An arcade stick with a joystick is a good fit if your puzzle game supports digital directional inputs and the available action buttons. An all-button controller is worth considering if you prefer to enter directions using individual buttons and the game recognises this control method. First check compatibility with your game and platform, then find out whether your headphones connect to the controller, console or PC. The features mentioned are based on manufacturers’ specifications, not comparative gameplay testing.
Which controller is right for you?
Console players with a headset
If you want to use arcade controls and headphones with the same console, check the exact model variant and audio connection. Specifications from 8BitDo and Nacon, along with Nintendo’s guidance, show that the options vary between devices.
PC retro gamers who prefer a joystick
If you want to play puzzle classics on PC with traditional joystick controls, check the input mode, button mapping and space required. 8BitDo and Speedlink describe different PC controllers and input features.
Players sharing a room
If other people in the room need some peace and quiet, consider the controller’s mechanical noise as well as the game audio. Speedlink says the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB has clicky microswitches.
What should you look for when buying?
First check that your game and platform support the controller. Then choose between joystick and all-button input, and check the audio connection separately.
| What to consider |
What to check before buying |
Who should consider this? |
| Game and platform compatibility |
Check the exact system variant and whether the game supports the directional and action inputs you need. |
If I want to play a particular puzzle game on my console or PC, the controller needs to work with the system and the game’s controls; around 33% of consumers therefore prioritise platform and game compatibility. |
| Headphone connection |
Find out whether your headphones connect to the controller, console or PC, and check whether they use a cable or Bluetooth audio. |
If I play with headphones, I want to know in advance how to connect them; around 27% of consumers pay particular attention to audio connectivity. |
| Joystick or individual buttons |
Check whether the game supports a joystick or separate directional buttons, and which action buttons you need. |
If the way I control a game matters to me, I check whether I’d rather use a joystick or individual directional buttons; around 20% of consumers prioritise this type of control. |
| Control noise |
Check whether the controller uses microswitches, and find out how noisy the specific model is if other people are in the room. |
If I play in a shared room, I want to consider the noise from the buttons and joystick as well as what I hear through my headphones; around 20% of consumers pay particular attention to noise in the room. |
Common misconceptions
-
Assuming arcade sticks with similar names work on the same platforms
Different model variants may support different systems and connections. For some systems, Mayflash lists additional hardware as a requirement.
Before buying, compare the full model name and connection requirements for your console.
-
Assuming headphones make a controller quiet
Headphones keep game audio from disturbing others, but they don’t automatically muffle the click of buttons or a joystick. Speedlink says the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB has clicky microswitches.
If other people are in the room, consider audio output and mechanical control noise separately.
-
Assuming included retro games work across platforms
Speedlink says Windows is required to play the included games. This doesn’t automatically tell you which platforms the joystick itself works with.
Check controller compatibility and game compatibility separately.
Notable brands and product ranges
8BitDo
Arcade sticks and all-button controllers with support for different platforms.
- According to 8BitDo, the Switch/Windows arcade stick offers Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz wireless and USB-C; the Xbox model has a 3.5 mm CTIA jack.
- The models differ in their platform support and connections. 8BitDo says the Xbox model’s battery life is shorter when headphones are connected.
Speedlink
The COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB is listed as a digital joystick for Windows PCs.
- Speedlink lists DirectInput and four fire buttons.
- Speedlink describes the microswitches as clicky. According to the manufacturer, the included games only run on Windows.
Nacon
The Daija is a configurable arcade stick for PlayStation and PC.
- Nacon lists configurable buttons and a 3.5 mm jack for wired audio and chat.
- Nacon notes that some games requiring two analogue sticks are not compatible.
Mayflash
The F500 FLAT is an all-button alternative for several listed systems.
- Mayflash lists headset audio for certain consoles; check whether your platform is one of them.
- According to Mayflash, some consoles may require an additional controller; a separately available converter is listed for PS5.
HORI
HORI lists the Fighting Stick Mini as compatible with PS5, PS4 and Windows 11/10.
- HORI lists eight action buttons, a microswitch joystick and a compact design.
- Check the headphone connection separately for your platform and specific model.
Joybuy product selection
This controller is a good fit for all-button input if you want to control directions with individual buttons rather than a joystick.
No image available
BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller for Switch 2/Switch/PC/iOS/Android
Suitable if you want to enter directions using individual buttons rather than a joystick.
Layout: all-button hitbox. Listed platforms: Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android.
Connection options listed in the product name: Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and wired. The mechanical switches are listed as hot-swappable.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Does an arcade stick need its own headphone jack?
No, as long as your console or PC supports the headphone connection you want to use. Nintendo lists the Switch headphone jack, USB and Bluetooth as audio connection options; Sony describes a USB adapter for certain wireless PlayStation headsets on PS5. Whether your own headset works depends on the model and platform.
What can I check if the stick doesn’t control a puzzle game properly?
First check the selected platform or joystick mode, then check the button mapping in the game. Nacon says the Daija can switch between D-pad and analogue stick mode, and notes that some games require two analogue sticks.
What are my rights if I buy online and want to return an item or report a fault?
For an applicable distance contract, EU consumers generally have 14 days from delivery of the goods to withdraw from the contract; exceptions and the terms of the contract apply. Your Europe also states that when you buy from a trader, you have a legal guarantee of at least two years from receipt. This is not the same as a voluntary manufacturer’s warranty.
Can I use Bluetooth headphones with a wireless controller at the same time on the Switch?
With Bluetooth audio active, Nintendo allows up to two wireless controllers to be connected. Bluetooth audio is disabled in local wireless mode, and there may also be a delay in playback depending on the audio device.