Which arcade stick is right for you?

Players practising joystick movements

If you want to enter combos using a physical joystick, check the layout and input mode for the specific game you play. The product information from 8BitDo and MAYFLASH describes different input options.

Players switching between console and PC

Check the exact model variant and connection against your devices. Adapters and firmware can also matter for some combinations, as HORI, 8BitDo and MAYFLASH note in their product information.

Players at a bright desk

In daylight, a screen that’s easy to see and enough room for your hands, the casing and cables are important. The German Social Accident Insurance (DGUV) covers screen glare, not the legibility of specific stick labels.

What should you look for when buying?

First decide which type of input you want to practise, then check compatibility, space and setup requirements for your device.

What you need What to check Who is this important to?
Directional and action inputs Check whether you want a joystick or an all-button layout, as well as the button mapping and directional mode in your game. If I want to practise the inputs my game requires, the controls need to suit those movements. Around 26% of consumers put the right input method first.
Compatibility Check the full model name, gaming system and, if needed, adapter and firmware. If you want to use the same input style on a console or PC, check the exact variant. Around 26% of consumers prioritise compatibility with their gaming system.
Visibility in daylight Position the screen away from direct reflections and consider any available glare protection. If I want to see the game and on-screen information clearly in daylight, I start by looking at the screen and where it’s positioned. Around 21% of consumers say visibility while gaming is their main concern.
Space where you play Check the casing dimensions and leave room for your hands, joystick movement and cable routing. If you practise at a desk with limited space, you’ll need to fit the stick, your hands and the cables together. Around 16% of consumers focus mainly on desk space and hand position.
Setup and maintenance Check what accessories you need, along with firmware, access to the casing and the requirements for compatible replacement parts. If I want to keep the setup straightforward and consider maintenance options, I check the necessary steps and parts in advance. Around 11% of consumers place the greatest importance on these additional requirements.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming a general platform listing guarantees PS5 compatibility

    MAYFLASH says that using the specified F300 and F500 models with PS5 requires the MagicBoots-S5 and compatible firmware.

    Check the model number, firmware and required converter as a complete combination.

    The MAYFLASH configurations described may require a separate adapter, adding to the setup process.

  • Assuming similarly named PlayStation and Xbox variants are interchangeable

    HORI lists separate PlayStation and Xbox versions of the Fighting Stick α range, while 8BitDo also specifies different platforms for its models.

    Check the full model name against your console, not just the product family name.

  • Expecting an arcade stick to solve screen glare

    Glare affects how clearly you can see the screen. For screen-based workstations, the German Social Accident Insurance (DGUV) recommends positioning yourself so that your line of sight is parallel to the window front.

    Position your screen and any available blinds or curtains to suit the daylight, and assess the stick labels separately.

  • Using all-button inputs as a substitute for joystick practice

    Pressing individual directional buttons involves a different hand movement from using a physical joystick.

    Choose your input method based on the movement you want to practise, and check the platform requirements for all-button models too.

Brands to consider

HORI

The Fighting Stick α range includes separate PlayStation and Xbox versions. The key is choosing the variant for your gaming system.

  • HORI describes the PlayStation model as having a customisable casing that opens for maintenance, with Hayabusa controls.
  • These features don’t prove a higher combo success rate, and the console variants aren’t interchangeable.

MAYFLASH

The F300 Elite and F500 Elite are joystick sticks; the F500 FLAT Elite is an all-button alternative.

  • MAYFLASH specifies Sanwa controls for its Elite joystick models.
  • For the PS5 use described with MagicBoots-S5, you’ll need to check the compatible model and firmware. The F500 FLAT Elite has its own connection requirements.

8BitDo

The Arcade Stick for Switch and Windows and the separate Xbox version are designed for different platforms.

  • 8BitDo describes profiles and a changing visual button layout when switching modes on its Switch/Windows stick.
  • The product information doesn’t show that the labels are easier to read in bright daylight; the Xbox version has a different compatibility list.

Qanba

Qanba lists the Obsidian 2 as a joystick model for PS5, PS4 and PC.

  • According to Qanba, it comes with 30 mm Sanwa buttons, a Sanwa JLF joystick and a tournament-lock switch.
  • These are the manufacturer’s specifications for the Obsidian 2, not an independent performance comparison or a verdict on the entire range.

Nacon

Nacon offers the Daija in a PlayStation version for PS5, PS4 and PC.

  • Nacon lists Sanwa joystick and action buttons, configuration software and a detachable 3-m cable.
  • Check the exact variant and allow enough room for the casing and cable routing where you play.

Joybuy products

This selection focuses on an all-button layout without a joystick for fighting game combos. It trains a different hand movement from a stick with a physical joystick.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

The all-button layout is a good fit if you want to practise directional inputs using individual buttons rather than a joystick.

Listed systems: Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android.

Listed connections: wired, Bluetooth and 2.4 GHz.

The product title mentions hot-swappable Fast-Trigger Mechanical Switches and RGB lighting.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does a backlit arcade stick make the screen easier to see in a bright room?

Lighting on the stick can’t replace a well-positioned screen or glare protection. For screen-based workstations, the German Social Accident Insurance (DGUV) recommends positioning your line of sight parallel to the window front. Assess the stick labels separately in your own gaming setup.

Can I use the MAYFLASH F300 Elite or F500 Elite with PS5 straight away?

Not based on a general platform listing alone. MAYFLASH says these models require the MagicBoots-S5 adapter and compatible firmware for PS5 use. Before buying, check the combination for your exact model.

How should I set up the buttons for practising combos?

First check which directional and action inputs your game requires. 8BitDo describes profiles for its Switch/Windows arcade stick. Set up the button mapping to suit your game, then check the inputs in training mode if your game provides a suitable display.

What should I do if the stick wears out or develops a fault?

First check your statutory rights to goods of satisfactory quality with the seller; these are separate from any voluntary guarantee. The Verbraucherzentrale explains the difference and your rights if goods are faulty. Check separately whether replacement parts you buy yourself are compatible with your exact model.

Do you have a right to cancel an online purchase in Germany?

For a consumer contract made at a distance, there is generally a statutory right to cancel, with a cancellation period of 14 days. You must notify the trader that you wish to cancel. The relevant statutory conditions apply to goods and any legal exceptions; the German Federal Ministry of Justice and the Verbraucherzentrale explain the rules.