For classic arcade puzzle games, first check which directional inputs and buttons your particular game accepts, and whether the exact controller variant works with your PC or console. If storage space is limited, a compact, wired stick may be the better choice. Multiple connection options can be handy, but they won’t reduce the space the casing takes up.
Who is an arcade controller for?
Puzzle gamers with a dedicated PC or console
If you mainly play on your own device, check the exact model variant and input mode against the game’s requirements. Manufacturers list different platforms for different models, including Windows, Switch, PlayStation and Xbox.
Fans of precise directional inputs
For classics that involve frequent changes of direction, it’s important to know which directional inputs the game expects and whether you can assign the buttons as needed.
Gamers with a small desk
If you use the same desk for studying, consider the controller’s dimensions, cable routing and storage. In a shared room, the noise made by the switches may also matter.
What should you look for when buying?
First check the game’s controls and device compatibility. Then weigh up the space required and connection type to find the right fit for your room.
| Buying consideration |
What to check |
Who is it especially important to? |
| Compatibility with your device and game |
Compare the exact model variant, platform and input mode with the game’s settings. |
If I’m playing on my existing PC or console, I want to be sure this specific model works with my puzzle game. Around 36% of consumers prioritise compatibility. |
| Directional controls and buttons |
Make a note of the actions you need and check which directional inputs and button assignments the game accepts. |
When changing direction frequently, I want to be able to use the right inputs and button layout. Around 29% of consumers put directional controls first. |
| Desk space and storage |
Measure the available desk width and depth, allowing room for your hands, joystick movement and, if necessary, the cable. |
If I need to keep my desk clear for studying too, the space it takes up and storage are especially important. Around 21% of consumers prioritise space requirements. |
| Connection and noise |
Check the connection type and the USB port required. In a shared room, also check the noise information for the specific model. |
In a shared room, I want to take the cable routing and switch noise into account. Around 14% of consumers prioritise connection and noise. |
Common pitfalls
-
Assuming similarly named 8BitDo sticks are the same version
The standard Arcade Stick and the Arcade Stick for Xbox have different platform and connection details. So, a similar name doesn’t mean that both variants will work with the same device.
Check the full model name and platform list against your device.
Choosing an incompatible model could mean extra hassle when returning it.
-
Comparing only the casing dimensions with your available desk space
You’ll need extra room beyond the casing for your hands, joystick movement and cable. The models also vary in size.
Measure the usable width and depth of your desk, including room for operating the stick and routing the cable.
-
Assuming retro controls mean quiet operation
Speedlink explicitly describes the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA’s microswitches as loud and clicky. This applies to this model and doesn’t tell you anything about other sticks.
If you share a room, check how noisy the specific model is before buying.
-
Overlooking extra requirements for use with consoles
Some consoles may require additional devices or adapters, as well as the right firmware, when used with MAYFLASH models.
Before deciding, read the instructions for your exact console, model and firmware version.
Depending on your set-up, you may also need a compatible wired controller or adapter.
Key brands at a glance
MAYFLASH
The F101 and F300 Elite cater to different needs when it comes to directional input modes and replaceable components.
- MAYFLASH lists DP, LS and RS modes for the F101, along with a casing measuring 27,8 × 19,8 cm.
- For the F300 Elite, MAYFLASH lists Sanwa components and a larger casing measuring 30,2 × 23,6 × 11,3 cm. Some console set-ups may have additional requirements.
HORI
The Fighting Stick Mini SPF-038U is a compact, wired option for the platforms listed by the manufacturer.
- HORI lists dimensions of approximately 8 × 6 inches, eight buttons and a cable for this model.
- There’s no touchpad. The listed platforms alone don’t guarantee that every puzzle game will support the inputs.
8BitDo
The standard Arcade Stick and the Arcade Stick for Xbox are separate variants, each with its own list of supported platforms.
- According to 8BitDo, the standard Arcade Stick offers Bluetooth, 2,4 GHz and USB-C.
- The Xbox version has a different list of platforms and connection options. Check the exact variant rather than assuming one model’s details apply to the other.
Speedlink
The COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB is described as a joystick with a small number of buttons for compatible Windows games.
- Speedlink lists four fire buttons and DirectInput.
- Speedlink explicitly describes the microswitches as loud and clicky. Windows recognition alone doesn’t guarantee that every game will be supported.
Qanba
The Drone 2 is a larger fight stick for the PS5, PS4 and PC systems listed by the manufacturer.
- Qanba lists a platform switch and a touchpad.
- The platform details don’t replace testing the inputs in the specific puzzle game.
Joybuy products
Joybuy’s selection of arcade controllers with multiple connection options.
No image available
BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller
The product title describes it as an all-button Hitbox arcade controller. Check whether your puzzle game accepts this type of input.
Listed platforms: Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android.
Connections listed in the product title: Bluetooth, 2.4G or wired.
The product title mentions hot-swappable fast-trigger switches.
Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is ‘PC compatible’ on the box enough?
No. Check the input mode of the exact model against the game’s settings. For example, the MAYFLASH F101 is documented as supporting XInput and DirectInput on PC, as well as DP, LS and RS modes.
What should I check before a firmware update?
First identify your device version and select the right mode for your device. MAYFLASH notes that a newer F101 board is incompatible with certain older firmware versions. Then test the directional and action buttons in your game.
What are my rights when buying online from a trader?
For a distance purchase, you generally have 14 days from delivery to cancel, subject to legal exceptions. Information from Your Europe, the European Union’s consumer portal, also notes that consumers may have to pay return costs in certain circumstances. Separately, faulty goods are covered by a statutory guarantee against the seller for at least two years. This is not the same as a voluntary manufacturer’s guarantee.
How should I dispose of an old arcade controller in Germany?
Electrical and electronic waste must not be put in household rubbish. The German Environment Agency lists recycling centres and suitable return points; removable batteries should be collected separately where possible.