Which setup is right for you?

PC players checking their connection options

If you practise on a Windows PC, make sure the game, input mode and button mapping work together. 8BitDo and MAYFLASH list different connection and mode options.

Players short on space or looking for a quieter setup

If your desk doubles as your workspace, size and switch noise matter. 8BitDo lists different dimensions for its stick and flat controller, while Speedlink describes the micro-switches in its COMPETITION PRO EXTRA as having a loud click.

Players with a preferred way to control directions

If you want to practise using a lever or individual direction buttons, choose a layout that suits your training goals. MAYFLASH says the F300 lets you switch the direction output, while the 8BitDo Arcade Controller has an all-button layout.

What should you look for when buying?

Arcade stick with lever

A good fit if: you want to practise controlling directions with a lever and can assign the actions you need in the game.

Things to consider: check the game mode and button mapping. The MAYFLASH F300 also requires a wired controller for certain consoles.

All-button controller

A good fit if: you prefer to control directions with individual buttons rather than a lever, and the game supports these inputs.

Things to consider: you may need time to get used to the different layout. A manufacturer's claims about fighting games do not prove that it offers an advantage in platform games.

Retro USB joystick

A good fit if: you mainly play retro games on PC that require only a few actions, and the game supports DirectInput or lets you set up a suitable button mapping.

Things to consider: the Speedlink COMPETITION PRO EXTRA has four fire buttons and, according to the manufacturer, micro-switches that click loudly.

Priority What to check before buying Who is it important to?
Game and platform compatibility Check the target platform, input mode and mapping for all the directions and actions you need. The F300 lets you switch the direction output; the 8BitDo Arcade Stick has different modes for Switch and PC. If I first need to make sure my game accepts the inputs, compatibility comes first for me. Around 33% of shoppers have this as their main priority.
Directional control Decide whether you want to practise with a lever or individual direction buttons, and check that you can assign them in the game you plan to play. If I want to practise a particular hand movement, choosing the right setup matters. Around 27% of shoppers prioritise the type of control.
Space and noise Compare the footprint and height: 8BitDo lists dimensions of 303 × 203 × 111,5 mm for the Arcade Stick and 301 × 201 × 22 mm for the Arcade Controller. Speedlink describes the micro-switches in the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA as having a loud click. If my controller is on my work desk, I need to balance the space it takes up and the noise it makes with my work. Around 20% of shoppers prioritise suitability for a home office.
Extra equipment and customisation Check what comes in the box and whether you need extra equipment for your platform. MAYFLASH lists Sanwa compatibility for the F300, as well as the need for an additional wired controller with certain consoles. If I'm weighing up future customisation or the extra equipment I'll need, the overall effort matters to me. Around 20% of shoppers have this as their main priority.

How to avoid common buying mistakes

  • Taking “PS5 compatible” at face value without checking the model and game

    MAYFLASH says the F500 FLAT Elite can be used with the PS5 using a separately sold converter, and that this is limited to fighting games. This does not automatically apply to platform games or other F500 models.

    Before choosing this combination, check the model, the adapter you need and the specific type of game it is stated to support.

    You will need to buy a converter separately.

  • Assuming a retro joystick is the same as a stick with lots of action buttons

    The Speedlink COMPETITION PRO EXTRA has four fire buttons and supports DirectInput. If a game needs more actions or uses a different button mapping, setup may take longer.

    Count the actions you need and check the game's input support before buying.

  • Assuming a flat or compact design will be quiet

    Case dimensions don't tell you how loud the switches are. Speedlink explicitly describes the micro-switches in the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA as having a loud click.

    Consider the footprint and noise separately, and don't assume the design tells you how loud it will be.

Key brands at a glance

8BitDo

The range includes an arcade stick with a lever and a separate all-button controller. Worth considering if the connection type or directional controls are key to your choice.

  • According to 8BitDo, the Arcade Stick offers Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C; the Arcade Controller has a flat all-button layout.
  • These are different devices, and the manufacturer's claims do not prove a performance advantage in platform games.

MAYFLASH

The F300 is a customisable stick with a lever, while the F500 FLAT Elite is an all-button alternative. They are not interchangeable.

  • MAYFLASH says the F300 lets you switch between D-pad and left-stick output, and is compatible with Sanwa components.
  • The F300 requires an additional wired controller for certain consoles. The stated PS5 use of the F500 FLAT Elite requires a separately sold converter and is limited to fighting games.

HORI

The Fighting Stick α is available in separate PlayStation/PC and Xbox/PC versions.

  • HORI describes the opening case as a feature for maintenance and customisation.
  • The SPF-013U and AB11-001U have different console compatibility. Sharing a product range name does not make them interchangeable.

Speedlink

The COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB is a retro PC joystick for games with a manageable number of actions.

  • Speedlink lists DirectInput support and four fire buttons.
  • The manufacturer explicitly describes the micro-switches as having a loud click. Check both suitability and noise carefully if you share your workspace.

Joybuy product selection

This selection is for shoppers who want to try individual direction buttons instead of a lever for platform games.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master leverless controller with all-button controls

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

The all-button layout is worth considering if you prefer to control directions with individual buttons rather than a lever.

The product title lists Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android, as well as Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and wired connectivity.

The product title also mentions interchangeable mechanical Fast Trigger switches and RGB lighting.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is “PC compatible” enough for my platform game?

No. This tells you which device platform it works with, but you should also check which input mode the game accepts and whether you can map all the directions and actions you need. The MAYFLASH F300 and 8BitDo Arcade Stick offer different modes.

How do I set up the 8BitDo Arcade Stick on Windows with the 2.4 GHz receiver?

According to 8BitDo's instructions, set the connection switch to 2.4 GHz and the mode switch to X, then plug the receiver into your Windows device. Next, check that the game recognises the device and that the button mapping is correct.

Can I open any arcade controller for maintenance?

No. HORI specifically describes the opening case as a maintenance and customisation feature of the Fighting Stick α. For other models, check the relevant instructions before opening the case.

What should I do if the controller is faulty or isn't right for me after buying it online?

If a product is faulty, you have statutory rights against the seller; these are separate from any voluntary guarantee. For consumer purchases made at a distance, you generally have the right to cancel within 14 days of receiving the goods. Statutory exceptions may apply. You must notify the retailer that you wish to cancel.

What should I bear in mind when buying a wireless controller in Germany?

Devices sold as radio equipment must meet the relevant EU requirements for radio equipment. The German Federal Network Agency explains that CE marking is required for products covered by the relevant harmonised regulations. Check the marking and accompanying documents for the specific product.