Who are the different designs suited to?

Considerate practice players

You practise in a shared bedroom and are specifically looking for controls that the manufacturer describes as noise-reducing. “Silent” doesn’t automatically mean inaudible: Qanba lists a Silent lever and Silent buttons for the Q8, while Hit Box Arcade describes the PC Hit Box buttons as “silent”.

Platform-specific players

You want to avoid a controller not working as needed with your device or in a particular game. Check the systems and limitations listed for the specific model; for example, MAYFLASH limits the stated PS5 use of certain models to fighting games.

Space-conscious players

You want to put your controller away after playing or use it in a limited space. Compare the stated dimensions of 8BitDo’s cases or the approximate size of the HORI Fighting Stick Mini, but don’t assume this tells you anything about noise levels.

What should you consider when buying?

Lever stick with noise-reducing controls

A good fit if: You want to practise the classic lever movement while specifically looking for noise-reducing controls. Qanba lists a Silent lever and Silent buttons for the PC-compatible Q8.

Keep in mind: The manufacturer’s description isn’t an independent measurement of noise levels in your room; the Q8 is listed as compatible with PC.

Leverless controller

A good fit if: You want to input directions with individual finger-operated buttons rather than a lever. Hit Box Arcade lists Silent buttons for the PC Hit Box, while 8BitDo lists Switch and Windows compatibility for the Arcade Controller.

Keep in mind: Designs and listed platforms vary; also check how your chosen game handles simultaneous opposite directions.

Classic or compact lever stick

A good fit if: The feel of a lever or easy storage matters more to you than explicitly stated noise-reducing features. 8BitDo lists Switch and Windows compatibility for the Arcade Stick; HORI gives the Fighting Stick Mini’s approximate size as 8 × 6 inches and lists Switch and PC compatibility.

Keep in mind: These models aren’t specifically described as suitable for quiet practice at bedtime; the HORI Mini has a microswitch lever.

MAYFLASH multi-system controller

A good fit if: You switch between multiple devices and can check the connection types and conditions for the exact model variant.

Keep in mind: MAYFLASH lists PS5 support for the F700 Elite and F500 FLAT Elite only for fighting games; according to the manufacturer, the F500 FLAT Elite also requires a converter for this.

Buying consideration What to look for Who it matters most to
Noise while practising Check information about buttons and, where applicable, the lever separately; if you need a guaranteed level of quiet, you’ll need a suitable measurement or to test it in your own room. If I practise in a shared bedroom, I want to consider the buttons and, where applicable, the lever without assuming “Silent” means inaudible. Around 33% of consumers prioritise noise while practising.
Platform and game Check the exact model variant, target device and game type; don’t assume PS5 support for fighting games applies to platform games. If I want the controller to work with my device and in a particular platform game, I check the stated support for both. Around 33% of consumers put platform and game compatibility first.
Directional input Choose a lever or individual direction buttons to suit your preferred input routine; check the game’s SOCD behaviour when opposite directions are pressed. If I want to learn a particular input for the game I’m practising, I compare a lever with individual direction buttons. Around 20% of consumers prioritise the right type of directional input.
Desk space and storage Compare the case dimensions, cable routing and available storage space with your own setup. If I need to put the controller away after practising, I want to know whether the device and cable will fit in my space. Around 14% of consumers prioritise desk space and storage.

Which buying misconceptions should you avoid?

  • Assuming “Silent” means “inaudible in the bedroom”

    Manufacturers may describe individual buttons or levers as noise-reducing without proving how loud the whole device will be on your desk.

    If you need to keep noise to a minimum, consider the controls, the surface underneath and your specific living situation. Don’t assume there’s a guaranteed reduction in noise without comparable measurements.

  • Taking a PS5 listing to mean it works with every PS5 platform game

    According to the manufacturer, MAYFLASH limits PS5 use of the F700 Elite and F500 FLAT Elite to fighting games; this doesn’t mean they’re generally suitable for PS5 platform games.

    Before buying, check the game type and any additional hardware required for the exact model variant. Don’t assume approval for fighting games extends to other genres.

    The manufacturer’s stated PS5 use of the F500 FLAT Elite requires a converter, which must be purchased separately.

  • Assuming compact, low-profile and quiet mean the same thing

    Case dimensions help you plan for space, but tell you nothing about noise levels. For the HORI Fighting Stick Mini, the manufacturer lists a microswitch lever.

    Consider the space it needs, its noise levels and your preferred input method separately.

Which brands are worth considering?

Qanba

For PC players looking for a classic lever and controls explicitly described as noise-reducing.

  • Qanba lists a Silent lever and Gravity KS Silent buttons for the Q8.
  • This isn’t an independent noise measurement; the model is listed as compatible with PC.

Hit Box Arcade

For PC players who prefer individual direction buttons to a lever and want action buttons described as “silent”.

  • Hit Box Arcade lists Silent C.O.M.B.O. buttons and several SOCD modes for the PC Hit Box.
  • Compatibility is listed for PC; check support for other systems and your specific game separately.

8BitDo

For anyone comparing separate models with a lever or a low-profile leverless design.

  • 8BitDo lists Windows and Switch compatibility for the Arcade Stick and Arcade Controller; the Arcade Stick also lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C.
  • The Arcade Controller isn’t described as having a Silent feature for the whole device; the two designs shouldn’t be treated as equivalent.

HORI

For anyone looking for a space-saving classic lever stick for Switch or PC.

  • HORI lists the Fighting Stick Mini at approximately 8 × 6 inches, with a wired connection and eight action buttons.
  • The microswitch lever doesn’t prove that it’s especially quiet to use.

MAYFLASH

For buyers comparing the design and multi-system support of the models covered here.

  • MAYFLASH lists a lever, Sanwa components and several connection options for the F700 Elite.
  • According to the manufacturer, PS5 use of the F700 Elite and F500 FLAT Elite is limited to fighting games; the F500 FLAT Elite also requires an additional converter.

Joybuy product pick for finger-based directional input

This pick is for anyone who prefers to use individual direction buttons rather than a lever when practising arcade games. The listed variant names Switch 2, Switch and PC as compatible platforms.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller for Switch 2, Switch and PC

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller for Switch 2/Switch/PC

The all-button design is worth considering if you prefer to input directions with individual buttons rather than a lever.

According to the product title, it’s for Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android; connects via Bluetooth, 2.4G or cable; and features hot-swappable fast-trigger switches.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I use a fight stick advertised for PS5 with a PS5 platform game?

Not on the basis of the PS5 listing alone. According to the manufacturer, MAYFLASH limits the F700 Elite to fighting games on PS5; for the F500 FLAT Elite, MAYFLASH also lists only fighting games and says a converter must be purchased separately. For any other model, check that it supports your game and the inputs you need.

How do I set up a leverless controller for the game I’m practising?

First, match the direction and action buttons to the game’s controls. Hit Box Arcade describes SOCD modes for leverless controllers; when opposite directions are pressed at the same time, the selected setting can affect the output. Check the mode and test the inputs you need in the game.

What should I bear in mind when cleaning or modifying a controller?

Follow the instructions for your exact model variant. Hit Box Arcade describes the PC Hit Box as having a removable bottom panel and replaceable parts, and notes that damage caused by modifications isn’t covered by the manufacturer’s warranty.

What are my rights when shopping online in Germany?

You generally have a right to cancel a distance sales contract with a business. The Verbraucherzentrale states that the usual cancellation period is 14 days and notes that exceptions apply. Statutory rights relating to faulty goods are against the seller and are separate from a voluntary guarantee.

Which legal product details should I check for a wireless controller in Germany?

CE marking is required for a product only if it falls under EU harmonisation legislation that explicitly requires it. The European Union’s Your Europe website explains that CE is a declaration of conformity by the manufacturer, not an independent quality mark. Check the details for the specific model and its accompanying product documents.