Who are the different input styles suited to?

Platform game players with a specific system

If you’re practising a particular game on PC or console, first check that the exact controller version works with your platform and game. For example, 8BitDo lists separate Switch/Windows and Xbox models, while HORI also offers different platform versions.

Players focusing on directional input

If you want to practise directions, jumps or dashes repeatedly, the input style is a key consideration: a joystick reproduces joystick movements, while an all-button controller enters directions using individual buttons. Check that your game supports the layout you want.

Players who enjoy long sessions

If you’re planning longer practice sessions, consider the space you have, how easily you can reach the buttons and whether the cable can be routed conveniently. Product features alone can’t tell you how a controller will feel in your hands.

What should you look for when buying?

First, work out which type of movement input you want and check that it’s supported by your specific game. Then you can weigh up the space you have, connection options and maintenance requirements.

Arcade stick with joystick

A good fit if: you specifically want to practise joystick movements and the exact model works with your system and game.

Consider: The joystick takes up space, and different platform versions aren’t interchangeable.

Leverless or all-button controller

A good fit if: you want to enter directions using individual buttons and the game, layout and platform are all compatible.

Consider: The input style is different from using a joystick, so you may need to practise with it.

Keep using your current controller for now

A good fit if: you haven’t yet confirmed that an arcade controller supports the inputs you need for your game or platform.

Consider: You won’t yet get the arcade-style input feel you’re looking for.

Buying priority What to look for Who it matters most to
Platform and game compatibility Check the model number, platform, game and input mode together; check whether you need an adapter or firmware. If I’m looking for a controller for a particular system and platform game, that exact combination needs to work. Around 31% of consumers are likely to prioritise compatibility above all else.
Directional input Check the directions and button layout your game requires; joystick and all-button layouts differ. If I want to practise directional, jump or dash inputs, the input style is one of my first decisions. Around 25% of consumers are likely to prioritise directional practice above all else.
Ease of use during long sessions Consider the space you have and how easily you can reach the buttons; don’t assume the design guarantees greater comfort. If I’m practising for long periods, I want to position the controller and my hands comfortably in my gaming space. Around 19% of consumers are likely to prioritise ease of use during long sessions above all else.
Connection and power Check the connection options for the exact model and the ports available on your gaming device. If I need to choose between wireless and wired play, the setup in my gaming space is key. Around 13% of consumers are likely to prioritise connection options above all else.
Maintenance and ongoing costs Check access to the casing, compatible parts and any accessories you’ll need before buying. If I use a controller often, I want to know whether it can be maintained and whether I’ll need accessories for the way I plan to use it. Around 12% of consumers are likely to prioritise maintenance and ongoing costs above all else.

Common buying misconceptions

  • A fighting stick will automatically work with every platform game on the console listed

    Support for a platform doesn’t automatically confirm that a particular model and game support the inputs you need. MAYFLASH limits the stated PS5 use of the F500 FLAT Elite to fighting games and specifies that a separate converter is required.

    Check the model number, game and platform together. Treat the F500 Elite and the leverless F500 FLAT Elite as different models.

    For the stated PS5 use of the F500 FLAT Elite, you’ll need to buy a separate converter; the stated restriction to certain games still applies.

  • The name Fighting Stick α is enough to choose the right HORI version

    HORI lists SPF-013U as the PlayStation version and AB11-001U as the Xbox version. The shared product range name alone doesn’t tell you which version works with your system.

    Check the full model number and listed platform before making your choice.

  • A low-profile design or marketing claim guarantees greater comfort during long sessions

    The design can’t predict how button reach or hand position will feel for you. A manufacturer’s claim about input precision also isn’t independent evidence of performance in platform games or during long practice sessions.

    Consider the surface you’ll use, button reach and cable routing in your gaming space. Stop playing if you feel pain or tingling, and seek medical advice if symptoms keep coming back.

Brands and product ranges at a glance

8BitDo

The arcade sticks are available in separate versions for different platforms.

  • According to 8BitDo, the Switch/Windows version offers Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C, as well as an eight-way joystick with a square gate.
  • The Xbox version is a separate model. The platform details for the Switch/Windows version don’t apply to it.

HORI

The Fighting Stick α range includes separate PlayStation and Xbox versions.

  • According to HORI, the casing can be opened for maintenance and customisation.
  • SPF-013U and AB11-001U identify different platform versions; the shared product range name is no substitute for checking the model.

MAYFLASH

The range includes joystick models such as the F300 Elite and F500 Elite, as well as all-button versions in the F500-FLAT range.

  • MAYFLASH lists interchangeable components for the F300 Elite. For the F500 Elite, the manufacturer specifies firmware V1.19 with MagicBoots-S5 for PS5 games.
  • For the F500 FLAT Elite, MAYFLASH describes PS5 use with a separately available converter for fighting games only. This doesn’t confirm that it’s suitable for PS5 platform games.

Razer

The Kitsune is an all-button alternative for PS5 and PC.

  • Razer lists four movement buttons, a low-profile design and a detachable USB-C cable.
  • A manufacturer’s claim of superior input precision isn’t independent evidence of performance in platform games or comfort during long sessions.

Hit Box Arcade

The Hit Box ULTRA is an all-button model with platform-specific start modes.

  • Hit Box lists PS5, Xbox Series S|X, Switch and PC as supported platforms.
  • According to the manufacturer, you need to select the appropriate start mode for each platform other than PC. This doesn’t automatically mean that every individual game supports all the inputs you want.

Joybuy products for arcade platform games

Joybuy products for players who want an all-button layout rather than a joystick for arcade platform games.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

The all-button layout is an option if you want to enter directions using buttons rather than a joystick; check which layout your particular game requires.

The product description lists Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android, as well as Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and wired connections.

It also lists hot-swappable fast-trigger mechanical switches. Check compatibility with your game and system.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is ‘PS5 compatible’ enough to know it’ll work with my PS5 platform game?

No, the platform listing alone isn’t enough. MAYFLASH describes PS5 use of the F500 FLAT Elite with a separately available converter for fighting games only. For the F500 Elite, MAYFLASH specifies firmware V1.19 with MagicBoots-S5 for PS5 games. Check the model, accessories and specific game separately.

How do I set up a wireless arcade stick?

With the 8BitDo Arcade Stick for Switch and Windows, setup depends on whether you choose USB-C, Bluetooth or 2.4 GHz mode. The supplied USB receiver is used for the 2.4 GHz connection. Follow the instructions for your exact model version and platform.

What should I do if my hand hurts or tingles during long sessions?

Stop playing and seek medical advice if symptoms persist or keep coming back. According to gesund.bund.de, overuse and incorrect strain on the wrist can play a role in symptoms; this doesn’t establish whether a particular controller design is medically suitable.

Who should I contact if a product develops a fault after purchase?

For purchases from a business seller, you’re generally entitled to a legal guarantee lasting at least two years from the date you receive the goods; your point of contact is the seller. This is separate from any voluntary manufacturer’s warranty. The EU rules explained by Your Europe don’t apply to purchases from private individuals.

What should I look for in a wireless controller in Germany?

For products of this kind, the Bundesnetzagentur lists checks including the CE marking, being able to identify the product, accurate manufacturer details and German-language instructions with the required usage and safety information. These checks don’t tell you whether a controller will work with your game.