Which arcade stick is right for you?

Puzzle fans with a specific console

If you want to use an arcade stick with a console, check the full model variant and your game's inputs against your device. 8BitDo, MAYFLASH and HORI list different platform and model details.

Players in a dark room

If you want to see the buttons more clearly in low light, check whether the controls themselves are illuminated. 8BitDo describes changing button labels, while Qanba lists RGB elements on certain Q8 versions.

Evening PC gamers

If you play on PC, the space it takes up, its connection type and any switch noise may all influence your choice. MAYFLASH lists several PC input modes for the F500 Elite. Qanba describes components on certain Q8 versions as “Silent”, but does not provide a noise measurement.

What should you look for when buying?

First, think about which features matter most for your game and where you plan to set up your stick. Then check the exact model variant against those needs.

Buying criterion What to look for Who it matters most to
Platform and game Check the full model name, platform version, input mode and in-game controls. Also check whether you need an adapter or firmware update. If I want to play a particular puzzle game on my console or PC, I check whether that exact combination supports the inputs I want. Around 33% of consumers put platform and game first.
Directional control and button layout Compare the directions and actions required by the game with the stick, input mode and button layout. If the feel of the controls and the button layout for puzzle actions matter most to me, I compare both with the game's requirements. Around 27% of consumers make directional control their top priority.
Controls in the dark Check which buttons are actually illuminated on the exact model variant and whether you can adjust the lighting. If I want to find the right buttons in low light, I look for illuminated controls rather than just status lights or changing labels. Around 27% of consumers prioritise visibility in the dark.
Noise in the evening Check the exact stick and button variants. If needed, look for a reliable noise measurement of the complete device. If I play in the evening and don’t want to disturb anyone, the noise from the whole stick matters. Around 13% of consumers give quiet evening play their highest priority.

Common buying misconceptions

  • Confusing status lights or changing labels with illuminated action buttons

    These features do not necessarily solve the same visibility problem. Changing button labels does not mean the action buttons are illuminated.

    For the exact model variant, check which controls are actually lit and whether you can adjust the lighting.

  • Assuming similar model names mean the same console support

    8BitDo lists separate Switch and Xbox versions, while HORI offers Fighting Stick α models for different platforms. Certain MAYFLASH connections may also require additional accessories.

    Before buying, check the full model number, console, game and connection setup together.

    Depending on the MAYFLASH model and console, you may need a suitable adapter or other connection components.

  • Assuming “Silent” means completely noise-free gaming

    Qanba uses the term for certain Q8 components; it is not an independent measurement of the noise produced by the complete stick.

    Check the exact configuration. If quiet gaming is important to you, look for a reliable measurement or try the stick for yourself.

Key brands to help you choose

8BitDo

The arcade sticks for Switch/Windows and Xbox/Windows are different versions. Check the full version name and the platform you use for your game.

  • For its Switch/Windows stick, 8BitDo describes Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz, USB-C and changing visual button labels.
  • Changing labels do not prove that the action buttons are illuminated or that the stick is compatible with every game.

MAYFLASH

The F300 Elite and F500 Elite are customisable arcade sticks, each with its own model and connection requirements.

  • MAYFLASH lists Sanwa components. It also lists XInput and DInput modes for the F500 Elite on PC.
  • MAYFLASH says that connecting to PS5 may depend on the model, suitable accessories and firmware. This is not an independently measured claim about in-game performance.

HORI

The Fighting Stick Mini SPF-038U is a compact option for the PlayStation systems and Windows listed by the manufacturer. The Fighting Stick α is available in separate versions for different platforms.

  • HORI lists eight buttons and a base measuring around 8 × 6 inches for the Mini. The manufacturer says the α models’ casing can be opened for maintenance and customisation.
  • HORI does not list a touchpad for the Mini. The different α model numbers do not refer to the same platform version.

Qanba

The Q8 is worth considering if you play on PC and are interested in illuminated controls and components described as quiet.

  • Qanba describes RGB elements and “Silent” components on certain Q8 versions.
  • Specifications vary. A product page for the Q8-SS does not prove that noise levels have been measured or that the product is available in Germany.

Joybuy product selection

This selection covers arcade controllers for puzzle gaming. The model listed is leverless, so it does not have a traditional stick.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

If you’re specifically looking for a controller without a traditional stick, this leverless model is a style worth considering.

The product name lists Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android, along with Bluetooth, 2.4G and wired connections.

It also lists hot-swappable fast-trigger mechanical switches and RGB lighting.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is “compatible with my console” enough to know it will work with my puzzle game?

No. That alone does not confirm whether the specific game supports the directional and action inputs you want to use. Check the model variant, input mode and in-game controls separately. 8BitDo lists Switch and Windows for the original Arcade Stick, and offers a separate Xbox version.

How do I connect the 8BitDo Arcade Stick to a Switch using a cable?

To connect it as described in the 8BitDo manual, enable wired Pro Controller communication in the system settings, select S mode on the stick and connect it to the dock using USB-C. The manual specifies that the Switch must be running at least system version 3.0.0.

What should I bear in mind when maintaining or modifying a stick?

First, check whether the exact model can be opened and is designed for the parts you want to replace. HORI describes the Fighting Stick α casing as openable, while MAYFLASH describes the F300 Elite as customisable. This does not mean that any parts will fit. If there is a fault, remember that your statutory rights are separate from any voluntary warranty.

Can I return an arcade stick bought online in Germany if I’m not happy with it?

Online purchases are generally covered by a statutory right of withdrawal. According to Verbraucherzentrale, this usually applies for 14 days after you receive the goods, and you must notify the other party to the contract that you are withdrawing. If a product is faulty, you also have statutory rights against the seller. A manufacturer’s warranty is separate.

What should I know about labelling and disposal in Germany?

The Bundesnetzagentur lists checks for CE marking, product identification and manufacturer details among its market surveillance activities. For covered electrical and electronic equipment, the European Union points to the crossed-out wheelie bin symbol and separate collection. This does not mean that any specific model mentioned here has been tested.