Which controllers are right for different players?

Platformer players practising with a stick

If you want to practise directional changes and jumps repeatedly with an arcade stick, check the inputs required by the specific game. 8BitDo notes that its Arcade Stick for Xbox may not be suitable for games that require two joysticks at the same time.

Players using headphones with their setup

If you want to listen to game audio or chat through headphones, check whether the headset connects to the controller or directly to the output device. 8BitDo and Nacon list a 3.5 mm socket on certain models. On PS5, you can also choose your audio output in the audio settings.

Players using both PC and console

If you want to use the same type of controls across several devices, check the exact model version and the systems it supports. 8BitDo and MAYFLASH specifications show that some models may require additional steps, such as using a converter or updating the firmware.

What should you look for when buying?

First, check that the layout suits the game’s controls. Then consider the exact system version, how you want to connect your headphones and how much space you have for practice.

Criteria What to check before buying Who should consider this?
Controls that suit your game Check the controller layout against movement, jumping, menus and any inputs that need to be used at the same time. If I want to practise my platformer’s moves with a stick or individual buttons, the layout needs to support all the game’s controls. Around 26% of consumers are likely to prioritise suitable controls.
Headphone audio Check how game audio and, where applicable, chat are output for your controller, platform and headset. If I want to use headphones while practising, I need to know whether they connect directly to the controller or to the output device. Around 26% of consumers are likely to check how audio is handled first.
System compatibility Check the full model name, console or operating system, and whether any additional hardware is needed. If I want to use the controller with my PC or console, I need the right model version and must allow for any adapter requirements. Around 21% of consumers are likely to prioritise system compatibility.
Setup and maintenance Allow for any converters or firmware you may need, and check whether replaceable parts are accessible. If I want to set up the controller easily or customise it later, I’ll look for extra setup steps and accessible components. Around 16% of consumers are likely to consider this effort first.
Space for practice Allow enough room for the controller, your hands, stick movements and cables. If space is limited where I practise, I’ll want room to position the controller and my hands comfortably. Around 11% of consumers are likely to prioritise the space available.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming similarly named arcade sticks are the same system version

    The 8BitDo Switch/PC version and Arcade Stick for Xbox are listed for different platforms. The name alone doesn’t tell you whether a particular version will work with your device.

    Compare the full model name with the supported systems before making your choice.

  • Assuming a headphone socket means universal audio compatibility

    Socket and headset-output specifications apply to particular models and platforms. They don’t automatically confirm that game audio and microphone functions will work with every combination.

    Check audio output, chat and connection type for your specific system and headset.

  • Applying PS5 specifications from one MAYFLASH model to another

    The F500 Elite and F500 FLAT Elite have different manufacturer specifications. The PS5 use described on the product page for the F500 FLAT Elite with the converters listed there is limited to fighting games.

    Check the exact model, game genre, converter and firmware together.

    Using the F500 Elite with PS5 as described may require a MagicBoots-S5 converter and a firmware update. According to MAYFLASH’s instructions, the update must be carried out on a Windows PC.

  • Measuring the space needed by the base alone

    A stick controller also needs room for your hands and movements. A flat, all-button controller changes the way you play and isn’t a substitute for practising with a stick.

    Measure your practice space, allowing room for your hands, stick movement and cables. Then decide whether you want a stick or individual buttons.

Key brands to consider

8BitDo

Arcade sticks for Xbox/Windows, a separate Switch/Windows version and an all-button model for Xbox/Windows.

  • For the Arcade Stick for Xbox, 8BitDo lists a CTIA-compatible 3.5 mm socket and software for button mapping.
  • The Switch/PC version isn’t listed as an Xbox or PlayStation model. According to 8BitDo’s FAQ, the Xbox stick may not be suitable for games that require two joysticks at the same time.

HORI

The PlayStation version of the Fighting Stick α is listed for PS5, PS4 and Windows. Its casing opens for maintenance.

  • HORI lists a stick and a 3.5 mm audio socket for this version.
  • These specifications don’t confirm the audio functions of other HORI versions or suitability for every platformer.

Nacon

The PlayStation version of the Daija is a stick controller for PS5, PS4 and PC.

  • Nacon lists a 3.5 mm socket for audio and chat, configurable buttons and a detachable USB cable.
  • These specifications apply to the PlayStation version listed here. Manufacturer claims aren’t independent evidence of better controls for platformers.

MAYFLASH

The F500 Elite is a stick controller, while the F500 FLAT Elite is a separate all-button controller.

  • For the F500 Elite, MAYFLASH describes headset audio output on PS4 and Xbox One, as well as PS5 use with MagicBoots-S5 and compatible firmware.
  • The F500 FLAT Elite has different converter requirements. The PS5 use described on its product page is limited to fighting games.

Razer

The Kitsune is an all-button alternative for PS5 and PC if you’d prefer individual directional buttons to a stick.

  • Razer lists four movement buttons and a detachable USB-C cable.
  • Manufacturer claims of superior precision aren’t an independently measured advantage for platformers.

Related products at Joybuy

This Joybuy selection includes a leverless controller for practising with individual directional buttons. It isn’t suitable for practising with an arcade stick.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master leverless controller for Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android

BIGBIG WON Fight Master leverless controller for Switch 2/Switch/PC/iOS/Android

The all-button design is a good fit if you want to practise using individual buttons for directions instead of a stick.

Listed systems: Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android. Connection options: Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and wired. The product name lists hot-swappable Fast-Trigger mechanical switches and RGB lighting.

Shop at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is an arcade controller with a switchable stick mode suitable for every platformer?

No. Check the inputs required by the specific game. 8BitDo notes that the Arcade Stick for Xbox may not be compatible with games that need two joysticks at the same time; a mode switch alone doesn’t confirm that it will work.

Where do I set the audio output on PS5 for a headset connected separately?

Go to Settings, Sound and Audio Output, then select your preferred output device. PlayStation notes that not every setting is available for every headset.

What should I know about setting up a MAYFLASH F500 Elite for PS5?

MAYFLASH describes PS5 use with MagicBoots-S5 and compatible F500 Elite firmware. According to the instructions, the update must be carried out on a Windows PC. Don’t assume these specifications also apply to the separate F500 FLAT Elite.

Who should I contact in Germany if my controller is faulty?

For statutory consumer rights, the seller is generally your point of contact. Verbraucherzentrale gives a two-year period; this is separate from a voluntary guarantee. It also describes a one-off 12-month extension for purchase contracts from 31 July 2026 if you choose a repair under your statutory rights.

Can you put a worn-out arcade controller in household rubbish in Germany?

No. Electrical and electronic waste must not go in household rubbish. The German Environment Agency lists local authority collection points among the options; returns to retailers are subject to specific conditions.