consider both the size and how audible the switches are. Around 21% of consumers prioritise space or noise. |
| Customisation |
Check the specific model’s button-mapping features, access to components and relevant manufacturer instructions. |
If I want to change the button mapping or components to suit my preferences, I need the right features on that particular model. Around 14% of consumers put customisation first. |
Which buying mistakes can you avoid?
-
Confusing similarly named fightsticks for different consoles
HORI offers the Fighting Stick α in separate PlayStation and Xbox versions. Similar product names don’t mean that both versions support the same consoles.
Before buying, check the full model number against the platform you use most.
-
Assuming a retro look means there are enough buttons
According to the manufacturer, the Speedlink Competition Pro Extra USB has four fire buttons, while the HORI Fighting Stick Mini has an eight-button layout. The right layout depends on the actions required by the game you want to play.
Count how many actions you need to reach directly before choosing a layout.
-
Assuming compact means quiet
Size and switch noise are separate features. Speedlink explicitly describes the Competition Pro Extra USB’s microswitches as loud and clicky; “Silent” is a Qanba product description, not an independent noise measurement.
If you play in a shared space, check the size and noise information separately.
Which brands are worth considering?
8BitDo
Arcade sticks for PC and different console versions; platform support depends on the specific model.
- For its Switch and PC stick, the manufacturer lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz wireless and USB-C, as well as button-mapping and profile features.
- The separate Xbox model lists 2.4 GHz wireless and USB-C. The console support of one model cannot be assumed to apply to another.
MAYFLASH
The F300 Elite and F500 Elite are wired fightsticks for buyers who want to consider input modes and customisation options.
- MAYFLASH lists XInput and DInput for the F500 Elite on PC, and describes the F300 Elite as having a mod-friendly design.
- Console and firmware information should match the exact model and version. A platform listing alone doesn’t confirm support for every game.
HORI
The Fighting Stick α models for PlayStation and Xbox, and the Fighting Stick Mini, differ in platform and design.
- According to the manufacturer, the Fighting Stick α’s casing opens for maintenance and customisation. HORI lists an eight-button layout and a size of around 8 × 6 inches for the Mini.
- The PlayStation and Xbox versions of the Fighting Stick α are separate models and shouldn’t be treated as interchangeable.
Speedlink
The Competition Pro Extra USB is a four-button joystick for retro games on Windows PC.
- Speedlink lists DirectInput and two round and two triangular fire buttons.
- The manufacturer explicitly describes the microswitches as loud and clicky, so check whether they’re suitable for your home office.
Qanba
According to the manufacturer, the Q8 Silent is a PC option with a joystick and buttons described as “Silent”.
- Qanba describes the joystick and buttons as “Silent”.
- The product description isn’t an independent noise measurement and doesn’t promise complete silence.
Joybuy products on this topic
This selection features a leverless arcade controller with an all-button layout, rather than a traditional joystick with action buttons.
No image available
BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller
For players looking for leverless controls instead of an arcade joystick.
All-button layout with mechanical hot-swap Fast Trigger switches. The product name lists Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android, along with Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz wireless and wired connections.
There’s no joystick, so check that this control style suits your game and input preferences.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is “PC-compatible” enough for every retro beat ’em up?
No. Also check controller support and button mapping in the specific game. For the F500 Elite, MAYFLASH lists XInput and DInput on PC; Speedlink lists DirectInput for the Competition Pro Extra USB.
How do I set up an arcade stick with multiple input modes?
Use the instructions for your model to select the mode intended for your device, then check the button mapping in your game. 8BitDo has separate Switch and PC modes for the Arcade Stick; MAYFLASH lists XInput and DInput on PC for the F500 Elite.
Do I need to replace components to change the button mapping?
Not necessarily: according to the manufacturer, the 8BitDo Arcade Stick has button-mapping and profile features. That’s different from making mechanical changes; HORI says the Fighting Stick α has a casing that opens for maintenance and customisation.
What are my rights in Germany if a controller bought online is faulty?
If a product is faulty, the seller is generally responsible under the statutory guarantee of conformity. This is different from a voluntary manufacturer’s warranty. Your Europe, the European Union’s consumer portal, states that this protection lasts for at least two years from the date you receive the goods. The Verbraucherzentrale also explains that online purchases generally come with a 14-day right to cancel, although exceptions may apply.