Who is this comparison for?

Players practising with a lever

If you want to practise movements and jumps using an arcade lever, first check that the game supports the actions you need and the available direction modes. MAYFLASH lists switchable LS, DP and RS modes for the F101; the right one depends on the game.

Players who are considerate of housemates

If you share a room or live somewhere with thin walls, consider the lever and buttons separately. QANBA describes components in the Q8-SS version as “Silent”. This is a manufacturer’s claim, not a measurement of how loud it will be in your room.

Players with a small desk

If you need to leave room for work as well as your stick, the dimensions of the specific model matter, along with hand space, lever movement and cable routing. A compact case alone doesn’t tell you how much clear space you’ll need while playing.

What should you look for when buying?

Traditional arcade stick with lever

A good fit if: you specifically want to practise using a lever, and the game and platform support the directional and action inputs you need.

Consider: using a lever takes up space, so check the exact model version and test the in-game actions. MAYFLASH lists three switchable direction modes for the F101.

All-button arcade controller

A good fit if: you want to enter directions using buttons rather than a physical lever, and the game and platform support the layout.

Consider: you won’t practise using a lever, and a low-profile case doesn’t tell you how loud the buttons will be in your room.

Gamepad you already own

A good fit if: your gamepad already supports the inputs you need in the game, and you don’t want to practise using a lever.

Consider: you won’t need to buy another stick or make extra room on your desk, but you won’t be practising with an arcade lever.

Each percentage refers to consumers who prioritise one main concern when making this purchase decision.

Priority What to check before buying Who is it important to?
In-game actions and directional control Check the game’s controls against the direction mode and action buttons on the exact model. Test them in the game after connecting. If you need to reliably move, jump and perform other actions in a platform game using the stick, inputs are the priority. Around 28 % of consumers prioritise the in-game actions and directions they need.
PC or console compatibility Check the full model name, operating system or console version, and supported mode. If you plan to use the stick with a particular PC or console, check the exact version. Around 22 % of consumers put platform compatibility first.
Noise in your room Check claims about the lever and buttons separately. Don’t treat “Silent” as a measurement of how loud it will be in your room. If you want to be considerate of housemates or neighbours, the noise made by each control matters. Around 22 % of consumers prioritise being considerate of others.
Desk space and room for your hands Measure the available width and depth, and allow space for your hands, lever movement and connectors. If you want to use a stick alongside work equipment on a small desk, you’ll also need enough clear space to play. Around 17 % of consumers put available space first.
Wired or wireless connection Check the connection and cable route where you plan to use it. For wireless use, choose a connection documented as compatible with your platform. If your PC or console isn’t right next to your playing area, the right connection type could be crucial. Around 11 % of consumers prioritise freedom from cables.

Assumptions to avoid

  • Assuming platform compatibility means the controls will work in your game

    Even if a stick is designed for a particular device, the controls depend on the inputs required by the specific game. With the MAYFLASH F101, the game also determines whether LS, DP or RS is the right direction mode.

    Make a note of the in-game actions you need, check them against the modes and buttons on the exact model, then test every input in the game after connecting.

  • Assuming “Silent” means you know how loud it will be in your room

    QANBA describes components in the Q8-SS version we researched as “Silent”. By contrast, Speedlink explicitly describes the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA as having loudly clicking microswitches. These claims aren’t comparable measurements taken in a student bedroom.

    Consider the lever and buttons separately, and don’t assume the product name tells you how loud it will be in your room.

  • Allowing only for the case dimensions on your desk

    Your hands, lever movement and cable also need space when you play. The case dimensions alone don’t show the full space you’ll need to use the stick.

    Measure the clear space available, and also allow for your hands, connectors and cable routing.

  • Choosing an F101 firmware file based on the model name alone

    MAYFLASH notes that a new F101 circuit board isn’t compatible with certain earlier firmware versions. Choosing the wrong one could make it harder to troubleshoot a problem.

    Before updating, identify your device version and use the manufacturer’s instructions for that version.

Relevant brands at a glance

MAYFLASH

The F101 is a wired lever stick that the manufacturer lists for use with, among other devices, Windows PCs and Switch.

  • MAYFLASH says the model has eight action buttons and LS, DP and RS direction modes.
  • The mode and actions you need must suit the specific game. For firmware updates, the device version matters.

HORI

The Fighting Stick Mini SPF-038U is a compact lever option for the PlayStation systems and Windows versions listed by the manufacturer.

  • HORI lists its dimensions as approximately 8 × 6 inches, with eight buttons and a cable.
  • The manufacturer says this model doesn’t have a touchpad. The case dimensions don’t include all the space you’ll need while playing.

8BitDo

The Arcade Stick is a lever option; the separate Arcade Controller uses directional buttons instead of a lever.

  • For the Arcade Stick, 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz, USB-C and customisable button mapping.
  • The leverless Arcade Controller is a different model and isn’t suitable for practising physical lever movements.

QANBA

The Q8-SS version we researched is a PC-focused lever option for anyone comparing manufacturers’ claims about quieter components.

  • QANBA describes the lever and buttons on this version as “Silent”.
  • This isn’t an independent measurement of noise in a student bedroom. Check other Q8 versions separately.

Speedlink

The COMPETITION PRO EXTRA is a USB retro joystick for Windows games with compatible DirectInput controls.

  • The manufacturer lists four fire buttons.
  • Speedlink explicitly describes the microswitches as loudly clicking. Also check whether the four buttons cover the actions you need.

Joybuy product selection

This selection features an all-button arcade controller for entering inputs with buttons rather than a lever. It isn’t for practising physical lever movements.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

Worth considering if you want to enter directions using buttons rather than a physical lever; this layout isn’t suitable for practising with a lever.

The product name lists Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android.

Listed connection types: Bluetooth, 2.4G and wired.

The product name mentions hot-swappable fast-trigger mechanical switches.

View on Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is “PC-compatible” enough to ensure my platform game will work?

No. Also check which direction and action inputs the game requires, and which mode the specific model offers. MAYFLASH lists LS, DP and RS for the F101; you’ll need to check which mode suits the game’s requirements.

What should I set up after connecting a MAYFLASH F101?

Choose the input mode that suits your platform, then check the direction mapping against the game. Test movement and actions in-game. Before updating the firmware, identify your device version: MAYFLASH notes that some older firmware versions aren’t compatible with new F101 circuit boards.

Does “Silent” on the QANBA Q8 mean my housemate won’t hear it?

No. QANBA uses “Silent” to describe components in the Q8-SS version we researched. This manufacturer’s claim isn’t a comparable measurement of how loud the stick will be in your room.

Who should I contact in Germany if an arcade stick I bought online is faulty?

The seller is responsible for your statutory consumer rights; these are separate from a manufacturer’s warranty. If there’s a fault, you may initially be entitled to have the item repaired or replaced. The Verbraucherzentrale also explains that online purchases generally come with a 14-day right to cancel, subject to the conditions that apply in each case.

Can I put a worn-out arcade stick in general waste in Germany?

No. The German Environment Agency recommends disposing of electrical and electronic waste separately from general household waste. Check with your local authority to find out where to take it.