Who is this guide for?

Puzzle fans with a specific platform

If you want to play classic puzzle games on a particular Switch, PlayStation, Xbox or PC, check the exact model version and the controls supported by the game. 8BitDo, MAYFLASH and HORI specifications each apply to particular versions.

Fans of precise directional inputs

If the directions and action buttons you need in-game matter more to you than extra features, check the input mode and button mapping on the exact version. MAYFLASH says the F300 Elite and F500 Elite can switch between D-pad and X/Y analogue modes.

Players who enjoy long sessions

If you’ll be using the stick in the same place for extended periods, consider how much space it takes up and where your hands will rest. The manufacturer’s dimensions can give you an idea, but they can’t replace checking the posture and comfort for yourself.

What should you look for?

First, check the game and platform, then the directional inputs and button mapping. Finally, make sure the stick’s footprint and connection route work with your gaming setup.

Buying priority What to check Who is it important to?
Platform and game Exact model version and platform compatibility; inputs accepted by the game. If I play on a specific console or PC, I want to check that this exact version works with my game. Around 31 % of consumers say platform and game compatibility is their main priority.
Directions and buttons Required directions and actions; D-pad or analogue mode, and buttons that can be mapped on the version. If my puzzle game requires precise changes of direction, I want to make sure the game’s controls match the stick’s input signal. Around 31 % of consumers say directional inputs and button mapping are their main priorities.
Space and hand position Desk space, including room to move the lever and space for the cable; try out the hand position yourself if possible. If I play at the same table for long periods, I want to position the stick so my hands can rest comfortably. Around 23 % of consumers say footprint and hand position are their main priorities.
Connection and setup Documented connection method for your platform; any adapter or firmware you may need. If I want to connect the stick to my usual gaming setup with as little fuss as possible, I check the required connection method and any extra requirements first. Around 15 % of consumers say connection and setup are their main priorities.

Common misconceptions

  • Comparing only the brand name instead of the full platform version

    HORI has separate PlayStation and Xbox versions. For the use of certain F300 and F500 models with PS5 games described by MAYFLASH, a compatible MagicBoots-S5 adapter and the latest firmware are specified.

    Check the full model number against your console. For MAYFLASH, check whether you need the adapter for your intended use and whether it’s included.

  • Assuming compact automatically means comfortable for long sessions

    A smaller case takes up less space, but that doesn’t tell you whether your hands will rest comfortably on it. A larger case changes how much room you’ll need, but it doesn’t guarantee personal comfort either.

    Measure your desk space and consider your hand position. Try the stick out for yourself if possible.

  • Confusing lots of buttons with the right controls for puzzle games

    Extra button-mapping options won’t make up for unsuitable directional controls. What matters is whether the specific game accepts the inputs from the mode you choose.

    First, note the directions and actions you need in the game. Then check them against the modes and mappable buttons on the exact model version.

Key brands at a glance

8BitDo

The Arcade Stick for Switch and Windows could be an option if you want to choose between several connection types.

  • 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2,4 GHz and USB-C, as well as profiles for button mapping.
  • The documented compatibility of this version doesn’t confirm PlayStation support. Connection options alone also don’t tell you whether a particular puzzle game will accept the inputs.

MAYFLASH

The F300 Elite and F500 Elite are wired models with a documented switch for changing the directional input signal.

  • MAYFLASH lists Sanwa components for both models, along with a switch between D-pad and X/Y analogue modes.
  • For the PS5 use of these model ranges described by MAYFLASH, a compatible MagicBoots-S5 adapter and the latest firmware are required. According to the manufacturer, the larger F500 Elite has metal plates; this feature doesn’t automatically apply to the F300 Elite.

HORI

The Fighting Stick Mini for PS5 and PS4 is aimed at players with limited desk space, while the Fighting Stick α models have an access panel for maintenance.

  • HORI describes the Mini as a compact model measuring around 8 × 6 inches, and says the α versions have an opening case.
  • The PlayStation and Xbox versions aren’t interchangeable when it comes to platform compatibility. Manufacturer claims about the hand rest aren’t an independent long-term test.

Joybuy products

The Joybuy product below may appeal if you’re looking for a leverless, all-button layout instead of a classic joystick. Still, check that the platform support listed matches the inputs your particular puzzle game requires.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

Worth considering if you want an all-button layout without a classic joystick; check whether your puzzle game supports this type of input.

According to the product title, compatible with Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android.

Bluetooth, 2,4 GHz or wired connection; hot-swappable mechanical switches and RGB lighting.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is ‘PC compatible’ enough to know it will work with my classic puzzle game?

No, that information alone isn’t enough. Compare the directional and button modes accepted by the game with the exact controller version. MAYFLASH documents a switch between D-pad and analogue modes on the F300 Elite, but that doesn’t mean every PC game accepts both.

How do I set up the 8BitDo Arcade Stick via 2,4 GHz on Windows?

According to 8BitDo’s instructions, set the connection switch to 2,4G and the mode switch to X, then connect the receiver to your Windows device. After that, check whether the game recognises the inputs.

Can I plan to use a MAYFLASH F300 Elite or F500 Elite with PS5 games without any extra accessories?

Not with the manufacturer setup described: MAYFLASH specifies a compatible MagicBoots-S5 adapter and the latest firmware for this use. Check the exact stick version and whether the adapter is included.

What are my rights if a stick is faulty or bought online in Germany?

Your statutory rights against the seller are separate from any voluntary guarantee. For the usual claims relating to defects in movable goods, § 438 BGB generally specifies two years from delivery. A distance-selling consumer contract generally comes with a right to cancel; the Verbraucherzentrale says that for ordered goods, the period is usually 14 days from receipt. Exceptions and the circumstances of the specific purchase should be taken into account.

How should I dispose of an old arcade stick in Germany?

The Umweltbundesamt advises against putting waste electrical equipment in household rubbish. For example, take the device to a suitable collection point or return it to a retailer.