Puzzle gamers with a specific system in mind
You know which game and PC or console you’ll be using, and want to make sure its directional inputs, action buttons and input mode all work together.
An arcade stick can work with your puzzle classics, provided the specific game supports its directional and action inputs, input mode and exact model version. Then check that your PC or console is explicitly supported, and that the stick’s footprint, cable and clicking noise are suitable for your room. A compact stick may be wired, while a retro joystick won’t necessarily offer the button layout you need.
You know which game and PC or console you’ll be using, and want to make sure its directional inputs, action buttons and input mode all work together.
You put the stick away after playing, or share your desk with study materials. That makes the casing dimensions, room for your hands and cable routing important too.
You’d like to use a joystick, but also need to consider any clicking noises it might make. If the product is explicitly described as having loud clicks, that’s a good reason to check how noisy it is before choosing.
First compare the inputs your specific game needs with those on the stick, then check device compatibility. After that, measure the space available and consider whether clicking noises could be disruptive in your room.
| What matters | What to check before buying | Who it matters most to |
|---|---|---|
| Game controls | Check that the exact model has the number and layout of buttons needed for the game’s directional and action inputs. | If I need specific inputs for actions or menus, I want to find them on the stick. That’s why around 29% of consumers put suitable game controls first. |
| Device compatibility | Check the model version, operating system or console version, input mode and any connection requirements. | If I want to play on a device I already own, support for that exact model version matters to me. Around 29% of consumers prioritise compatibility with their gaming device and game. |
| Space and storage | Measure the available width and depth, and allow extra room for your hands, the joystick and the cable. | If I also need my desk for studying, I want to be able to put the stick away easily after playing. Around 24% of consumers put the available desk space first. |
| Clicking noises | If you’re sensitive to noise, look for specific information about the model or a chance to try it out. | If other people in the room are studying or relaxing, I want to know what clicking noises to expect before I buy. Around 18% of consumers say keeping noise to a minimum is a priority. |
8BitDo and HORI each offer different versions with different platform support. A shared brand or product family name doesn’t mean they work with the same devices.
Before buying, check the full model name and the platforms it explicitly supports.
Choosing the wrong one could mean you need to buy another compatible device.
For the MAYFLASH F300, the manufacturer says that a controller connected by cable is also required for PS4, Xbox One and Xbox 360. The stated PS5 adapter solution also has its own requirements.
Check the connection method for your specific console in the instructions for the exact model.
Speedlink describes the microswitches on the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB as making loud clicks. This doesn’t compare its volume with that of the other models.
If you share a room, check how noisy the model you’re considering is rather than trying to judge its volume from its design or connection type.
The Fighting Stick Mini range includes different model versions for different platforms, so check each one separately.
The Arcade Stick is an option if your device matches one of the supported Switch or Windows configurations.
The F300 may suit PC gamers who want to switch between input modes; the F300 Elite is a separate version with different components.
The COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB is a basic retro joystick for compatible Windows games, not necessarily a substitute for a stick with a more extensive button layout.
The Drone 2 may be worth considering if you’ll be using a PS5, PS4 or PC as your main gaming device.
No. Also check whether the specific game supports controllers, and whether the input mode, directional controls and action buttons are suitable. MAYFLASH lists XInput and DirectInput for the F300; Speedlink lists DirectInput for the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB.
For a Bluetooth connection, 8BitDo’s instructions specify using the BT connection switch and S mode. Then pair the stick through the Switch’s controller settings, and check the instructions and supported system version for your specific model.
It depends on your console and connection method. For the F300, MAYFLASH says a controller connected by cable is also required for PS4, Xbox One and Xbox 360. According to the manufacturer, the PS5 setup described with MagicBoots-S5 requires a compatible device and up-to-date firmware.
You generally have a right to cancel an applicable distance selling contract with a trader. According to the German Federal Ministry of Justice, the cancellation period for goods is usually 14 days from delivery; statutory exceptions apply. Return postage may be payable under the conditions set out by the European Union.
As part of its market surveillance, the German Federal Network Agency lists CE marking, product identification, manufacturer details, instructions in German and a declaration of conformity among the points to check. This doesn’t confirm anything about a particular product listing.