Choose your controller based on whether you prefer to play shoot-’em-ups with a physical stick or separate direction buttons. An all-button model replaces the stick with buttons, but that doesn’t automatically give you an advantage in-game. To reduce screen glare, it’s more important to position your display and lighting carefully. Also check that the exact model version works with your platform and the game you want to play.
Which control style is right for you?
Players who prefer a stick
If you prefer to control your character with a traditional arcade stick, compare the exact model version and check that it supports your platform. Manufacturers such as 8BitDo and HORI list different platform compatibility for their respective models.
Players who prefer buttons
If you’d rather enter directions using individual buttons, an all-button controller could be a good option. 8BitDo and MAYFLASH both offer suitable models, although connection requirements vary by version.
Players in a bright gaming spot
Consider the controller surface, the space it needs and reflections on your display separately. The Federal Institute for Occupational Safety and Health explains that glare and reflections on screens and other IT surfaces can cause visual problems.
What should you consider when choosing?
Arcade stick with a lever
A good fit if: you prefer to control directions with a physical stick and can find a model for your platform.
Things to consider: the stick and case need space, and using a stick alone doesn’t guarantee greater precision.
All-button controller
A good fit if: you’d rather enter directions using individual buttons and are happy to get used to this layout.
Things to consider: button controls feel different from a stick. Depending on the model, connecting to a console may require extra hardware or come with limitations.
When playing shoot-’em-ups in a bright room, consider how the controls feel, whether the controller works with your game and platform, how you’ll set it up and what’s involved in connecting it.
| What matters to you |
What to check before buying |
Who should consider this? |
| Directional and action inputs |
Check whether it has a stick or separate direction buttons, as well as the button mapping and input mode of the exact model. |
If you have a preferred control style, test movement and actions in the game you want to play once connected. Around 33% of consumers put how the controls feel first. |
| Platform and game compatibility |
Check the full model name, platform version, connection mode and any restrictions for the specific game. |
If you’re buying a controller for a particular console or PC, check the model and game together. Around 27% of consumers prioritise platform compatibility. |
| Screen visibility and space |
Identify the source of reflections where you plan to set up, and allow space for your hands, the stick and cables. |
If you play in daylight or at a small table, assess reflections on the display separately from the controller surface. Around 20% of consumers prioritise lighting and setup. |
| Connection and accessories |
Check the intended connection type, what’s included and whether you’ll need extra hardware for your platform. |
If you want to play without extra connection steps, check the cable, wireless mode and any accessories you may need. Around 20% of consumers prioritise an easy connection. |
Avoiding common arcade controller buying mistakes
-
Assuming a PS5 converter connection works for shoot-’em-ups
MAYFLASH says that using the F500 FLAT Elite with a PS5 via a separately sold converter is limited to fighting games. This doesn’t confirm that it works with a shoot-’em-up.
If you want to play a shoot-’em-up on PS5, look for confirmation for the exact model, platform and game.
-
Confusing a low-reflection controller surface with an anti-glare screen
Reflections on your display can come from windows or lights, and choosing a controller won’t get rid of them.
Check what’s causing the reflections and, if needed, reposition your screen or lighting. Assess reflections on the controller surface separately.
-
Choosing by brand name alone instead of checking the model version and platform
Even models from the same brand can differ in platform support, input mode and connection requirements.
Check the full model name, the intended connection method and compatibility with the specific game you want to play.
Brands and model ranges to help you choose
8BitDo
The ranges mentioned include both an arcade stick with a lever and an all-button controller.
- Product pages list supported Switch and Windows versions, as well as connection types and button-mapping options that vary by model.
- Connection method, directional layout and dimensions differ. The product pages don’t list PlayStation support for the models mentioned.
MAYFLASH
The F500 Elite has a stick, while the F500 FLAT Elite uses separate direction buttons.
- MAYFLASH lists platform and mode information for these models, including XINPUT and DINPUT for the F500 Elite on PC.
- Connecting the F500 FLAT Elite to certain consoles requires extra hardware. The manufacturer says that connecting it to a PS5 via a converter is limited to fighting games.
HORI
The Fighting Stick models mentioned have different case designs: the Mini is compact, while the α opens for access inside.
- HORI lists the models mentioned as compatible with PlayStation and Windows 11/10. The manufacturer says the Fighting Stick α case can be opened for maintenance and customisation.
- The Mini’s compact design and the larger, customisable α meet different space and modification needs; this doesn’t mean one offers better performance than the other.
Qanba
The Drone 2 is a stick option that the manufacturer lists as compatible with PS5, PS4 and PC.
- The product page lists a platform switch and a touchpad.
- The manufacturer’s claims about comfort or suitability for larger hands don’t prove an independent advantage specifically for shoot-’em-ups.
Joybuy products on this topic
This product is an all-button alternative for players who’d rather enter directions using individual buttons.
No image available
BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller
The all-button layout could suit you if you prefer to enter directions using individual buttons. Still, check that it works with the specific game you want to play.
Listed platforms: Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android.
Listed connection types: wired, Bluetooth and 2.4 GHz.
The product name mentions hot-swappable fast-trigger switches.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Can a particular controller make your screen easier to see in a bright room?
Not on its own: changing your controller won’t make your screen anti-glare. Check whether windows or lights are reflected in the display and, if needed, reposition your screen or lighting. Assess reflections on the controller surface separately.
What should I test after connecting the controller?
Select the input mode intended for your model and platform, then test all the directional and action inputs you need in the specific shoot-’em-up. For example, MAYFLASH lists XINPUT and DINPUT for using the F500 Elite on PC.
Does the MAYFLASH F500 FLAT Elite work with every PS5 game?
No. The manufacturer says that connecting it to a PS5 using a separately sold converter is limited to fighting games. This doesn’t confirm compatibility with a PS5 shoot-’em-up, so check support for the specific model and game.
What are my rights if a controller bought online is faulty?
For purchases from professional sellers, Your Europe, the European Union’s consumer portal, states that you have at least two years of legal guarantee from the date you receive the goods. For distance purchases, you generally also have a 14-day right to cancel from delivery, subject to relevant exceptions. Your legal rights for faulty goods and your right to cancel are separate.
What does CE marking tell you about a wireless controller?
The Federal Network Agency explains that products covered by the relevant EU harmonisation rules must carry CE marking. The marking alone doesn’t confirm that the controller will work with your shoot-’em-up or indicate how well it performs in-game.