Which controls are right for you?

Puzzle players who focus on directional inputs

If you play classic arcade puzzle games, check whether your game requires directional buttons or a joystick, and whether you need diagonal inputs. A joystick restrictor and a digital input mode are two different features.

Players in a dark room

If you want to see the controls in low light, check whether the buttons or joystick you’ll actually use are illuminated. An RGB light ring or status indicator doesn’t mean the action buttons are lit.

Players with a specific PC or console setup

If you want to use the controller with a particular PC or console, check that the exact model variant and input mode are compatible with your system. Depending on the model, you may also need additional accessories.

What should you look for when buying?

First, decide which directions and inputs your puzzle requires. Then compare the controls’ lighting with the platform, the space you have available and the connections on the specific model.

What matters What to look for Who is this especially important to?
Illuminated controls Check the full model details to see whether the buttons, joystick or just a light ring are illuminated, and whether you can switch the lighting off. If I play in a dark room, I want to see the controls I actually use. Around 29% of consumers say this lighting is their top priority.
Directional control Check your game’s inputs against the button layout and the joystick’s actual restrictor; a D-pad mode is not the same as a mechanical four-way restrictor. If my puzzle requires specific directions or no diagonals, I want controls that suit it. Around 29% of consumers say this is their main priority.
Platform and game Check the full model name, supported platform and input mode. Also find out whether you need an additional device. If I play on a particular PC or console, I want to make sure the model supports the inputs my games require. Around 24% of consumers say compatibility is their top priority.
Space and connections Compare the exact model’s dimensions with your playing area, allowing space for your hands, joystick movement and cable. If I have limited space, I want to choose a device that fits along with its cable and wrist rest. Around 18% of consumers say space is their main concern.

Common misconceptions

  • Confusing an RGB ring with illuminated action buttons

    In a dark room, it matters which controls are actually lit. 8BitDo lists an RGB light ring for the Arcade Controller for Xbox; Qanba describes the Crystal as having illuminated buttons and a lit joystick.

    For the exact variant, check separately whether the buttons, joystick or just an indicator are illuminated, and which lighting modes are available.

  • Assuming an input mode is the same as a joystick restrictor

    A D-pad mode affects the input sent to your device, while a mechanical restrictor limits the joystick’s direction of movement. Slagcoin’s technical guide explains that these are separate features.

    For your game, check both the directions the controller sends and the joystick’s actual mechanical restriction.

  • Assuming similar product names mean the models are compatible

    8BitDo lists the Arcade Stick and the Arcade Controller for Xbox as separate models with different platform specifications. For certain console setups, MAYFLASH says the F300 requires an additional connected controller.

    Before ordering, check the full model name, target platform, required input mode and any accessories you may need.

Key brands at a glance

8BitDo

The range includes button-based controllers and joystick models, each with specified platform support.

  • According to 8BitDo, the Arcade Controller for Xbox has an adjustable RGB light ring and supports Xbox and Windows.
  • The Arcade Stick for Switch and Windows is a different model; dynamic button labelling doesn’t mean the action buttons are illuminated.

Qanba

The Crystal is a joystick model that the manufacturer describes as suitable for specific PlayStation and PC setups.

  • Qanba lists illuminated buttons, a lit joystick and three LED modes.
  • For PS5, the manufacturer’s specification applies only to games that support PS4 joysticks; it doesn’t mean the controller is suitable for every puzzle.

MAYFLASH

The F300 and F300 Elite are joystick options with documented input modes and customisation features.

  • For the F300, MAYFLASH describes XInput and DInput for PC, as well as switching between D-pad and analogue stick modes.
  • According to MAYFLASH, an additional controller may be required for certain console setups. Also check the specific joystick configuration of the variant you’re considering.

HORI

The Fighting Stick Mini SPF-038U is a compact joystick option for PS5, PS4 and Windows 11/10.

  • HORI lists eight action buttons and a compact body with a cable.
  • The product description for this variant doesn’t specify illuminated action buttons; the details don’t automatically apply to other HORI models.

Suitable products at Joybuy

The following Joybuy products are for players who prefer to enter directions using buttons rather than a joystick.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

The all-button layout suits players who prefer to enter directions using buttons rather than a joystick.

The product name lists Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android, as well as Bluetooth, 2.4G and wired connectivity.

The product name also mentions hot-swappable fast-trigger mechanical switches and RGB.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is ‘4-way’ or a D-pad mode enough for a puzzle with no diagonals?

No, these terms describe different features. A mechanical restrictor limits the joystick’s movement, while D-pad mode affects the input sent to your device. Check both against your game and, for the MAYFLASH F300 Elite, check the specific joystick configuration.

How do I set up an arcade controller for PC or console?

Choose the connection and input mode that suit the full model and your platform. MAYFLASH describes PC modes for the F300 and says an additional connected controller is needed for certain consoles. For the Switch/Windows Arcade Stick, 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C; these details don’t automatically apply to other variants.

What should I do if the controller is faulty or I want to return it?

If a product is faulty, statutory consumer rights against the seller are separate from a voluntary guarantee, as the Verbraucherzentrale explains. For ordinary online purchases from business sellers, there is generally a 14-day right to cancel from the date you receive the goods. Exceptions and return conditions may apply in individual cases.

What rules apply to controllers and their disposal?

According to the European Union, whether CE marking is required depends on whether relevant harmonised EU rules apply to the specific product. An international product description doesn’t confirm that a particular listing complies with these rules. The Umweltbundesamt advises that electrical and electronic waste should not be put in household rubbish, but taken to an appropriate collection or take-back point.