Which control style suits you?

Puzzle gamers using multiple devices

If you switch between supported PCs or consoles, check the input mode and model version against your games on each device. MAYFLASH and 8BitDo list different platforms and connection types for different models.

Fans of classic joystick controls

If you prefer playing puzzle classics with a physical joystick, compare a simple retro model with an arcade stick that has several buttons. Speedlink lists four fire buttons and DirectInput for the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB.

Gamers who play for long sessions

If you play for extended periods, compare how you hold your hands and how much room you have for a joystick or direction buttons in your own setup. The German Social Accident Insurance (DGUV) notes in general that intensive computer input can be associated with musculoskeletal complaints; this does not constitute a comfort assessment of any particular controller model.

What should you look for when buying?

What to consider What to check Who it matters most to
Game and device compatibility Match the game, device, model version, input mode and required action buttons. If I want to play a particular puzzle game on a specific PC or console, I first check that it accepts all the inputs I need. Around 36% of consumers put compatibility first.
Directional feel and button layout Count the actions you need, then compare the joystick with separate direction buttons and check how they are mapped. If I prefer moving a joystick or entering each direction with a separate button, I want to choose a layout that suits the way I play. Around 29% of consumers prioritise control type and button layout.
Hand position and desk space Measure the space available and check your hand and arm position where you actually play. If I play for long periods, I want to position my hands and controller in a way that works for me. Around 21% of consumers make hand position and space their main concern.
Wired and wireless connections Check the connection for your platform, as well as the USB port, receiver, cable routing and charging requirements. If I want to avoid cables while playing or don't want to recharge a battery, I check that the connection suits my device and where I sit. Around 14% of consumers focus mainly on connections and interruptions.

Common buying misconceptions

  • A platform listing doesn't mean every game will work

    Even if a controller is listed for a device, the specific game must accept its input mode and the actions you need. MAYFLASH also specifies an additional wired controller connection for certain consoles.

    Check the game’s button mapping, mode and any additional connections required for your exact setup.

  • There’s no proof that all-button layouts are more ergonomic or faster

    Separate direction buttons and a low-profile case do not prove that an all-button layout will be more comfortable or improve performance during a long puzzle session. Manufacturer claims about precision or speed are not independent evidence for your game.

    Assess the hand position and ease of use for yourself, rather than relying on general claims about precision.

  • Don’t overlook the noise or number of buttons on a retro joystick

    Speedlink describes the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB as having loud-clicking microswitches and four fire buttons. This may matter in shared rooms or games that require lots of different actions.

    Consider who shares the room with you, and check whether the available buttons are enough for your games.

Key brands to consider

Speedlink

The COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB is a simple retro joystick option for games with suitable controls, on a supported Windows PC.

  • Speedlink lists DirectInput and four fire buttons for this model.
  • The manufacturer specifically says that the microswitches click loudly. The included game bundle does not prove compatibility with other puzzle games.

MAYFLASH

The F300 is worth considering if you want to switch between XInput and DirectInput on PC, or change between directional modes.

  • MAYFLASH documents switchable input modes and replaceable parts for the F300.
  • For certain listed consoles, the manufacturer specifies a connection to an additional wired controller. Specifications for other MAYFLASH models do not automatically apply to the F300.

8BitDo

8BitDo offers separate joystick and all-button options with its Arcade Stick and Arcade Controller, for the Switch and Windows setups listed for each model.

  • According to the manufacturer, the Arcade Stick offers several connection options, while the Arcade Controller has separate direction buttons and a low-profile design.
  • Platform compatibility, input mode and wireless connection vary by model and should be checked individually.

Razer

The Kitsune is an all-button alternative for gamers who deliberately want to play without a joystick on PS5 or PC.

  • Razer lists four movement buttons, optical switches and a detachable USB-C cable.
  • Manufacturer claims that inputs are especially precise or fast are not independent evidence of the controller’s suitability for puzzle games.

Related products at Joybuy

This selection is for gamers looking for an all-button layout without a joystick for puzzle games, with a wired or wireless connection depending on their platform.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

The all-button layout, without a joystick, is an option if you prefer to enter directions using separate buttons.

The product title lists Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android as compatible platforms.

The product title lists Bluetooth, 2.4G and wired connections.

The title also mentions hot-swappable mechanical switches and RGB lighting.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Will every arcade controller work with every classic puzzle game?

No. Check that the game and device support the input mode of the specific model version, as well as all the actions you need. MAYFLASH lists XInput and DirectInput for the F300 on PC; Speedlink lists DirectInput for the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB. Neither guarantees compatibility with a game that isn't listed.

How do you set up an 8BitDo Arcade Controller on Switch or Windows?

For Windows, 8BitDo’s instructions specify the X switch position and the USB adapter for wireless use. For Switch, they specify the S switch position and Bluetooth pairing. For a wired Switch connection, the instructions say to enable “Pro Controller Wired Communication”. These steps apply to this model.

What should you bear in mind during longer sessions?

Check your actual hand position and desk space rather than assuming that a low-profile design offers health benefits. The German Social Accident Insurance (DGUV) notes in general that intensive use of computer input devices can lead to possible complaints; it has not assessed any of the controllers mentioned here. Follow your specific device’s instructions for cleaning and maintenance.

What are your rights if a product develops a fault after you buy it in the EU?

According to the EU’s Your Europe portal, goods bought in the EU are generally covered by a legal guarantee of at least two years from the date you receive them. This is separate from any voluntary manufacturer’s warranty.

Can you put a worn-out arcade controller in household rubbish in Germany?

No. The German Environment Agency notes that waste electrical equipment must be collected separately; local recycling centres accept it free of charge. Whether you can return it to a retailer depends on the applicable legal requirements.

What should you look for in an electronic or wireless controller?

The German Federal Network Agency lists correct CE marking and identifiable products and manufacturer information among its market surveillance checks. An online listing alone does not prove that an individual model complies with the requirements.