Which controller is right for you?

Players who want a stick for long sessions

If you want to play for hours with a stick and large action buttons, compare the size of the casing, the wrist rest and the button layout. MAYFLASH and NACON offer different casing and wrist-rest designs. Manufacturer information is no substitute for checking what feels comfortable to you.

Players committed to one platform

If you play on a particular PlayStation, Xbox, Switch or PC, check the full model variant and its compatibility with your game. HORI and 8BitDo offer different console versions; certain MAYFLASH models may also require an adapter and firmware.

Players who switch between setups

If you move between devices or gaming spaces, choose a connection that suits your setup. 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C for its Switch/Windows arcade stick, while the Xbox version lists 2.4 GHz and USB-C.

What should you look for when buying?

First decide whether you want a stick or separate direction buttons. Then check the model number, game, platform and connection type.

Buying criterion What to check Who is this important to?
Wrist rest and feel Check that the casing size, room for your hands and forearms, and the position of the stick and buttons suit your gaming space. If I play for several hours, I want somewhere comfortable to rest my hands and forearms, with the buttons within easy reach. Around 36% of consumers prioritise wrist-rest space and feel.
Game and platform compatibility Check your console or PC, game version, full model number, and any required adapters and firmware. If I want to make sure a specific game works on my device, the exact model variant matters to me. Around 29% of consumers prioritise game and platform compatibility.
Controls and maintenance Choose a stick or separate direction buttons to suit the movements you want to make; check the input mode and access to components on the exact version. If I prefer a particular way of entering directional movements or want to customise parts later, the control layout is essential. Around 21% of consumers prioritise controls and customisation options.
Connection and charging Consider the cable route, device ports, space for a wireless receiver and the charging requirements of the exact model. If I don’t want an awkward cable in my gaming space, wireless use, including the receiver and charging, needs to work with my setup. Around 14% of consumers prioritise choosing the right connection type.

Avoid common buying mistakes

  • Assuming similar model names mean the same console support

    The HORI models SPF-013U and AB11-001U are listed for different PlayStation and Xbox platforms respectively. The 8BitDo arcade sticks for Switch/Windows and Xbox also have different platform specifications.

    Before ordering, check the full model number, your platform and the specific game.

  • Assuming PS5 compatibility has no conditions

    For certain MAYFLASH models, the connections described depend on a compatible converter and firmware. MAYFLASH states that the F500 FLAT Elite can be used with PS5 for fighting games only; this does not confirm that every retro beat ’em up will work.

    Check the exact version, the specific game, the required converter and the right firmware.

    Depending on the model and connection, you may need to buy a converter separately. Check whether your setup requires one before you buy.

  • Assuming wireless means maintenance-free gaming

    The 8BitDo Arcade Stick for Switch/Windows uses a rechargeable battery; its 2.4 GHz connection uses the supplied USB receiver.

    Make room for charging and the receiver, or check whether a wired model would suit your gaming space better.

  • Assuming component names guarantee long-term comfort

    References to Sanwa or HAYABUSA components describe the parts, but they don’t tell you whether the casing and hand position will feel comfortable after a long gaming session.

    Compare the wrist rest, dimensions and button positions. Don’t treat manufacturer specifications as a personal comfort test.

Key brands to consider

MAYFLASH

Worth considering if you’re weighing up stick and all-button versions, or different platform requirements.

  • MAYFLASH lists Sanwa components for the F300 Elite and F500 Elite, as well as metal plates for the F500 Elite. According to the manufacturer, the input mode on the F300 Elite can be switched.
  • Certain console connections may require a converter and compatible firmware. The described PS5 use of the F500 FLAT Elite is limited to fighting games and requires a converter, sold separately.

8BitDo

Worth considering if you’re choosing between the separate Switch/Windows and Xbox/Windows versions, or between different connection types.

  • 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C for the Switch/Windows model, and 2.4 GHz and USB-C for the Xbox version.
  • The platform specifications for the two versions are not interchangeable. For wireless use, remember to factor in charging and, where needed, the USB receiver.

HORI

Worth considering if you’re looking for a specific PlayStation or Xbox version and want a casing that gives you access for maintenance.

  • HORI describes the Fighting Stick α as having an opening casing and HAYABUSA controls.
  • The SPF-013U is listed for PlayStation and Windows, while the AB11-001U is listed for Xbox and Windows. Specifications for one version don’t automatically apply to the other.

NACON

Worth considering if you’re looking for a wired stick with a wrist rest and interchangeable stick tops for PlayStation or PC.

  • For the PlayStation version of the Daija, NACON lists a textured wrist rest, a button lock and a detachable 3-m cable.
  • These features are based on manufacturer information and don’t independently prove long-term comfort. The PlayStation version is not evidence of Xbox compatibility.

Qanba

Worth considering if you’re looking for another traditional stick option for PS5, PS4 and PC.

  • Qanba lists a proprietary stick and buttons, as well as a platform switch and touchpad, for the Drone 2.
  • The manufacturer’s claim that the redesigned shape is better suited to larger hands is not an independent comfort assessment, and doesn’t automatically apply to other Qanba models.

Joybuy product selection

This product selection features a leverless arcade controller with separate direction buttons and several connection types listed in the product title.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master leverless controller

BIGBIG WON Fight Master leverless controller for Switch 2/Switch/PC/iOS/Android

If you deliberately want to play without a physical stick, this all-button design, described as leverless, suits that control preference.

Listed in the product title: Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and wired connection.

Listed in the product title: hot-swappable fast-trigger mechanical switches and RGB lighting.

The controller uses separate direction buttons instead of a stick. Check that you like this style of control and that the exact version works with your game and device.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does an arcade stick automatically improve your inputs in retro beat ’em ups?

No. An arcade stick changes how you move your hands; the German Heise guide notes that using a stick may take some practice at first. Check whether the stick and button layout suit the game you play.

What should I check before using an arcade stick with a PS5?

Check the exact version and the console instructions. HORI lists PS5 compatibility for the Fighting Stick α SPF-013U. For the MAYFLASH F300 Elite, MAYFLASH specifies firmware V1.15 when used with MagicBoots-S5; a general PS4 listing isn’t enough to confirm compatibility.

How should I plan for wireless use and maintenance during longer sessions?

The 2.4 GHz connection on the 8BitDo Arcade Stick for Switch/Windows requires the supplied receiver; 8BitDo lists a charging time of 4 hours. HORI describes the Fighting Stick α as having an opening casing that gives you access to its components. Before making changes, check the instructions and the parts compatible with your version.

What are your rights when shopping online in Germany?

According to the Verbraucherzentrale, a standard online purchase of goods usually comes with a 14-day right to cancel; you must notify the other party to the contract that you wish to cancel. Your statutory rights against the seller if goods are faulty are separate from any voluntary manufacturer’s guarantee.

What should I look for when it comes to product safety in Germany?

For its market surveillance of electrical and electronic products, the Bundesnetzagentur lists checks including correct CE marking, identifiable manufacturer details, and German instructions containing the required usage and safety warnings. A CE mark alone does not confirm that a controller is compatible with your game or right for you.