Which stick is right for you?

Playing while someone else is asleep

If you share a bedroom, pay particular attention to the noise made by the stick and buttons. A manufacturer’s claim about “Silent” components refers to the specific configuration.

Playing on a particular console or PC

If the stick needs to work with your gaming system, check the exact model version and which platforms it supports. Devices with similar names may differ.

Limited space on your desk or lap

If you want to set the stick up in a shared room and put it away after playing, compare its shape and dimensions. Also consider whether you prefer a traditional stick or a flat, all-button layout.

What should you look for when buying?

Traditional stick with components described as quiet

A good fit if: You play on PC and want to consider the stick and buttons from the outset. Qanba lists Gravity Silent components for one Q8 configuration.

The trade-off: Qanba also offers traditional Sanwa configurations, so check the exact version. The manufacturer’s claim doesn’t predict how loud the stick will be in your room.

Traditional stick you can modify

A good fit if: You want to keep the stick and choose the components yourself. HORI describes how to access the case of the Fighting Stick α SPF-013U, while MAYFLASH says the F300 Elite can be modified.

The trade-off: Being able to replace components doesn’t confirm that specific parts will fit or guarantee a particular noise level. Check connectors and dimensions before making any modifications.

Leverless, all-button controller

A good fit if: You’re happy to play without a stick and use a PC or Android device. Qanba lists quiet mechanical switches for the Ruby.

The trade-off: You use buttons for directional input, so make sure this suits you. Qanba lists the Ruby as available to pre-order on its German European website.

Wireless traditional stick

A good fit if: A cable is the main thing getting in the way in your shared room. 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C connectivity for Windows and Switch on its original Arcade Stick.

The trade-off: A wireless connection won’t automatically make the stick and buttons quieter. According to 8BitDo’s FAQ, this model doesn’t support PS4, PS5 or Xbox.

Buying priority What to check Who is this particularly important to?
Noise from the stick and buttons Check the exact stick and action-button configuration separately; don’t assume a specific noise level for the complete device. When I play at night, I want both the stick and buttons to make as little noise as possible. Consumers who prioritise quiet inputs account for around 33%.
Compatibility with your gaming system Check the model version, console or PC, and any adapters and firmware you may need. When I play on a particular console or PC, the stick needs to work with that exact system. Consumers who prioritise platform compatibility account for around 27%.
Space and positioning Compare the case dimensions, weight, underside and position you want to play in. When desk or lap space is limited, the design needs to fit and be easy to put away afterwards. Consumers who prioritise space account for around 20%.
Replaceable components Check access to the case, the dimensions and connectors of the replacement parts you’re planning to use, and what’s included. When I want to choose components myself or replace them later, I need a compatible design and must allow for the work involved. Consumers who prioritise customisation account for around 20%.

Common misconceptions

  • “Silent” means you won’t disturb anyone in the bedroom

    The term refers to highlighted components, not the noise level of the complete device when used and positioned in your particular way.

    Check the stick and buttons separately on the exact version you’re considering. Also think about how the device rests on your desk or lap and how you use it.

  • A similar model name means the same console support

    Platform compatibility varies between models. For using the MAYFLASH F500 Elite with PS5, the manufacturer’s guidance specifies a MagicBoots-S5 adapter and compatible firmware. The manufacturer’s FAQ says the original 8BitDo Arcade Stick doesn’t support PS4, PS5 or Xbox.

    Check the full model name against your system, and find out whether you need an adapter or firmware before deciding.

    An adapter may require additional hardware, so check that it’s designed for your exact model.

  • A modifiable stick is already a quiet stick

    Access to the case or the inclusion of standard Sanwa components doesn’t prove that specific Silent parts will fit or that modifications will produce a particular noise level.

    First check component dimensions, connectors and access to the case. Allow for compatible replacement parts and, if needed, tools and the work involved.

    Replacing components as planned may require extra parts and additional work.

Key brands at a glance

Qanba

Qanba offers the Q8 as a traditional PC stick and the Ruby as a leverless alternative for PC and Android.

  • For the appropriately configured Q8, Qanba describes a Silent stick and Silent buttons; for the Ruby, the manufacturer lists quiet mechanical switches.
  • The exact Q8 configuration matters, as traditional Sanwa versions are also available. The Silent claims are manufacturer descriptions, not the result of a specific noise test in a bedroom.

HORI

The Fighting Stick α SPF-013U combines a traditional stick with the PS5, PS4 and Windows 11/10 platforms listed by the manufacturer.

  • HORI describes a case that opens for access and maintenance.
  • The HAYABUSA stick and buttons aren’t described as especially quiet.

MAYFLASH

The manufacturer describes the F300 Elite as modifiable, while MAYFLASH lists Sanwa components for the F500 Elite.

  • The models have different case sizes, so check the exact model and its dimensions against the space you have available.
  • Sanwa components don’t guarantee quiet operation. For using the F500 Elite with PS5, the manufacturer’s guidance specifies a MagicBoots-S5 adapter and compatible firmware.

8BitDo

According to 8BitDo, the original Arcade Stick offers several connection options for Windows and Switch.

  • The manufacturer lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C.
  • According to 8BitDo’s FAQ, this particular model doesn’t support PS4, PS5 or Xbox. A wireless connection says nothing about the noise made by the stick and buttons.

Nacon

Nacon offers the Daija as a traditional stick for PlayStation and PC.

  • Nacon lists a Sanwa stick and action buttons, a detachable cable and interchangeable stick tops.
  • These features don’t mean the controls are particularly quiet.

Related products at Joybuy

This selection includes a leverless all-button controller for fighting games.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master leverless controller

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

Designed for fighting games, its all-button layout does away with the traditional stick.

Platforms: Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android.

Connections: Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and wired.

Mechanical Fast Trigger switches are hot-swappable.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Are headphones enough to avoid disturbing anyone at night?

Headphones affect the game audio, not the mechanical inputs. So check the stick and buttons separately. Qanba describes both types of component as “Silent” on the appropriately configured Q8, but this doesn’t tell you how loud it will be in your room.

Can I use the original 8BitDo Arcade Stick with a PS5?

Not according to 8BitDo’s manufacturer FAQ. This applies to the Arcade Stick model specified there; check other model versions separately.

How do I connect the Nacon Daija to PlayStation or PC?

According to Nacon, select PC, PS4 or PS5 mode on the device and connect it using the supplied USB cable. Make sure you choose the Daija PlayStation version that’s compatible with your system.

What should I check before replacing the buttons with quieter ones?

Check that the dimensions, connectors and installation are compatible with the specific case and replacement parts. HORI describes access to the inside of the Fighting Stick α, while Qanba lists Gravity-KS Silent buttons separately. This doesn’t prove that these specific products are compatible with each other.