Which control styles are right for you?

Considerate stick player

If you want to keep using an arcade stick, you’ll also want to consider the noise made by the stick and buttons in a shared room. Qanba describes the relevant Q3MF-GV components as “Silent”, but this doesn’t specify a particular noise level in your room.

Space-saving all-button player

If you have limited space or want to put your controller away after playing, a low-profile all-button layout could be a good fit – provided you prefer entering directions with buttons rather than using a stick in shoot-’em-ups. 8BitDo lists the Arcade Controller’s dimensions as 301 × 201 × 22 mm.

Console and PC players

If you play on several systems, check that your specific console and shoot-’em-up are supported. General platform information may come with restrictions based on the type of game, system version or additional accessories.

What should you look for when buying?

Start by checking noise levels and support for your specific game and system. Then decide whether a stick or all-button controls, and the space you have available, best suit your day-to-day needs.

What matters to you What to check before buying Who will find this most useful?
Noise in a shared room Assess the stick and action buttons separately, and check the exact component version. If someone sleeps in the same room, I want to know how loud the stick and buttons are individually; around 29% of consumers prioritise keeping room noise to a minimum.
Support for your specific game Check the console, game version, input mode and any required adapters together. If I want to play my shoot-’em-up on a particular console, I want confirmation that this specific game is supported; around 29% of consumers prioritise system and game compatibility.
Stick or direction buttons Check the controller layout and the button arrangement needed for diagonal inputs. If using a stick matters to me, or I prefer direction buttons, I want to choose a layout that suits the way I play; around 24% of consumers prioritise their preferred control style.
Space and storage Compare the dimensions, including height, with the space available. If I need to put my controller away after every session in a shared bedroom, the space it takes up matters to me; around 18% of consumers prioritise footprint and storage.

Avoiding buying pitfalls

  • Assuming “Silent” means completely noiseless

    Describing components as “Silent” doesn’t establish a particular noise level in a bedroom. The stick and buttons may sound different from one another.

    Assess both components separately and consider how they sound in the room where you’ll actually use them.

  • Assuming a PS5 claim applies to every PS5 game

    MAYFLASH limits the F500 FLAT Elite’s stated PS5 use with a separately sold converter to fighting games. For the F700 Elite, the manufacturer warns against other types of PS5 games, including shoot-’em-ups.

    Before buying, get confirmation that your specific shoot-’em-up is supported and find out what accessories you’ll need.

  • Treating all-button as just a flatter arcade stick

    With an all-button layout, you enter directions using buttons rather than a stick. So a low-profile case doesn’t tell you whether you’ll enjoy using the controls.

    Check the button layout and consider whether it will make it easy for you to enter diagonal movements.

Brands to consider

Qanba

A stick option for PC players looking for components at the stick and buttons that the manufacturer says are quieter.

  • For the Q3MF-GV, Qanba lists a Gravity Silent stick and Gravity KS Silent buttons, as well as PC support via D-Input and X-Input, and Android support.
  • The manufacturer doesn’t specify a noise level in the room or confirm support for any other consoles.

8BitDo

Offers both a low-profile all-button controller and a separate arcade stick with a joystick.

  • For the Arcade Controller, 8BitDo lists dimensions of 301 × 201 × 22 mm and replaceable switches. The manufacturer lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C for its separate Arcade Stick.
  • The connection, dimensions and feature details apply to the specific model mentioned. Neither model is confirmed to operate silently.

MAYFLASH

Offers the F500 FLAT Elite as an all-button model and the F700 Elite as a separate wireless stick option.

  • For the F500 FLAT Elite, MAYFLASH lists additional connection requirements for certain consoles; the F700 Elite is a stick model.
  • The F500 FLAT Elite’s stated PS5 use with a separately sold converter is limited to fighting games. MAYFLASH warns against using the F700 Elite for PS5 shoot-’em-ups and other types of games.

HORI

A stick option for PlayStation players who want access to the components for maintenance or customisation.

  • HORI lists a HAYABUSA stick and HAYABUSA buttons for the Fighting Stick α. The case can be opened for maintenance and customisation, according to the manufacturer.
  • The standard version described isn’t identified as a Silent model. HORI notes that the Silent HAYABUSA stick has a different connector pinout.

Joybuy product selection

This selection is for players who want to control shoot-’em-ups with an all-button or Hitbox layout instead of a stick.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

The all-button and Hitbox layout is a good fit if you want to enter directions in shoot-’em-ups using buttons rather than a stick.

Compatible systems listed in the product title: Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android.

Connections listed in the product title: Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and wired.

The product title also mentions hot-swap fast-trigger mechanical switches and RGB.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is “PS5 compatible” enough to confirm it will work with a shoot-’em-up on PS5?

No, not on its own. MAYFLASH limits the F500 FLAT Elite’s PS5 use with a separately sold converter to fighting games, and explicitly warns against using the F700 Elite for PS5 shoot-’em-ups. Check that your specific game version is supported.

Can I simply replace a standard stick with a Silent one?

Not without checking the specific model. HORI lists different connector pinouts for the standard and Silent HAYABUSA sticks. Before fitting one, check the connections and your controller’s instructions.

What are my rights if a controller is faulty or bought online in Germany?

Your statutory rights against the seller and a voluntary guarantee are separate things. According to the Verbraucherzentrale, online purchases generally come with a 14-day right to cancel from the date the contract is made or the goods are received. You must notify the retailer or contracting party if you wish to cancel. Check the terms of your specific contract.

What markings should I look for on a wireless controller sold in Germany?

The Bundesnetzagentur outlines requirements for electrical and electronic devices, including wireless devices. These include correct CE marking, device identification and German-language instructions. Check the details for the specific device; an image in the product description alone doesn’t confirm that all requirements have been met.

Should an old controller go in the household bin?

No. The stiftung elektro-altgeräte register sets out the rules for returning waste electrical equipment. Whether a retailer is required to accept it depends, among other things, on the size of its sales area and, for a one-for-one return, whether you’re buying equipment of the same type. Check where you can return your old device and what conditions apply.