Which designs are right for different players?

Players with a small desk

If you’ll use the controller alongside study materials or a keyboard and need to put it away afterwards, compare the dimensions of the specific model and allow room for your hands and cable. HORI lists the Fighting Stick Mini SPF-038U as having a footprint of around 8 × 6 inches.

Players with a dedicated console

If you play on a particular console, check the exact model variant and its stated platform compatibility before deciding. The MAYFLASH F300 has additional requirements for certain consoles, including a wired controller or a suitable adapter and firmware version.

Retro fans with a preferred control style

If you’re choosing between an arcade stick, a classic retro joystick and individual directional buttons, check that the available directions and action buttons suit your games. Speedlink lists four fire buttons on the Competition Pro Extra, while 8BitDo describes its Arcade Controller as a stick-free design.

What should you look for when choosing?

What matters What to check before buying Who it matters to
Platform and game compatibility Check the exact model variant, platform, input mode and requirements of the game you want to play. If you want to use the controller with your existing console or PC, choosing the right model version is key. Around 31% of consumers are likely to prioritise compatibility with their device.
Desk space and storage Compare the model’s width and depth with the space available, and allow extra room to use it comfortably. If you also need your desk for study materials or a keyboard, the casing and room to move your hands both matter. Around 25% of consumers are likely to prioritise a small desk footprint.
Directions and action buttons Match the directions and actions your game needs to the stick, directional buttons and number of buttons available. If you have a preferred control style, check whether an arcade stick, retro joystick or individual directional buttons will suit your games. Around 19% of consumers are likely to choose based on their preferred control style.
Clicking noise Don’t assume wireless operation or a slim design means quieter use; check the details for the specific model. If other people in the same room are studying or need peace and quiet, noisy switches could be disruptive. Around 13% of consumers are likely to prioritise keeping disruption at home to a minimum.
Customisation and accessories Check whether you can change the button mapping or components on the exact model, and whether your system requires additional accessories. If you want to customise the button mapping or components, check what the specific model allows and whether you’ll need any extra parts. Around 12% of consumers are likely to prioritise customisation and avoiding additional purchases.

Which buying mistakes should you avoid?

  • Assuming platform variants are the same because they share a brand name

    The standard 8BitDo Arcade Stick and the Xbox version have different platform specifications. The MAYFLASH F300 may also have additional requirements for certain consoles.

    Before buying, check the full model name, supported platform and any required connections or adapters.

  • Measuring only the casing

    Even if the casing fits on your desk, you’ll also need room for your hands, stick movement and, where applicable, the cable.

    Compare the available desk space with the dimensions of the exact model and allow extra room to use it. Wireless operation may change how you manage cables, but it won’t reduce the space the casing needs.

  • Expecting a retro joystick to work like a quiet eight-button fight stick

    Speedlink lists four fire buttons on the Competition Pro Extra and specifically describes its microswitches as having a loud click.

    Check that the design gives you the number of buttons your game needs, and consider whether the clicking could disturb anyone in the room.

Brands worth considering

HORI

HORI describes the Fighting Stick Mini SPF-038U as a compact stick option for the PlayStation and Windows systems specified by the manufacturer.

  • HORI lists eight action buttons and a footprint of around 8 × 6 inches for this model.
  • According to the manufacturer, the model has no touchpad. The specifications don’t confirm a particular noise level or compatibility with every game.

8BitDo

8BitDo offers an arcade stick with a lever and a slim Arcade Controller without one. There’s also a separate stick variant for Xbox.

  • For the standard Arcade Stick, 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and wired connectivity. For the Arcade Controller, the manufacturer specifies wireless connection types by platform.
  • The models differ in design, platform specifications and connectivity. Don’t assume details for one variant apply to another.

MAYFLASH

The MAYFLASH F300 is aimed at buyers who want to customise input modes or components; according to the manufacturer, the F700 offers additional connection types and has its own platform specifications.

  • MAYFLASH lists switchable PC input modes and compatibility with certain Sanwa components for the F300.
  • For certain consoles, the manufacturer requires an additional connected controller for the F300. The stated PS5 use requires a suitable adapter and firmware version.

Speedlink

According to Speedlink, the Competition Pro Extra is a USB retro joystick for the specified Windows systems. It shouldn’t be confused with a fight stick that has eight action buttons.

  • Speedlink lists four fire buttons and DirectInput.
  • The manufacturer specifically describes the microswitches as having a loud click.

Qanba

According to Qanba, the Drone 2 is a stick option for the PS5, PS4 and PC systems specified by the manufacturer.

  • Qanba lists a platform switch, touchpad and headset connection.
  • These specifications don’t establish any advantage in terms of noise or gaming performance.

Related products at Joybuy

This selection includes a leverless arcade controller with individual directional buttons.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master leverless arcade controller

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

A good choice if you prefer directional inputs without a stick and want an all-button layout.

  • Compatibility according to the product name: Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android.
  • Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz or wired operation according to the product name.
  • Hot-swappable mechanical switches according to the product name.
View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is USB enough to make an arcade controller work with my console?

No. USB alone doesn’t confirm compatibility with your console and game. Check the full model variant and intended input mode. For the PS4, Xbox One and Xbox 360, MAYFLASH requires an additional wired controller for the F300. The stated PS5 use requires a suitable adapter and firmware version.

How much space does a stick need on a small desk?

As well as space for the casing, allow room for your hands, stick movement and cable. The manufacturer lists dimensions of 303 × 203 × 111.5 mm for the standard 8BitDo Arcade Stick; compare these with the space you actually have available.

What can I do if my controller is faulty or I’ve bought the wrong one from a German online retailer?

If a product is faulty, you have statutory rights against the seller. The European Union’s consumer information states that consumer purchases are generally covered for at least two years from receipt of the goods. This is separate from the right to cancel an online contract, which according to the Verbraucherzentrale generally lasts 14 days and must be communicated to the retailer.

What does a CE marking tell me about an arcade controller?

According to the European Commission, CE marking is required only when the relevant harmonised EU rules apply to the specific product. It doesn’t prove compatibility with a particular game or that the product has undergone independent performance testing.

How should I dispose of a controller with a battery when it’s no longer needed?

In Germany, waste electrical equipment must be collected separately. According to the Federal Environment Agency, local collection points generally accept it free of charge. Only remove the battery if you can do so without taking the device apart extensively, then take it to a separate battery collection point.