Which controller might suit you?

Console players

If you play on a particular console, check the full model variant against the specific game. Controllers with similar names may have different platform requirements.

PC players with a small desk

If you use the same desk for studying and gaming, you’ll need to consider the footprint and whether you can put the controller away after playing, as well as PC support.

Players sharing a room

If you practise combos regularly, check the noise information for the exact model. A low-profile design or a particular switch type is no guarantee that it will be quiet.

What to look for when buying

Buying priority What to check Who it matters most to
Platform and game Check the full model name and support for your console or PC, as well as the specific game. If I play on a particular console, I don’t want to find out after buying that the variant isn’t suitable. Around 26% of consumers give platform and game compatibility top priority.
Input layout Decide whether you want to practise using a joystick or separate directional buttons. If I want to learn certain moves with a joystick, an all-button layout won’t automatically suit me – and vice versa. Around 21% of consumers put their preferred input layout first.
Desk space and storage Compare the footprint and playing position with the space available, and allow for your hands and the cable route. If I need my desk for studying again after gaming, I want a device that fits the available space and can be put away. Around 21% of consumers prioritise footprint and storage.
Noise while practising Check the information for the exact variant, and don’t assume you can tell how loud it is from its design or switch type. If I share a room, I want to be able to practise regularly without assuming that a low-profile case or particular switches will be silent. Around 16% of consumers are most concerned about being considerate while practising.
Total cost and maintenance Check which adapters are required and what accessories are included for your platform. If you plan to modify it, consider how easy it is to access the components. If I need to budget for accessories or future maintenance, I want to know what my chosen setup will actually involve. Around 16% of consumers put total cost and ease of maintenance first.

Common buying mistakes

  • Checking only the brand name, not the model variant

    Models from the same brand can differ in whether they have a joystick or an all-button layout, and in which platforms they support. The MAYFLASH F500 FLAT Elite is specified as supporting PS5 only for fighting games, with a converter that must be bought separately.

    Check the full model name, your platform, the game and any required accessories together.

    Choosing an unsuitable variant may mean you need an extra adapter or have to return it.

  • Assuming “low-profile” means it takes up hardly any desk space

    A low-profile case can still have a large footprint. According to the manufacturer, the 8BitDo Arcade Controller is 22 mm high and has a footprint of 301 × 201 mm.

    Measure the usable desk space, including room for your hands, rather than considering only the height when planning where to store it.

  • Assuming switch descriptions tell you how loud it will be in your room

    Information about switches or design doesn’t tell you how loud the entire controller will be on your desk.

    Treat noise information as dependent on the model and how you use it. Don’t assume that terms such as “low-profile” or “optical” mean a particular noise level.

Relevant brands at a glance

HORI

The models featured range from a compact joystick arcade stick to a case that opens for maintenance.

  • HORI lists the Fighting Stick Mini SPF-038U as compatible with PS5, PS4 and Windows.
  • The Mini doesn’t have a touchpad. The Fighting Stick α SPF-013U is a different size and caters to a different type of use.

MAYFLASH

The range includes a joystick arcade stick and an all-button model, each with different connection requirements.

  • MAYFLASH lists customisation options and support for PC, Switch and PS3 for the F101.
  • The F500 FLAT Elite requires a converter, sold separately, for the stated use with PS5 fighting games. This does not mean the F101 supports PS5.

8BitDo

The products featured include a joystick arcade stick and a low-profile all-button controller.

  • The manufacturer lists both models as compatible with Switch and Windows. For the Arcade Stick, it also lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz wireless and a wired connection.
  • The Arcade Stick’s connection options don’t automatically apply to the Arcade Controller. Neither model is listed here as supporting PS5.

Qanba

The Drone 2 is a joystick arcade stick for the PS5, PS4 and PC systems listed by the manufacturer.

  • Qanba lists features including a touchpad and a headset port.
  • These features don’t prove that it offers a better feel or lower noise levels than other sticks.

Razer

The Kitsune is an all-button alternative for PS5 and PC if you want to practise directional inputs using separate buttons.

  • Razer lists a low-profile case, a detachable USB-C cable and several SOCD modes.
  • Manufacturer claims about more precise or faster inputs aren’t an independent comparison with other controllers.

Joybuy products

Joybuy products for players looking for a leverless controller with separate directional buttons for PC or Switch.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

This could suit you if you want to use separate directional buttons instead of a joystick, and would like to use the controller with PC or Switch.

The product title lists support for Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android. Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz wireless and a wired connection are also listed, along with replaceable mechanical switches.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is “PS4 compatible” enough if I want to play a PS5 fighting game?

No. That statement alone doesn’t confirm compatibility with every model and game combination. PlayStation sets out the support for officially licensed specialist controllers on PS5. For PS5 fighting games, MAYFLASH also specifies that the F500 FLAT Elite needs a converter, sold separately. Check the exact variant and the game you want to play.

How should I plan for connections and use on a small desk?

Compare the manufacturer’s measurements with the space available, and allow room for your hands and the cable route. For the 8BitDo Arcade Stick, the manufacturer lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz wireless and USB-C. MAYFLASH lists selectable PC input modes for the F101. Check which mode works with your system.

What should I do if the controller is faulty or I don’t want to keep an online purchase in Germany?

For a standard distance-selling contract, consumers generally have the right to cancel, usually within 14 days, although statutory exceptions may apply. If there’s a fault, your statutory rights for faulty goods apply against the seller and are separate from any voluntary guarantee.

What should I check on the labelling of an electronic controller?

When monitoring products on the market, the German Federal Network Agency lists checks including CE marking, product identification, manufacturer information and, where applicable, instructions in German. A model description or brand name alone doesn’t confirm that the specific product on offer complies with the relevant requirements.