Who this buying decision is for

Shoot-’em-up players with limited desk space

If you plan to keep the controller on your desk beside your monitor or keyboard, compare its dimensions and leave extra room for your hands and cables. You’ll also need to put it away after playing. 8BitDo, HORI and Haute42 list the dimensions of certain models.

Players in shared rooms

If you want to keep the noise from the stick and buttons to a minimum, check the specific components. Qanba describes the stick and buttons on the Q8 as “silent”; this isn’t a measurement of the noise made by the complete controller in a room.

Players who already have a particular console

If you’ll mainly use the controller with a particular PC or console, check the full model name, input mode and any accessory requirements. The details apply to specific devices and variants.

What to consider when choosing

First, check that the platform and game inputs match. Then decide whether you’d prefer a stick, individual directional buttons or, for your specific game, separate directional inputs.

What to consider What to look for Who it matters to
Platform and game Check the full model name, system and input mode; allow for any required adapters or additional controllers. If I want to be sure the controller and game will work with my existing system, I check these details before anything else. Around 28% of consumers are likely to prioritise compatibility.
Desk space Compare the controller’s width and depth with the available space, and leave room for your hands and cables. On a small desk, I want to be able to put the controller away easily after playing. Around 22% of consumers put available desk space first.
Noise Check the stick and buttons separately; don’t take labels such as “silent” to mean the complete device has been measured. If I share a room, I want to keep noise to a minimum when I play regularly. This is the main concern for around 22% of consumers.
Directional input Choose a joystick or individual directional buttons to suit the game’s controls; if movement and aiming are controlled separately, check both inputs. I want to enter directions in a way that suits my game, and check in advance whether it requires separate controls. Around 17% of consumers are likely to make this their main consideration.
Extra set-up Check which cables, adapters, connected controllers or compatible replacement parts you’ll need. If I want to keep set-up and extra purchases to a minimum, I need to know what the complete set-up involves beforehand. Around 11% of consumers focus mainly on this.

Common buying assumptions

  • “Suitable for PC” doesn’t mean “compatible with every console”

    Support varies by model and system. The manufacturer says the 8BitDo Arcade Stick in question isn’t compatible with PS4, PS5 or Xbox. For certain consoles, MAYFLASH says the F300 needs an additional controller connected.

    Before buying, check the full model name against your platform, game and input mode. Also check whether you need an adapter or an additional controller.

  • “Silent” components don’t guarantee a quiet controller

    Qanba’s claims apply to specific stick and button components. They don’t indicate how loud the complete device is in a student bedroom.

    Consider the stick and buttons separately, and don’t expect a particular noise level unless comparable measurements are available.

  • Every shoot-’em-up only needs one directional input

    Some games are specifically described as twin-stick shooters. So a single arcade stick won’t necessarily replace two separate directional inputs.

    Check whether your specific game controls movement and aiming separately, and whether the controller you want can handle both inputs.

Relevant brands and model ranges

8BitDo

The Arcade Stick is a joystick option for the systems and connection types listed by the manufacturer.

  • 8BitDo lists remappable buttons and dimensions of 303 × 203 × 111,5 mm.
  • According to the manufacturer, this Arcade Stick doesn’t support PS4, PS5 or Xbox. These details don’t automatically apply to other 8BitDo models.

MAYFLASH

The F300 is a wired joystick controller with several input modes and replaceable arcade parts.

  • For PC, MAYFLASH lists XInput and DInput, as well as a switchable stick function.
  • According to the manufacturer, certain consoles require an additional controller to be connected. PS5 use with firmware V1.28 requires a MagicBoots-S5 adapter.

HORI

The Fighting Stick Mini SPF-038U is a compact joystick model for the PlayStation and Windows systems listed by the manufacturer.

  • HORI lists a footprint of approximately 8 × 6 inches, an eight-button layout and a cable.
  • According to HORI, it doesn’t have a touchpad. Its compact design doesn’t prove that it’s quieter or suitable for every game.

Qanba

The Q8 is a PC-focused joystick option for buyers who care about the type of stick and button components.

  • Qanba describes the Q8’s stick and buttons as “silent” and outlines noise-reducing features of its Gravity-KS buttons.
  • These are the manufacturer’s claims about individual components, not an independent noise measurement of the complete Q8 or a statement about other Qanba models.

Haute42

The Haute Pad M series is a slim, wired controller with directional buttons instead of a joystick.

  • Haute42 lists dimensions of 166 × 240 × 12,6 mm for the M series, along with several system and input modes.
  • For PlayStation, the manufacturer describes additional configuration and authentication steps. The dimensions and modes don’t apply to every Haute42 series.

Joybuy products

The following Joybuy products are for anyone who prefers directional buttons to a joystick for shoot-’em-ups.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

The leverless design is an option if you prefer using buttons rather than a stick for directional inputs.

The product title lists Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android, as well as Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and a wired connection.

Other features listed in the title include an all-button layout, hot-swappable fast-trigger mechanical switches and RGB.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do I set up an arcade stick on PC for my shoot-’em-up?

Choose a PC input mode supported by your model, then check the in-game controls for directions, firing and special actions. MAYFLASH lists XInput and DInput for the F300; 8BitDo describes a PC XInput mode for its Arcade Stick. Whether the controls work for you also depends on the specific game.

Can I simply use a PC-compatible button controller with the PS5?

Not just because it’s listed as compatible with PC. For PlayStation, Haute42 describes a separate mode or passthrough and lists authentication requirements. So check the model, firmware, any required extra device and the specific game together.

What are my rights if a product is faulty or I buy online in Germany?

Under EU rules, goods are covered by a legal guarantee for at least two years from the date you receive them. Online purchases generally come with a 14-day right to cancel; exceptions and the terms of the specific purchase should be checked. A voluntary manufacturer’s warranty doesn’t replace your legal rights.

Can I put an old arcade controller in general waste in Germany?

No. Germany’s Federal Ministry for the Environment explains that waste electrical and electronic equipment must be collected separately and can, for example, be taken to a local collection point. There are conditions for returning it to a retailer that is required to accept returns without making a new purchase; the 25 cm limit applies to this return option, not to buying a controller.