Which arcade controller is right for you?

Considerate players

If you share a bedroom, it’s worth thinking carefully about the noise made by the joystick and buttons before you buy. Qanba describes both controls on the Q8 as “Silent”, but that isn’t an independent noise comparison.

Players who switch platforms

If you play on PC or Switch, the connection mode and inputs need to work with the specific game. 8BitDo lists certain system versions for its arcade models, while The Tetris Company lists a keyboard and mouse as inputs for the browser version.

Players short on space

If you use your controller on a small shelf or want to put it away after playing, check its dimensions, height and cable routing. 8BitDo and HORI publish dimensions for specific models.

What should you look for when buying?

Arcade stick with joystick

Choose this if: You prefer the classic joystick controls and your game supports the inputs you need.

Things to consider: The joystick needs height and room to move. Qanba’s “Silent” claim doesn’t establish a specific noise level for a bedroom.

Flat controller without a joystick

Choose this if: You prefer to use buttons for directional and action inputs, and a low-profile design matters. 8BitDo lists the dimensions of its Arcade Controller as 301 × 201 × 22 mm.

Things to consider: The button layout needs to suit the moves in your game; a flat design doesn’t tell you how noisy the buttons are.

Compact wired stick

Choose this if: You want a joystick but are looking for a smaller device. HORI lists an approximate footprint of 8 × 6 inches for the Fighting Stick Mini.

Things to consider: Allow for the cable routing and check that your game supports it; HORI’s description of the micro-switch joystick doesn’t claim that it operates quietly.

First check whether the game supports your inputs, then consider noise, control feel and space requirements separately.

Buying priority What to check Who it matters most to
Noise in the bedroom Qanba describes the joystick and buttons on the Q8 as “Silent”. Think about which noises might disturb you in your room rather than assuming this means a particular decibel level. If someone in the room needs peace and quiet, you’ll want to assess the joystick and buttons separately rather than relying on the “Silent” label alone. Noise is likely to be the main buying priority for around 36% of consumers.
Game and device compatibility Check the game version, platform, input mode and button mapping. The Tetris Company says the browser version uses a keyboard and mouse. If you play on PC or Switch, you’ll want to make sure the specific game recognises your chosen controller. Around 29% of consumers are likely to put device and game compatibility first.
Space and storage 8BitDo lists the Arcade Controller’s dimensions as 301 × 201 × 22 mm; HORI gives an approximate footprint of 8 × 6 inches for the Fighting Stick Mini. Compare the relevant dimensions with your shelf and allow for cable routing with wired devices. If you have a small shelf, you’ll want to consider the footprint and cable routing together, so there’s room for the controller while you play and when you put it away. Around 21% of consumers are likely to prioritise space requirements.
Control feel Check directional input, how easy the action buttons are to reach and the mapping options available in the specific game version. 8BitDo offers both an Arcade Stick and an Arcade Controller without a joystick. If joystick or button controls are especially important to you, check that the directional input and action buttons are easy to reach for the moves you use. Around 14% of consumers are likely to base their choice mainly on how the controls feel.

Avoid common buying mistakes

  • Assuming “for Windows” means “works with my browser puzzle game”

    Compatibility with a device or operating system doesn’t prove that a particular game accepts controller input. According to The Tetris Company, the browser version of Tetris uses a keyboard and mouse.

    Before buying, check that the inputs supported by your exact game version match the controller and the button mapping you want.

  • Taking “Silent” to mean completely quiet

    Qanba’s description of the Q8’s joystick and buttons is a manufacturer’s claim, not an independent comparison with other models.

    Treat low noise as something to check, and don’t assume the label guarantees a particular noise level.

  • Overlooking the extra connection requirements for the Mayflash F300

    Mayflash lists additional connection requirements for certain console setups.

    Check the instructions for your console and the stated requirements for the controller, adapter and firmware.

  • Confusing a flat design with quiet buttons

    The low profile of the 8BitDo Arcade Controller describes its dimensions, not how loud its buttons are.

    Consider space and noise separately. If you choose a joystick model, allow for its height and room to move as well.

A guide to relevant brands

Qanba

The Q8 is an arcade stick with a joystick that the manufacturer lists as compatible with PC.

  • Qanba describes the Q8’s joystick and buttons as “Silent”.
  • This isn’t an independent noise comparison and doesn’t establish console compatibility.

8BitDo

The models covered include an arcade stick with a joystick and a flatter Arcade Controller without one.

  • 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C for the Arcade Stick; the Arcade Controller is listed as 301 × 201 × 22 mm.
  • Connection types and supported systems vary by model. These details don’t prove that every puzzle game is supported.

HORI

The Fighting Stick Mini is a compact, wired joystick option for the listed Switch and PC uses.

  • HORI lists an approximate footprint of 8 × 6 inches and a micro-switch joystick.
  • The dimensions don’t prove that the buttons are quiet or that every game is supported.

Mayflash

The F300 is a wired stick with systems and input modes listed by the manufacturer.

  • Mayflash lists a switch between D-pad and analogue stick output.
  • The manufacturer requires additional connection steps for certain consoles; PS5 use depends on adapter and firmware requirements.

Nacon

The Daija is a larger, configurable stick option for the listed PlayStation systems.

  • Nacon lists Sanwa joystick and buttons, configuration software and a detachable 3-m cable.
  • These features don’t prove an advantage for puzzle games or quiet operation.

Joybuy product selection

This selection features a leverless all-button controller for anyone comparing options without a joystick. Check separately whether your specific puzzle game supports the controller.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller (Switch 2/Switch/PC/iOS/Android)

The all-button design is worth comparing if you want to play without a joystick; check separately whether your specific puzzle game supports it.

The product title lists Bluetooth, 2.4G and a wired connection, as well as hot-swappable Fast-Trigger mechanical switches and RGB.

View on Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Will an arcade controller automatically work with every Tetris game?

No. According to The Tetris Company, the browser version of Tetris uses a keyboard and mouse. Check that your specific game version explicitly supports controllers and the button mapping you need; a stick’s device compatibility alone doesn’t guarantee this.

What should I bear in mind when connecting the Mayflash F300?

Choose the mode that matches your device and check whether the game expects D-pad or analogue stick input. For the PS4 and Xbox One/Xbox 360 setups listed on its product page, Mayflash requires an additional wired controller to be connected. The manufacturer says PS5 use is only possible subject to further adapter and firmware requirements.

Can I take a “Silent” claim as a guarantee of undisturbed play?

No. The manufacturer describes the Qanba Q8’s joystick and buttons as “Silent”. Without comparable measurements, you can’t tell what noise level to expect in your room.

If something goes wrong, what’s the difference between statutory rights and a guarantee?

Your statutory rights are separate from a voluntary guarantee. The German consumer advice centre points out that a guarantee is voluntary, so check its terms separately from your statutory rights.