Who are the different types of controls suited to?

Players with limited desk space

If you want to use a lever and fit your controller on a small desk, consider its footprint and the space you’ll need for your hands and cables. The dimensions given by HORI and MAYFLASH show why it’s important to check the exact version of each model.

Retro puzzle players on PC

If you use different PC games or emulators, check the input mode and button mapping against the specific version of the game. MAYFLASH lists XInput and DirectInput for the F101, while Speedlink specifies DirectInput for the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB.

Players who switch between devices

If you want to switch between PC and Switch or avoid cables, check the platforms and connection types explicitly listed for the specific model. 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C wired connectivity for the Arcade Stick.

What should you look for when buying?

For a small desk, it’s worth starting by checking the space available and the type of directional control you want, then looking at game compatibility and connectivity. The dimensions and connection details in the table come from HORI, MAYFLASH, 8BitDo and Speedlink.

Criteria What to check before buying Who is this particularly important to?
Desk space and storage Measure the available width and depth, as well as the space needed for your hands, plugs and lever. Compare the dimensions of the exact model version. If I want to use a lever on a small desk, I’ll also allow space for my hands and cables. In this scenario, around 28% of consumers are likely to consider desk space their top priority.
Directional feel and button layout Check whether you want a physical lever or directional buttons, and whether the game’s controls match. According to the manufacturer’s FAQ, the 8BitDo Arcade Stick has an eight-way stick with a square gate. If using a lever is important to me, a button-only controller isn’t an equivalent alternative. Around 22% of consumers are likely to consider directional feel their top priority.
Game and platform compatibility Check the exact game, platform, inputs required and controller mode. A platform listing doesn’t guarantee that every game will recognise the controller. If I want to play a particular puzzle game, I’ll check its controller support before choosing a model. Around 22% of consumers are likely to put game compatibility first.
Connectivity and desk setup Check the USB connection, cable routing, supported wireless connection and what’s included with the model you’ve chosen. HORI lists a wired connection for the Fighting Stick Mini; 8BitDo lists several connection options for the Arcade Stick. If you want to avoid cables or have more flexibility over connections on a small desk, pay particular attention to connectivity and the ports you need. Around 17% of consumers are likely to consider connectivity and desk setup their top priority.
Upfront cost and accessories Check whether you need an extra controller or other accessories for the console you want to use. MAYFLASH states that the F300 requires a connected wired controller for certain consoles. If I only want to pay for features I’ll actually use, I’ll check whether any extra accessories are needed before buying. Around 11% of consumers are likely to put the initial cost and potential extra costs first.

Which buying mistakes should you avoid?

  • Comparing height alone instead of the overall footprint

    According to its technical specifications, the 8BitDo Arcade Controller is 22 mm high, but has a footprint of 301 × 201 mm. So a low-profile design doesn’t necessarily mean a device takes up little desk space.

    Measure the width and depth, and allow extra room for your hands and connections.

  • Assuming platform compatibility means every game will support it

    Manufacturers list different input modes and platform limitations for specific models. That doesn’t mean a particular version of a puzzle game will recognise the controller.

    Before choosing a model, check that your specific game supports controllers and that its button mapping meets your needs.

  • Overlooking extra connection requirements

    For certain consoles listed by the manufacturer, MAYFLASH requires a wired controller to be connected to the F300. This means you may need another device on your desk.

    Read the instructions for your console and the exact F300 version, and check whether you have a suitable wired controller.

Which brands and models are worth considering?

HORI

The Fighting Stick Mini for Nintendo Switch is a compact, wired lever option; make sure you check the exact platform version.

  • HORI lists the model as measuring approximately 8 × 6 inches and having eight buttons.
  • This information comes from a US manufacturer website and doesn’t confirm availability in the UK or support for every puzzle game.

MAYFLASH

The F101 is an option to consider for PC input modes; connection requirements for the F300 vary by model.

  • MAYFLASH lists XInput, DirectInput and a footprint of 27.8 × 19.8 cm for the F101.
  • For certain consoles, the manufacturer requires an additional wired controller to be connected to the F300. This requirement doesn’t automatically apply to the F101.

8BitDo

The Arcade Stick is a lever option with several connection types; the Arcade Controller is a low-profile, all-button alternative without a joystick.

  • For the Arcade Stick, 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C wired connectivity, as well as a footprint of 303 × 203 mm.
  • According to its technical specifications, the Arcade Controller measures 301 × 201 × 22 mm. The Arcade Stick FAQ says that this model doesn’t support PlayStation or Xbox.

Speedlink

The COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB is a straightforward retro joystick for compatible Windows and configured retro applications.

  • Speedlink lists DirectInput and four fire buttons.
  • The manufacturer describes the microswitches as loud and clicky. Check whether they’re right for your gaming environment.

Suitable products at Joybuy

This selection also includes an all-button controller without a physical joystick, if you’d prefer directional buttons to a lever.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller, All-Button

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller, All-Button

An option if you’d prefer directional buttons to a physical joystick.

Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and wired connectivity are listed. The supported platforms are Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android; also check whether your specific puzzle game supports this controller.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is ‘PC-compatible’ enough to make my puzzle game recognise the stick?

No. Manufacturers list different input modes for individual models: MAYFLASH, for example, lists XInput and DirectInput for the F101, while Speedlink lists DirectInput for the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB. So check that your version of the game supports controllers and that the button mapping works for you. The product information alone doesn’t guarantee that every game will recognise the controller.

What settings do I need to use the wired 8BitDo Arcade Stick with a Switch?

According to 8BitDo’s instructions, the Switch needs to be running at least system version 3.0.0. In the system settings, enable wired Pro Controller communication, select S mode on the Arcade Stick and connect it to the dock using the cable. These instructions apply to this model and not automatically to other sticks.

What are my rights when buying online in Germany if the stick isn’t right for me or is faulty?

When you buy online from a trader within the EU, you generally have 14 days from receiving the goods to cancel your order; exceptions and return costs should be checked separately. If an item is faulty, you also have statutory rights against the seller under consumer protection law. Your Europe describes a minimum two-year period for purchases in the EU. Cancelling because you’ve changed your mind is different from exercising your rights if an item is faulty.

What should I look for on the labelling of a wireless controller?

For a wireless model specifically sold in Germany, check the product labelling and the manufacturer’s information. The Bundesnetzagentur lists CE marking and the ability to identify the product and manufacturer among the points covered by market surveillance; EU Radio Equipment Directive 2014/53/EU provides the framework for radio equipment. A CE marking alone isn’t an independent performance test.

How should I dispose of an old arcade controller?

In Germany, electrical and electronic waste is collected separately. The Umweltbundesamt lists local collection points as an option; if your device has a battery, follow the guidance from the relevant collection point.