Which controller is right for you?

Players using multiple systems

If you play retro games on PC and console, check the specific controller version and input mode against your system and game. 8BitDo and MAYFLASH list different platforms and requirements for their respective models.

Players in a dark room

If you want to find the controls quickly when the room is dimly lit, distinguish between lighting effects on the casing and clearly visible button labels. 8BitDo describes a changing layout display on one model, while Razer lists Chroma RGB effects for the Kitsune.

Players with a clear control preference

Think about whether you prefer to enter directions with an arcade stick or four directional buttons. HORI describes a stick for the Fighting Stick Mini SPF-038U; Razer lists the Kitsune as a controller with four directional buttons.

What should you look for when buying?

Arcade stick with a joystick

A good fit if: You want to enter directions with a stick, like on an arcade machine. 8BitDo describes its Arcade Stick for Switch and Windows; the HORI Fighting Stick Mini SPF-038U is listed for PS5, PS4 and Windows.

Consider: Sticks need room to move. The HORI’s compact design doesn’t remove the need to check whether its wrist rest suits you.

All-button controller

A good fit if: You want to use four directional buttons instead of a stick. Razer lists the Kitsune for PS5 and PC; 8BitDo describes a Switch/Windows version of the Arcade Controller.

Consider: The button layout differs from stick controls and may take some getting used to. RGB effects don’t prove that the action buttons are illuminated.

Multi-platform stick with potential extra requirements

A good fit if: You switch between systems and prefer a stick. MAYFLASH lists PC input modes among the features of the F500 Elite.

Consider: To use the F500 Elite with all PS5 games as described by the manufacturer, you’ll need a MagicBoots-S5 adapter and compatible firmware. Also check whether the adapter you need is included.

Buying priority What to check Who should consider it?
Platform and game Check the full model name and supported system; on PC, make sure you select the right input mode. If you play on several systems, it’s important that the exact version you want works with your game. Around 36% of consumers put compatibility first.
Finding your way in low light Check which areas light up and how the button layout is displayed. If you want to play in a dark room, what matters is whether you can actually see the controls. Around 29% of consumers prioritise being able to find their way in low light.
Stick or directional buttons Compare the layout with the directional sequences and inputs used in your games. If you’re used to a particular control style, choose a controller that suits it. Around 21% of consumers prioritise how the controls feel.
Space and connection Allow enough room for the casing, your hands and the stick; check the cable route and supported connections. If your gaming area is short on space or you want to avoid cables, the dimensions and connection type of the specific model matter. Around 14% of consumers prioritise space and connection.

Avoid common buying mistakes

  • Assuming similar-sounding model names mean the same platform version

    The 8BitDo Arcade Stick for Switch and Windows is a different version from the Arcade Stick for Xbox. Mixing them up could mean buying the wrong product and having the extra hassle of returning it.

    Before you buy, check the full version name against your gaming system.

  • Assuming RGB effects mean the button labels are illuminated

    Razer’s description of Chroma RGB effects on the Kitsune doesn’t prove that the action button labels are easy to see in a dark room.

    Check which parts of the specific model are illuminated and how the button layout is displayed.

  • Taking the PS5 compatibility claim for the MAYFLASH F500 Elite at face value

    MAYFLASH makes the F500 Elite’s stated support for all PS5 games conditional on using MagicBoots-S5 and compatible firmware.

    Check the adapter, firmware and your specific game before placing your order.

  • Confusing wireless operation with needing less space

    The connection options on the 8BitDo Arcade Stick don’t change how much room the casing needs.

    Measure the space required for the controller, your hands and the stick, whatever connection type you want to use.

Key brands at a glance

8BitDo

The Arcade Sticks described are available as separate Switch/Windows and Xbox/Windows versions. The Arcade Controller is an all-button option for Switch and Windows.

  • 8BitDo describes several connection options for the Arcade Stick, and a visual layout display for the Arcade Controller that changes with the input mode.
  • The layout display doesn’t prove that all the buttons are sufficiently illuminated in a dark room. The platform versions aren’t interchangeable.

HORI

The Fighting Stick Mini SPF-038U combines an arcade stick with a compact design and is listed for PS5, PS4 and Windows.

  • HORI lists eight action buttons, a microswitch stick and non-slip feet for this model.
  • It’s a smaller, wired model. You should also consider whether the wrist rest suits your hand.

MAYFLASH

The F500 Elite is a stick controller for several platforms listed by the manufacturer, with PC input modes also supported.

  • MAYFLASH lists Sanwa components, as well as XInput and DInput on PC.
  • To use the F500 Elite with all PS5 games as described, you’ll need a MagicBoots-S5 adapter and compatible firmware.

Razer

The Kitsune is a low-profile all-button controller for the PS5 and PC uses specified by Razer.

  • Razer lists four directional buttons, a detachable cable and Chroma RGB effects.
  • RGB effects don’t prove that the action button labels are illuminated or easy to read in a dark room.

Qanba

The Drone 2 is a stick controller listed by Qanba for PS5, PS4 and PC.

  • Qanba lists a platform switch, a touchpad and a headset socket for this model.
  • These features don’t tell you how easy the controller is to use in low light.

Arcade controllers at Joybuy

This Joybuy selection includes a leverless all-button controller for players who prefer directional buttons to a stick.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master leverless controller for Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android

BIGBIG WON Fight Master leverless controller for Switch 2/Switch/PC/iOS/Android

The all-button layout is an option if you’d rather use directional buttons than a stick.

Listed platforms include Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android; check compatibility with your specific game before buying.

Connect via Bluetooth, 2.4G or cable; features hot-swappable mechanical switches and RGB lighting. RGB alone doesn’t tell you whether the button labels are easy to see in a dark room.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RGB lighting enough to help me find the right action buttons in a dark room?

Not necessarily. Razer describes Chroma RGB effects on the Kitsune, while 8BitDo lists a changing visual layout display for its Arcade Stick. Neither tells you how easily you’ll be able to see all the action button labels in your room. Check the lighting and button layout of the specific model separately.

How do I set up an arcade stick on a Windows PC?

It depends on the model. 8BitDo lists the Arcade Stick for Windows; MAYFLASH specifies XInput and DInput for the F500 Elite on PC. Select the mode that’s right for your game, then check the button layout in the game.

What should I bear in mind when cleaning or modifying it?

Disconnect the controller before working on it, and follow the instructions for the specific model. MAYFLASH describes Sanwa components for the F500 Elite; 8BitDo lists a circuit board for compatible replaceable switches on the Arcade Controller. This doesn’t mean that parts will fit between the two devices.

What are my rights if the controller develops a fault after I buy it in Germany?

When you buy from a trader, you have statutory consumer rights against the seller. EU consumer information specifies a minimum two-year legal guarantee from the date you receive the goods. This is separate from any voluntary manufacturer’s warranty. If there’s a fault, the first step may be to have the product repaired or replaced.

Can I return a controller bought online if I don’t like how it feels to use?

In Germany, online orders generally come with a 14-day right to cancel, starting from the day you receive the goods. The consumer advice centre notes that exceptions and the specific contract should be taken into account; you must notify the seller that you’re cancelling. Before ordering, also check the return address and returns policy.