If there isn’t a spare socket near your gaming setup, you could use a USB controller connected to your existing device or a rechargeable wireless arcade stick. First, check that your particular puzzle game and gaming system support the controller and model you’re considering. Then think about cable routing, charging and how much space you have. Wireless play means no cable connecting the controller, but you’ll need to charge the battery later.
Which controllers are right for you?
Players with few spare sockets
If you want to play on your existing PC or console without using another socket at your gaming setup, check whether you can connect via USB or use a rechargeable wireless controller. These have different connection and charging requirements, as the specifications from 8BitDo and MAYFLASH show.
Fans of simple puzzle classics on PC
If your game only needs directional controls and a few actions, check that it supports DirectInput, XInput and your preferred button layout. MAYFLASH and Speedlink list suitable PC input options for their respective models.
Puzzle fans on console
If you want to use an arcade controller with your existing console, check the exact model against your system and game. 8BitDo and HORI offer separate models for different platforms.
What should you look for?
First, check that your game and system are supported. Then decide whether you’d rather keep the cable out of the way or play without a connecting cable, and consider how much space the controller needs.
| What matters to you |
What to check before buying |
Who should pay particular attention? |
| Power without using an extra socket |
Check for available USB ports, supported wireless connections and charging requirements. |
If I don’t want to use another mains socket at my gaming setup, I’ll compare USB connection to the gaming device with a rechargeable wireless model. Around 29% of consumers put this power-supply question first. |
| Compatibility with your system and game |
Check the full model name, gaming system and required input mode. |
If I want to play a puzzle on a particular PC or console, I’ll check the exact model and supported game inputs. Around 29% of consumers give compatibility priority. |
| Directional controls and action buttons |
Compare the actions you need, control mode and number of assignable buttons. |
If my puzzle needs specific directions and only a few actions, I don’t want to choose buttons or control modes that the game doesn’t support. Around 24% of consumers prioritise controls suited to puzzle games. |
| Cable routing and space |
Allow space for the controller and your hands, as well as a clear route to the connection. |
If space is limited where I play, I need a solution that fits comfortably alongside the gaming device. Around 18% of consumers focus mainly on cable routing and available space. |
Which buying mistakes should you avoid?
-
Assuming ‘wireless’ means ‘no charging needed’
A wireless arcade stick lets you play without a connecting cable, but you’ll still need a power source to charge it later. For the 8BitDo Arcade Stick for Switch and Windows, the manufacturer specifies a four-hour charging time.
Plan where you’ll charge it. A 2.4 GHz connection may also need a suitable USB port for the receiver.
Before buying, check the wireless mode and charging port. 8BitDo lists Bluetooth and 2.4 GHz separately in its specifications.
-
Assuming similarly named sticks work with the same platforms
8BitDo lists different platforms for the Arcade Stick for Switch and Windows and the Arcade Stick for Xbox. HORI also offers separate Fighting Stick Mini models.
Check the full model name against your gaming system and the particular puzzle game.
-
Assuming a games bundle proves compatibility
Speedlink describes the games included as being for Windows; that doesn’t prove the joystick will work with every other puzzle game. DirectInput and the four fire buttons need to be supported by the game.
Check which inputs your puzzle game supports and which actions you actually need.
-
Installing firmware on the MAYFLASH F101 without checking first
MAYFLASH warns that newer F101 circuit boards are incompatible with certain older firmware versions.
Check your device version first and follow only the manufacturer’s instructions for that version.
Which brands are worth considering?
8BitDo
Depending on the exact model, 8BitDo arcade sticks support different platforms and connection types.
- For its Switch/Windows stick, 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and a wired connection. The manufacturer says this model also comes with a battery and button-mapping software.
- The battery needs charging. The Xbox model is a separate version and shouldn’t be confused with the Switch/Windows one.
MAYFLASH
The wired F101 offers input and directional modes for supported gaming systems.
- MAYFLASH lists eight buttons and XInput and DirectInput support for Windows.
- According to the manufacturer, certain older firmware versions are incompatible with newer F101 circuit boards. It’s important to check that your device version matches the instructions.
HORI
The Fighting Stick Mini models are compact wired options, each designed for specific platforms.
- For the Mini models reviewed, HORI lists eight buttons and a casing measuring approximately 8 × 6 inches.
- The cable is part of the setup. Check whether the Switch or PlayStation/Windows model is right for your system.
Speedlink
The COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB is described as suitable for compatible Windows retro games that need only a few action buttons.
- Speedlink lists DirectInput and four fire buttons.
- The manufacturer describes the microswitches as noticeably clicky. The included games bundle doesn’t prove compatibility with every puzzle game.
Joybuy product selection
An arcade controller for puzzle classics that lets you choose between wired and wireless connections.
No image available
BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller for Switch 2/Switch/PC/iOS/Android
If your puzzle game supports an all-button layout and runs on one of the listed systems, you can compare the wired and wireless connection options. Check that the specific game supports the inputs.
All-button hitbox layout; Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz wireless and wired connection; the product name lists compatibility with Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android.
The product name also mentions hot-swappable fast-trigger mechanical switches and RGB.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Does an arcade controller always need its own socket?
No. The MAYFLASH F101 connects to a supported gaming device via USB. According to the manufacturer, the 8BitDo Arcade Stick can be used over Bluetooth or 2.4 GHz once charged. The gaming device still needs a power supply, and the wireless stick will need charging later.
How do I set up directional controls for a puzzle game?
Set up the controls to match the inputs your game requires. MAYFLASH describes separate modes on the F101 for the directional buttons and the left and right sticks, as well as XInput and DirectInput for Windows. Choose the mode that suits your system and game, then check all the actions you need.
What should I bear in mind when charging or updating firmware?
8BitDo specifies a four-hour charging time for the Arcade Stick for Switch and Windows. Before updating the MAYFLASH F101, check your device version: MAYFLASH says that newer circuit boards are incompatible with certain older firmware versions.