Which stick is right for you?

Shoot-'em-up players with specific input needs

You want to map stick directions and repeated actions in a way your particular game accepts. The number of buttons, input mode and feel matter more than a blanket rating of a fight stick.

Players with a specific PC or console

You’re buying for a device you already own, so check the exact model variant, connection and any adapter requirements against your platform.

Players at a bright desk

You need a comfortable space to play and want to understand how light reflections might affect your game. Your view of the game also depends on the screen and its surroundings, not just the stick.

What should you consider when buying?

First, check that the stick’s inputs match those of the game you want to play, then confirm compatibility with your device. After that, you can assess visibility, desk space and any set-up requirements.

What matters when buying What to look for Who is this important to?
Directional and action inputs Check the inputs and button mapping for the specific game, as well as the stick’s input mode. If I want to control movements and repeated actions in a way that suits my shoot-'em-up, I check its inputs first. Around 36% of consumers put suitable directional and action inputs first.
Compatibility with your device and game Check the full model number, platform, connection and, where necessary, adapter or firmware requirements. If I want the stick to work with my existing PC or console, compatibility with that exact variant matters. Around 29% of consumers prioritise compatibility with their device.
Visibility and ease of use in daylight Check the screen and light sources around your play area for reflections; assess the controller’s labelling and surface in similar lighting. If I play in a bright room, I want to see the game and controls clearly. Around 21% of consumers prioritise visibility and ease of use in a bright room.
Desk space and set-up requirements Compare the case dimensions, including space for your hands and cables, as well as any accessory or maintenance requirements. If my desk is short on space or I want to avoid extra set-up, the size and requirements will influence my choice. Around 14% of consumers focus primarily on space and set-up.

Avoid common buying mistakes

  • Assuming similarly named sticks work with the same console version

    HORI sells separate variants for PlayStation and Xbox. According to the manufacturer’s FAQ, the original 8BitDo Arcade Stick does not support PS4, PS5 or Xbox consoles.

    Before buying, check the full model number against the manufacturer’s compatibility information for your device.

  • Assuming PS5 support without checking adapter and firmware requirements

    MAYFLASH makes the stated PS5 use of certain models conditional on using the MagicBoots-S5 adapter and the correct firmware version.

    Check the instructions and firmware version for your exact model before relying on this set-up.

    Depending on the set-up, you may need an additional adapter and time to update the firmware.

  • Buying an arcade stick to solve screen reflections

    Reflected light on your screen depends on the display and its surroundings, not the type of controller.

    Check the screen position and lighting in your actual play area separately from your choice of controller. BenQ Europe describes reflected light as light that reaches your eyes from the screen or its surroundings.

Brands and model ranges to consider

MAYFLASH

The F300 Elite and F500 Elite ranges are worth considering if you want to check and potentially adjust input modes or components.

  • For the F300 Elite, MAYFLASH documents switching between D-pad and analogue signals. For the stated PS5 use with MagicBoots-S5, the manufacturer specifies firmware V1.15.
  • For the F500 Elite, MAYFLASH documents a PS5-related firmware fix. These requirements apply to the specific model and do not replace the need to check that you have the right set-up.

8BitDo

According to the manufacturer, the original Arcade Stick is an option for specifically supported Switch and Windows set-ups.

  • 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C connectivity, along with customisable button mapping.
  • According to the manufacturer’s FAQ, this model does not support PS4, PS5 or Xbox consoles. Information about other 8BitDo models does not automatically apply to this stick.

HORI

The range runs from the compact Fighting Stick Mini SPF-038U to the opening-case Fighting Stick α; choosing the right platform variant is essential.

  • HORI lists eight action buttons and a size of around 8 × 6 inches for the Mini. The manufacturer says you can open the Fighting Stick α SPF-013U case for maintenance.
  • The Xbox variant AB11-001U has different platform compatibility from the SPF-013U. You cannot automatically apply one model’s dimensions and uses to the other.

Speedlink

According to the manufacturer, the Competition Pro Extra USB is designed for classic arcade and retro games on Windows PCs.

  • Speedlink lists DirectInput, four fire buttons and a rapid-fire mode.
  • The manufacturer describes the microswitches as making a loud clicking sound. PC compatibility does not mean it works with consoles.

Joybuy product selection

The Joybuy selection below includes a leverless all-button controller. It’s only an option if you want to use buttons rather than a lever to control directions and actions.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master leverless controller, all-button arcade stick

BIGBIG WON Fight Master leverless controller, all-button, for Switch 2/Switch/PC/iOS/Android

A good fit if you want to control directions and actions using buttons only; there is no physical lever.

Listed in the product title: Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and wired connectivity, plus Switch 2/Switch/PC/iOS/Android. Check compatibility with your specific game version and platform.

The title lists replaceable fast-trigger mechanical switches and RGB lighting.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Will an arcade stick automatically work with my shoot-'em-up?

No. First check which directional and action inputs your specific game version accepts, then check the input mode and platform compatibility of the stick’s full model. MAYFLASH documents signal switching for the F300 Elite, but that does not mean it works with every game.

How do I set up a MAYFLASH F300 Elite for PS5?

For use with the MagicBoots-S5 adapter, MAYFLASH specifies firmware V1.15. Before buying, check the firmware version and required adapter against the manufacturer’s instructions; the adapter is not necessarily included with the stick.

Will an arcade stick make the game easier to see in a bright room?

No. If light sources are reflected on your screen, check the position of the screen and lighting. Display visibility and choice of controller are separate considerations.

What are my rights when buying online from a trader?

For distance purchases, the European Union’s consumer portal generally explains that you have a 14-day cooling-off period; exceptions and the details of your specific purchase should be taken into account. If goods are faulty, the EU rules explained there provide a minimum legal guarantee of two years from receipt, which you can claim against the seller. This is separate from any voluntary manufacturer’s warranty.