Who are the different controllers for?

Considerate evening gamers

If someone else in the room needs peace and quiet, consider game audio and mechanical noise separately. A headset affects audio output; QANBA separately markets its Gravity-KS buttons as noise-dampening. That doesn’t tell you how loud a complete controller is, though.

Players committed to one system

If you already use a particular console or PC, check the full model name against the platform list and the connection mode it’s designed for. For example, 8BitDo lists different arcade stick versions for Switch and Windows, and for Xbox and Windows.

Players short on space

If you want to put your controller away after playing or keep the room clear, compare its dimensions with the space you actually have available. With a wired model, you’ll also need to plan the route to your gaming system.

What should you look for when buying?

First, check compatibility with your system and input mode. Then consider the design, space required, cable routing and audio separately.

What matters What to check before buying Who is this especially important to?
Compatibility Check the full model name, platform and input mode. For the MAYFLASH F500 V2 with PS5, check the adapter and firmware configuration. If I’m looking for a controller for the system I already own, I mainly want to avoid choosing a version or connection mode that won’t work. Around 25 % of consumers cite compatibility as their main concern.
Being considerate in a shared room Consider audio output and mechanical noise separately. A headset tells you nothing about how loud the buttons and joystick are. If someone else in the room is asleep or needs peace and quiet, I want to be able to listen to game audio through a suitable headset without assuming that the buttons will be quieter. Around 25 % of consumers say being considerate is their main concern.
Space and storage Compare the controller’s dimensions with the space available. HORI describes the Fighting Stick Mini as around 8 × 6 inches; 8BitDo gives the Arcade Controller’s dimensions as 301 × 201 × 22 mm. If I need to put the controller away after playing in a shared bedroom, I want to choose a design that fits on the available shelf space. Around 20 % of consumers cite space as their main concern.
Cables and connection Check which wireless or wired modes are supported by your specific system. If you’re using a cable, plan its route through the room. Nacon specifies a 3-m cable for the Daija. If I don’t want a cable running across the room, I need the right wireless mode. If I’m using a cable, I need to route it safely. Around 15 % of consumers put cable routing and connection type first.
Arcade-style controls Decide whether you want to enter directions using a traditional joystick or individual buttons; these designs aren’t interchangeable. If I’m specifically looking for a joystick or an all-button layout for retro games, I want to choose the control style that suits me. Around 15 % of consumers say the feel of the controls is their main concern.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming similarly named 8BitDo versions are the same stick

    The Switch/Windows version and the Xbox/Windows version have different platform and connection specifications.

    Before buying, compare the full model name with your system, then check which connection type it’s designed for.

  • Assuming a ‘headset socket’ means ‘quiet buttons’

    A headset affects audio output. QANBA’s noise-dampening claim applies to separately sold buttons and doesn’t confirm the noise level of a complete stick.

    Consider game audio and mechanical noise separately. Before changing the buttons, check that their format and fit are right for your specific controller.

    You may need compatible replacement buttons and have extra work to do when fitting them.

  • Assuming a listed platform means the controller will work straight away

    Some ways of using MAYFLASH controllers may require extra hardware or the right firmware configuration.

    Before ordering, read the instructions for your exact model, console and intended connection method.

  • Planning for the controller’s footprint but not the cable route

    Even a compact wired stick needs a safe route to your gaming system. In the Drone 2’s instructions, QANBA recommends winding up the cable when it’s not in use to prevent it becoming a trip hazard.

    Plan where you’ll sit, where you’ll put the controller, how you’ll connect it and where you’ll store it.

Key brands at a glance

8BitDo

The range includes traditional arcade sticks for different systems, as well as a separate all-button controller.

  • According to 8BitDo, the Switch/Windows stick offers Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C. The manufacturer lists 2.4 GHz and USB-C for the Xbox version. These specifications don’t apply to both models.
  • The all-button controller replaces the feel of a joystick with direction buttons. Check the intended platform and connection for each version.

MAYFLASH

The F500 V2 is a larger joystick stick; the F500 FLAT is a separate all-button option.

  • For PC use with the F500 V2, MAYFLASH lists the XInput and DInput modes.
  • For PS5 use with the F500 V2, check the adapter and firmware configuration separately. For some consoles, MAYFLASH requires the F500 FLAT to be connected to an additional wired controller.

HORI

The Fighting Stick Mini is designed for users short on space. The larger Fighting Stick α has a casing that opens for maintenance and customisation.

  • HORI lists eight action buttons for the Mini and describes it as compact and easy to store.
  • According to HORI, the Mini doesn’t have a touchpad. The fact that the α opens up doesn’t prove that it’s quieter. The versions listed are for PlayStation and Windows.

QANBA

The Drone 2 is a joystick stick for PlayStation and PC, with a platform switch and headset socket. Gravity KS buttons are sold separately as replacements.

  • QANBA lists a 3.5-mm socket, platform switch and touchpad area for the Drone 2.
  • The manufacturer’s noise-dampening claim applies to Gravity KS buttons, not specifically to the Drone 2. It doesn’t confirm a measured noise level for the complete stick or that the buttons will fit every casing.

Nacon

The wired Daija is listed for PS5, PS4 and PC. According to Nacon, it has a headset socket.

  • Nacon lists a Sanwa joystick and action buttons, button-mapping software and a 3-m cable.
  • In a shared room, you’ll need to route a long cable so it’s out of the way. The manufacturer’s claims about professional performance are just that: manufacturer claims, not independent test results.

Joybuy products

This selection is for players who prefer to use buttons rather than a traditional joystick to enter directions.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master leverless controller for Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller for Switch 2/Switch/PC/iOS/Android

A good choice if you prefer to use buttons rather than a joystick to enter directions.

The product title lists Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android, along with Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and a wired connection. Check that your chosen device and connection mode work together.

The title also mentions hot-swappable mechanical switches.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Will every arcade stick work with every console?

No. Even the two 8BitDo stick versions have different platform lists. Check the full model name, your gaming system and the connection mode you need. If you plan to use the MAYFLASH F500 V2 with a PS5, you should also check the adapter and firmware configuration.

Will headphones make a stick quiet?

A compatible headset socket may let you listen to game audio and, where supported, chat through your headphones. The noise made by pressing buttons and moving the joystick is separate. Manufacturers don’t provide comparable noise measurements for the complete controllers.

How do I set up a controller with multiple modes?

First, select the platform and, if needed, the direction mode recommended by the manufacturer for your system. QANBA’s Drone 2 instructions describe a switch for PS5, PS4 and PC, with a choice of D-pad, left analogue stick or right analogue stick mode.

What should I bear in mind when cleaning and storing it?

Follow the instructions for your specific model. For the Drone 2, QANBA recommends using a dry cloth, unplugging it when it’s not in use and winding up the USB cable to prevent it becoming a trip hazard.

What are my rights if I return a product or find a fault after buying online in Germany?

Consumers buying online generally have a 14-day right to cancel, and you must notify the seller that you wish to cancel. The Verbraucherzentrale distinguishes between your statutory rights when goods are faulty and a voluntary guarantee. Check the terms and seller information for your specific purchase.