Which stick is right for you?

Players with a specific console

If you already know which console and 2D fighter you’ll be using, check the details for the exact version of the stick rather than relying on a similar-sounding model name.

Players who want to keep the noise down

In a shared student room, noise from the joystick and buttons can matter. A “silent” label on individual components doesn’t automatically tell you how noisy the whole stick will be.

Players with a small desk

If you also need space for a keyboard or study materials, allow for the stick’s footprint, room for your hands and the cable route. Consider whether you’ll want to put it away after playing, too.

What to look for when buying

Start by checking compatibility with your platform and the specific game. Then measure your desk space and decide which input layout and connection type will work best for you.

What matters What to check before buying Who should pay particular attention?
Platform and game Check the full model name, platform and game details; take into account any adapters or firmware required. If I play on a specific console and a particular fighter, I want to avoid buying the wrong stick. Around 28% of consumers prioritise compatibility between the stick, platform and game.
Operating noise Check whether the description applies to the joystick, the buttons or both, and which version it refers to. In a shared room, I want to practise without unnecessarily disturbing my flatmates. Around 22% of consumers put noise from the joystick and buttons first.
Desk space and storage Compare the available desk width and depth, including room for your hands and the cable route, with the dimensions of the exact version. If I use the same desk for studying, I need space for my hands and materials, and I want to be able to put the stick away afterwards. Around 22% of consumers prioritise the space it takes up.
Input layout and maintenance Check that it has the buttons and modes you need; if you plan to modify it, check how easy it is to access the case and components. For my training, it matters whether the buttons and joystick suit my preferred input layout and can be maintained. Around 17% of consumers prioritise layout and ease of maintenance.
Cable and wireless connection Check the connection mode and ports you need; if it’s wireless, find out whether you’ll need a receiver. If a cable gets in the way on my desk, I want to choose a connection that suits my device and setup. Around 11% of consumers prioritise connection options and cable routing.

Avoiding common buying mistakes

  • Assuming similarly named platform versions are identical

    8BitDo offers separate arcade stick versions for Switch and PC, and for Xbox. For the MAYFLASH F300 Elite, the manufacturer says PS5 use requires compatible firmware and a MagicBoots-S5 adapter.

    Before ordering, compare the full model name with the platform details and check whether your system requires an adapter or a firmware update.

  • Assuming “silent” means noiseless

    Qanba describes the Q8 as having a silent joystick and silent buttons. That doesn’t tell you how noisy the complete stick will be in your room.

    Check which components the description applies to, and don’t assume a guaranteed noise level if you’re particularly sensitive to noise at home.

  • Measuring only the case

    Even a compact stick needs room for your hands, joystick movement and, where applicable, a cable.

    Measure the space available on the desk you’ll actually use, allowing for your hand position and the cable route.

  • Assuming programmable features are allowed at tournaments

    The rules published by Evo prohibit programmable hardware inputs, rapid-fire and hardware macros. These event rules don’t automatically apply to other tournaments.

    If you’re entering a competition, check its own controller rules and your exact setup in advance.

Brands to consider

HORI

The Fighting Stick Mini SPF-038U is a compact joystick arcade stick, while the Fighting Stick α is a differently designed PlayStation/PC range with accessible components.

  • HORI gives the Mini’s dimensions as approximately 8 × 6 inches and says it has eight action buttons; the model has no touchpad.
  • According to HORI, the α’s case opens for customisation and maintenance. This feature doesn’t automatically apply to the Mini.

Qanba

According to Qanba, the Q8 is designed for PC and features silent components; the Drone 2 is offered with PS5, PS4 and PC compatibility.

  • Qanba lists a silent joystick and silent buttons for the Q8; this doesn’t measure the noise level of the complete stick.
  • Qanba lists a touchpad for the Drone 2, but not the same silent components as for the Q8.

8BitDo

8BitDo offers separate arcade stick versions for Switch/PC and Xbox/Windows.

  • For the Switch/PC version, 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2,4 GHz and USB-C, along with button mapping.
  • The Xbox version has different platform specifications. If you plan to use the Switch/PC version’s macro features in a tournament, check them against the event rules.

MAYFLASH

The F300 Elite is a customisable joystick arcade stick that the manufacturer lists as compatible with several systems.

  • MAYFLASH lists Sanwa components and replaceable parts; the stated footprint is 30,2 × 23,6 cm.
  • For the manufacturer’s stated PS5 compatibility, compatible firmware and a MagicBoots-S5 adapter are required.

NACON

The PlayStation version of the Daija is a wired stick with accessible components.

  • NACON describes replaceable joystick and button components, as well as a platform selector.
  • NACON notes that some games requiring two joysticks to be used at the same time aren’t compatible.

Joybuy products

This product option is a leverless all-button controller for players looking for a Hitbox layout rather than a joystick arcade stick.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master leverless controller for Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

The all-button Hitbox layout is a leverless alternative for 2D fighters, not a joystick arcade stick.

Platforms listed in the product name: Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android.

Connection types listed in the product name: Bluetooth, 2,4 GHz and wired.

Feature listed in the product name: hot-swap fast-trigger switches.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is “PlayStation compatible” enough for my PS5 game?

No. Check the exact model version and the manufacturer’s details for your system and game. HORI lists the SPF-038U for PS5 and PS4; the manufacturer says PS5 use of the MAYFLASH F300 Elite requires compatible firmware and a MagicBoots-S5 adapter.

Is the Qanba Q8 really silent?

The “silent” label doesn’t mean the whole stick is noiseless. Qanba describes the Q8 as having a silent joystick and silent buttons, but the label alone can’t reliably tell you how noisy the complete device will be in your room.

Is the BIGBIG WON Fight Master a joystick arcade stick?

No. The listed model is described as a leverless, all-button Hitbox controller. If you specifically want to play with a joystick, this isn’t the input layout you’re looking for.

How do I connect the 8BitDo Arcade Stick to Windows?

For the Switch/PC version, 8BitDo specifies X mode when connecting via USB. For a 2,4 GHz connection, use the receiver; then check the button mapping in your game.

Are macro buttons allowed at fighting game tournaments?

It depends on the event. The rules published by Evo prohibit programmable hardware inputs, rapid-fire and hardware macros. These event rules aren’t universal and don’t automatically apply to other tournaments.