Start by choosing an arcade stick that suits the directional and action inputs your particular puzzle game requires, and that works with your platform. An eight-way stick, a four-way-oriented model and a compact retro joystick all differ in how they control and in their design, so check the specifications against your game and device. In a bright room, assess screen visibility separately: a controller won’t change screen brightness, and you’ll also want to consider desk space, clicking noises and any adapters you may need.
Who might want an arcade stick
Fans of directional puzzles
If you’d like to play with classic left, right and action inputs using a joystick, check which directions you need, how the stick works and how its buttons are mapped. 8BitDo describes its Arcade Stick as an eight-way stick with a square gate; MAYFLASH specifies a four-way joystick for the F300 Elite.
Players using multiple systems
If you want to use the same controller with a PC and a console, check the full model name, connection type and input mode against your devices. 8BitDo and MAYFLASH list different platforms and connection options for their respective models.
Players with a bright room and limited space
In a brightly lit room, what matters is whether you can see the image clearly on your screen; check the screen’s brightness and position directly. If you have limited desk space or share the room, also consider the dimensions of the stick you’re interested in and any model-specific information about clicking noises from HORI, Speedlink and other manufacturers.
What to consider when buying
First, check your game’s controls and whether the stick is compatible with your platform. Then assess your screen in the bright room, and finally make room for the stick and consider noise levels and any accessories you might need.
| What matters |
What to look for when buying |
Who should pay particular attention |
| Directions and action buttons |
Note the inputs your game requires and check the joystick, gate, buttons and button mapping for the exact model. |
If you want to play puzzle classics using specific directions and actions directly on the stick, the right mechanism is what matters most. Around 36% of consumers say directional controls are their main concern. |
| Platform and game |
Check the model version, operating system or console version, connection type and input mode; confirm that the controls work with your game. |
If you want to use the controller with your existing PC or console, check the requirements for your specific devices and game. Around 29% of consumers put platform compatibility first. |
| Screen visibility in a bright room |
Check the screen’s position and brightness on the display you’ll actually use; the documented brightness controls on the Nintendo Switch apply in handheld and tabletop modes. |
If you want to see the game clearly in bright surroundings, check the display separately from the controller. Around 21% of consumers prioritise screen visibility. |
| Space and clicking noises |
Compare dimensions, room for your hands and cable routing; only apply noise information to the specific model it refers to. |
If you have limited desk space or want to be considerate of others in the room while playing, the design and model-specific noise information are key. Around 14% of consumers prioritise space and noise. |
How to avoid common buying mistakes
-
Expecting a new controller to make a hard-to-see image clearer
Brightness settings affect the Nintendo Switch screen, not a connected arcade stick. Changing controllers won’t automatically solve a display problem.
Check visibility and brightness settings on the screen you actually use, and choose your stick separately based on its controls and compatibility.
-
Assuming a platform listing guarantees compatibility with every game
A model’s compatibility doesn’t remove the need to check it against your specific game and the required input mode. For the PS5 use of the MAYFLASH F300 Elite described in its documentation with firmware V1.15, MAYFLASH specifies an additional MagicBoots-S5 adapter; when connecting the 8BitDo Arcade Stick to Windows over 2.4 GHz, you’ll need to check the mode and receiver.
Check the full model name, firmware, connection and input modes, and the actions required by your game.
Depending on the model and connection, you may need extra accessories and setup steps.
-
Treating four-way and eight-way sticks as the same
MAYFLASH describes the F300 Elite as a four-way joystick and also specifies an octagonal gate. 8BitDo describes its Arcade Stick as an eight-way stick with a square gate; these specifications refer to different mechanisms.
First check which directions your puzzle game requires, then compare them with the mechanism on the specific model.
-
Overlooking clicking noises and space requirements
Speedlink describes the microswitches on the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB as producing a loud click. HORI lists a compact design for the Fighting Stick Mini; that doesn’t mean other models have the same noise or space requirements.
Allow for the space you’ll need and plan your cable routing. Only take noise information into account for the model you’re considering.
Key brands at a glance
8BitDo
According to the manufacturer, the 8BitDo Arcade Stick is aimed at Switch and Windows users who want a choice of connection types.
- 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C, as well as customisable button mapping.
- According to the manufacturer’s FAQ, the stick has an eight-way joystick with a square gate and doesn’t natively support PS4, PS5 or Xbox.
MAYFLASH
According to MAYFLASH, the wired F300 Elite is customisable and designed for several of the systems listed by the manufacturer.
- MAYFLASH lists Sanwa components, a four-way joystick and switchable directional inputs.
- For the documented PS5 use with firmware V1.15, MAYFLASH also specifies a MagicBoots-S5 adapter.
Speedlink
According to Speedlink, the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB is a retro joystick for Windows players who are happy with a few action buttons.
- Speedlink lists DirectInput and four fire buttons.
- Speedlink describes the microswitches as producing a loud click; according to the manufacturer, the included game bundle only runs on Windows.
HORI
According to HORI, the Fighting Stick Mini for Nintendo Switch is a compact, wired option with an eight-button layout and PC compatibility.
- HORI lists a microswitch joystick and casing dimensions of approximately 8 × 6 inches.
- The manufacturer’s specifications don’t confirm that every individual puzzle game is supported.
Qanba
According to Qanba, the Drone 2 is designed for PS5, PS4 and PC.
- Qanba lists a platform switch and a touchpad.
- A platform listing doesn’t replace checking that the controls work with your specific puzzle game.
Joybuy product selection
The selection shown here includes a leverless, all-button controller. It may suit you if you want to use buttons rather than a joystick for directional inputs; check the button mapping against your game.
No image available
BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller
This all-button controller is suitable for puzzle classics only if you want to use buttons rather than a joystick for directional inputs and the game supports the right button mapping.
The product title lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and wired connections, as well as support for Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android.
Features listed in the title include hot-swappable Fast Trigger switches and RGB lighting.
View on Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Does an arcade stick make the picture easier to see in a bright room?
No. An arcade stick controls inputs, not screen brightness. Nintendo describes brightness settings for the Switch screen in handheld and tabletop modes; for an external screen, check its own settings.
How do I connect the 8BitDo Arcade Stick to a Windows PC over 2.4 GHz?
According to 8BitDo’s Windows instructions, set the connection switch to 2.4G and the mode switch to X, then plug the supplied receiver into a USB port on your Windows device.
Do I need an accessory to use the MAYFLASH F300 Elite with PS5 games?
For the PS5 use specifically described with firmware V1.15, MAYFLASH specifies a MagicBoots-S5 adapter. Before buying, check the firmware and any accessories needed for your particular setup.
What’s the difference between a four-way and an eight-way stick?
The terms describe the directional mechanism specified by the manufacturer: MAYFLASH lists a four-way joystick for the F300 Elite, while 8BitDo lists an eight-way stick with a square gate for its Arcade Stick. The right option depends on the directional inputs and button mapping your specific game requires.
What should I look for when it comes to product safety?
When carrying out market surveillance, Germany’s Federal Network Agency (Bundesnetzagentur) checks criteria including the CE marking, whether a product can be identified, accurate manufacturer details, and instructions for use and warnings. These criteria don’t mean that a particular listing has been checked.