Which type of control is right for you?

Players in a dark room

If you want to find the lever and buttons in the dark, with the option to switch the lighting off, the Qanba Crystal may be worth considering: Qanba lists illuminated controls and several lighting modes.

Console shoot-’em-up players

The key question is whether your particular game accepts input from the controller. On PS5, support for the game itself or, with certain MAYFLASH configurations, the right adapter and firmware may be crucial.

Players with a preferred way to control direction

Consider whether you prefer to enter directions using an arcade lever or individual buttons. Also take into account the space it takes up and the support listed for your system.

What should you look for when buying?

Illuminated stick

A good fit if: You want a lever and would find illuminated controls easier to locate in a dark room.

Consider: According to the manufacturer, you can switch off the Qanba Crystal’s lighting. Also check whether your PS5 game supports PS4 joysticks.

Stick with no confirmed button lighting

A good fit if: You prefer a lever but don’t need illuminated action buttons.

Consider: A dynamic layout display, such as the one on the 8BitDo Arcade Stick, doesn’t confirm that the action buttons are illuminated.

All-button controls

A good fit if: You prefer to enter directions using individual buttons rather than a lever.

Consider: The button layout needs to suit the way you play; a slim design doesn’t necessarily mean it takes up little space.

Stick with a PS5 adapter configuration

A good fit if: You want to use a MAYFLASH F300 Elite or F500 Elite with a PS5 game.

Consider: For the configuration described, MAYFLASH specifies compatible firmware and an additional MagicBoots-S5 adapter. Check that the combination works with your game.

Consideration What to check before buying Who it matters to most
Game and platform compatibility Check the model, game version and system together, along with the input mode, adapter and firmware, if applicable. If I want to play a particular shoot-’em-up on my system, support for that specific game matters most to me. Around 29% of consumers say compatibility is their top buying priority.
Finding the controls in the dark Check which buttons and lever you’ll actually use are illuminated, and whether there’s an option to switch the lighting off. If I want to find the controls quickly in a dark room, switchable lighting matters to me. Around 24% of consumers say being able to find the controls in the dark is their top priority.
Lever or separate direction buttons Check that the direction layout, action buttons you need and the space it takes up suit the way you play. I want to enter directions in the way that feels right for me, using either a lever or individual buttons. Around 23% of consumers say the type of control is their top priority.
Connection and setup Check the connection modes supported by your system, and make sure there’s room for the cable or receiver. If my gaming area only has certain connections or a particular route for cables, the controller needs to fit. Around 12% of consumers put connectivity first.
Maintenance and extra accessories Check access to the casing, any replacement parts you might need, and model-specific adapter or firmware requirements. I want to know whether the controls can be maintained and what accessories my setup requires. Around 12% of consumers say maintenance and included accessories are their main consideration.

Common misconceptions

  • ‘PS5 compatible’ doesn’t automatically mean support for every shoot-’em-up

    Manufacturer claims may depend on a particular game, input mode or combination of adapter and firmware.

    Before ordering, check the exact game and the complete controller setup.

    For the PS5 setup described by MAYFLASH for the F300 Elite or F500 Elite, you’ll also need to allow for the MagicBoots-S5 adapter.

  • A changing button display isn’t the same as illuminated action buttons

    8BitDo describes the Arcade Stick as having a dynamic layout display. Qanba explicitly lists illuminated buttons and a lit lever for the Crystal.

    If you need lighting to find the controls, check exactly which controls are illuminated on the specific model and whether you can switch the lighting off.

  • A slim all-button model doesn’t necessarily take up little space

    According to the manufacturer, the 8BitDo Arcade Controller is 22 mm high and measures 301 × 201 mm. Its low profile alone doesn’t tell you how much space you’ll need.

    Measure the width and depth, and allow extra room for your hands and the connection.

Key brands at a glance

Qanba

The Crystal is a stick option with illuminated controls and a lighting mode that can be switched off.

  • Qanba lists several lighting modes for the buttons and lever.
  • According to Qanba, using the Crystal on PS5 requires a game that supports PS4 joysticks.

8BitDo

The models listed offer either lever controls or a slim all-button alternative for the specified Switch and Windows versions.

  • The Arcade Stick offers Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C, according to the manufacturer; the Arcade Controller uses separate direction buttons.
  • A dynamic layout display on the Arcade Stick doesn’t confirm that its action buttons are illuminated.

HORI

The Fighting Stick α SPF-013U is a stick option for the PlayStation and Windows systems listed for this model.

  • HORI says the SPF-013U casing can be opened for maintenance and customisation.
  • The Xbox version, AB11-001U, is a different model; the system information for the SPF-013U doesn’t automatically apply to it.

MAYFLASH

The F300 Elite and F500 Elite are stick options for which MAYFLASH describes a PS5 setup using compatible firmware and MagicBoots-S5.

  • For this setup, MAYFLASH lists model-specific firmware and the adapter as requirements.
  • These conditions don’t apply to all MAYFLASH models; for the F700 Elite, the manufacturer warns against PS5 games outside the fighting game genre, including shooting games.

NACON

The PlayStation version of the Daija is a wired stick alternative for the PS5, PS4 and Windows systems listed by the manufacturer.

  • NACON lists configurable buttons and an included 3-m cable.
  • Claims about performance and precision come from the manufacturer; they aren’t based on an independent shoot-’em-up test.

Joybuy products

This selection is for consumers considering an all-button controller with RGB lighting for shoot-’em-ups.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller (Switch 2/Switch/PC/iOS/Android)

The all-button design is for players who prefer to enter directions using individual buttons rather than a lever; RGB lighting is also listed.

This model offers Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and wired connections, as well as hot-swappable Fast-Trigger mechanical switches. Check that it supports your specific game and system before choosing this setup.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is ‘PS5 compatible’ enough for my PS5 shoot-’em-up?

No. On its own, it doesn’t confirm support for your specific game. Qanba makes PS5 use of the Crystal conditional on playing games that support PS4 joysticks; MAYFLASH explicitly warns that the F700 Elite isn’t for PS5 games outside the fighting game genre, including shooting games. Check the model, game and any required adapter and firmware together.

How do I set up a controller in a dark room?

First, choose a connection mode that works with your system, then check that you can comfortably reach the buttons you need in your setup. For the Qanba Crystal, the manufacturer lists several lighting modes, including an off setting; you can customise the button layout on the 8BitDo Arcade Controller using software.

Do I need an extra accessory to use a MAYFLASH stick on PS5?

For the PS5 setup MAYFLASH describes for the F300 Elite and F500 Elite, you’ll need the MagicBoots-S5 adapter and compatible firmware. This isn’t a general requirement for all arcade controllers.

What are my rights if the controller is faulty after purchase?

For goods bought in the EU, the European Union’s consumer information states that you generally have a minimum two-year legal guarantee from the date you receive them. Contact the seller; an additional manufacturer’s guarantee doesn’t replace your statutory rights.

How do I dispose of an old arcade controller in Germany?

According to Germany’s Federal Environment Ministry, electrical waste must be handed over to an authorised collection operator, such as a local authority collection point. Retailer take-back schemes are subject to additional conditions.