Which controller is right for you?

Fans of traditional joystick controls

If you prefer to make puzzle moves with a joystick rather than individual directional buttons, check that the stick’s mechanism matches your game’s inputs. 8BitDo describes its Arcade Stick as an eight-way stick with a square gate.

Players using a specific platform

If you play on a particular console or PC, check the connection, input mode and full model number. Manufacturers such as MAYFLASH and HORI offer models with different platform specifications; similar names alone don’t confirm compatibility.

Players at a bright desk

If light on the screen is distracting, consider the screen surface and the light reaching it separately from your choice of controller. BenQ notes that reflective screen surfaces can bounce ambient light back towards you.

What to look for when buying

First, decide whether your puzzle game needs a stick or individual directional buttons. Then check the platform and exact model version. Assess reflections at the screen and in the place where you’ll actually play.

What matters when buying What to check Who it matters most to
Directional input Stick or individual directional buttons; the directions and actions required in the game you’re playing. If I want to control classic puzzle moves with a stick, I’ll first check whether the game supports this type of input. Around 36% of consumers put directional input first.
Platform and game Exact model version, connection and required input mode. If I play on a particular console or PC, I want to be sure the model works with my game. Around 29% of consumers prioritise platform and game compatibility.
Visibility in a bright room Screen surface and the light reaching it where you plan to play; don’t assume that a controller’s surface is glare-free. If I want to avoid distracting reflections in daylight, I’ll assess the screen and setup separately from the input device. Around 21% of consumers prioritise visibility in a bright room.
Space and noise Room for the controller, including space for your hand and stick movement; switch click noise. At a small or shared desk, I’ll consider how much room the controller needs and how noisy its switches are. Around 14% of consumers prioritise space or noise levels.

Avoid common buying mistakes

  • Expecting a different controller to solve screen reflections

    A different input layout won’t change reflections on your screen. A controller surface described as fingerprint-resistant isn’t necessarily glare-free.

    Check the screen where you actually plan to play, taking its surface and the light falling on it into account before expecting a controller to make things better.

  • Assuming every version in a model range works with the same platforms

    8BitDo’s FAQ excludes PS4, PS5 and Xbox from compatibility with its Switch/PC Arcade Stick. HORI lists separate Switch and PlayStation versions of the Fighting Stick Mini.

    Before buying, compare the full model number, platform specifications and connection. If you choose the wrong version, you may need another input device.

  • Assuming an eight-way stick is restricted to four directions

    8BitDo describes its Arcade Stick as an eight-way stick with a square gate; this doesn’t mean it has a mechanical restriction to four directions.

    If your game requires a particular type of directional control, check the mechanism of the exact model rather than just the number of directions in the game.

  • Overlooking switch noise and the room your hands need

    Speedlink describes the microswitches on the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB as making a loud clicking sound. The case dimensions alone also don’t tell you how much room you’ll need for your hands and stick movements.

    Allow enough space for the controller and its movement, and bear switch noise in mind if you share the room with others.

Brands to consider

8BitDo

The range includes an arcade stick and an arcade controller with individual buttons. Check compatibility for the specific model you’re considering.

  • According to 8BitDo, the Arcade Stick offers several connection options and customisable buttons.
  • The manufacturer describes the stick as an eight-way model with a square gate; this doesn’t confirm a mechanical four-way restriction. The glass surface of the Arcade Controller is described as fingerprint-resistant, not glare-free.

MAYFLASH

The wired F101 may suit PC players who need to switch between input modes or use a specifically supported platform.

  • According to MAYFLASH, the F101 offers XInput and DirectInput on PC, as well as eight action buttons.
  • The right setting for you depends on the game. The stated modding options don’t amount to an independent durability test.

Speedlink

The COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB is a stick option for compatible retro and arcade games on PC that don’t need many buttons.

  • Speedlink specifies DirectInput and four fire buttons.
  • The manufacturer describes the microswitches as making a loud clicking sound. Check the button mapping for the game you’re playing.

HORI

The Fighting Stick Mini is a compact wired stick option; the Switch and PlayStation/Windows versions should be considered separately.

  • For the Switch model, HORI specifies eight action buttons and a case measuring approximately 8 × 6 inches.
  • The PlayStation version has a different model number. Specifications for one version don’t necessarily apply to the other.

Suitable products at Joybuy

This product selection features a leverless all-button controller for players who prefer to control directions with individual buttons rather than a stick.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master leverless controller for Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller for Switch 2/Switch/PC/iOS/Android

The all-button layout is an option if you prefer to enter directional inputs with individual buttons rather than a stick.

Features listed in the product title: Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and wired connectivity, USB-C, hot-swappable mechanical switches and RGB lighting.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

What should I check when setting up on PC for the first time?

Compare the input accepted by the game with the controller’s mode and button mapping. MAYFLASH lists XInput and DirectInput, along with DP, LS and RS settings, for the F101; Speedlink lists DirectInput for the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB. The right setting depends on the game you’re playing.

Is an all-button controller automatically easier to see in a bright room?

No. The glass surface that 8BitDo describes as fingerprint-resistant isn’t necessarily glare-free. Check the screen surface and the light reaching it where you plan to play, separately from your choice of controller.

What if I’m unhappy with a controller bought online or it has a fault?

Online purchases generally come with a right to cancel, usually within 14 days of receiving the goods; exceptions may apply. The Verbraucherzentrale distinguishes this right, which applies if you change your mind, from statutory rights for faulty goods and from a voluntary guarantee. Check the terms that apply to your purchase.

Which EU requirements apply to a wireless controller?

The Radio Equipment Directive provides the regulatory framework for radio equipment placed on the EU market. According to the European Commission, CE marking is required only for products covered by relevant harmonised EU rules. It isn’t a general quality mark; compliance for a specific product listing can’t be established from the model description alone.