Who is an arcade stick suitable for?

Players practising precise sequences of movements

If you repeatedly practise directions, jumps and other actions, check whether the controls cover all the inputs required by the specific game. The specifications from 8BitDo and MAYFLASH show that different control options and button mappings are available.

Players who practise for long sessions

If you practise for longer periods, allow enough room for the stick and your hands, and consider your posture. The case dimensions are useful for comparison, but do not prove that a product will be comfortable for you over long sessions.

Players on PC and console

If you switch between devices or use a particular console, check the exact model variant, connection mode and any adapter or firmware requirements. Manufacturers list different platforms for different variants.

What should you look for when buying?

First check your game’s inputs, then look at platform compatibility, the space available and any extra steps needed for connection and maintenance.

What matters to you What to check before buying Who it matters to
Game inputs Compare the directions and actions you need with the controls in your specific game. MAYFLASH says the F500 Elite lets you switch between D-pad and X/Y axis modes. If I want to practise specific directions and actions repeatedly, the stick needs to support the inputs I need. Around 31% of consumers prioritise this when choosing.
Space and handling Compare the case dimensions with the available desk or lap space, and leave room to move your hands. Dimensions alone do not tell you whether it will be comfortable for you. If you practise for longer, you’ll want enough room for the device and your hands, and the ability to adjust your posture. Around 25% of consumers prioritise space and handling.
Platform and connection Check the platform list for the exact variant and make sure you use the right connection mode. For a documented PS5 setup with the MAYFLASH F300 Elite, the manufacturer specifies MagicBoots-S5 and firmware V1.15. If I want to use the stick with a particular console or PC, that exact combination needs to be supported. Around 25% of consumers put platform and connection first.
Accessories and maintenance Check whether your planned setup needs an adapter and whether the device can be serviced. HORI says the Fighting Stick α SPF-013U has a hinged case for maintenance and customisation. If you want to factor in potential accessories and future maintenance, check what’s included and how easy it is to access the inside of the exact variant. Around 19% of consumers prioritise these considerations.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming “PS5-compatible” means it works with every game

    Support can depend on the model, game type and connection setup. For a documented PS5 setup with the F300 Elite, MAYFLASH specifies MagicBoots-S5 and firmware V1.15. For the F700 Elite, the manufacturer warns that PS5 game types other than fighting games are not supported.

    Check the model, game type and specific connection setup separately, rather than assuming information applies across different variants.

    Depending on the model, you may need to spend extra time setting up an adapter and firmware.

  • Assuming a switchable stick mode provides full analogue control

    A mode switch does not prove that all directional and analogue functions are available at the same time. MAYFLASH says the F500 Elite lets you switch between D-pad and X/Y axis modes.

    Make a note of all the inputs your game needs at the same time, then compare them with the controls on the exact stick you’re considering.

  • Focusing only on the stick and overlooking space and noise

    Case dimensions don’t tell you whether a product will be comfortable for you over long sessions. Speedlink says the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB has audible clicking microswitches.

    Measure the available space and room for movement, and consider whether the noise could be disruptive where you plan to play.

Key brands at a glance

8BitDo

Arcade sticks are available in different platform variants, so choosing the right version is essential.

  • For its Switch/PC version, 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C connectivity, along with software-based button mapping.
  • The Xbox version has a different compatibility list. The manufacturer’s battery-life claims are not independent test results.

MAYFLASH

The F300, F500 and F700 variants differ in features, connectivity and console requirements.

  • For the F500 Elite, MAYFLASH lists Sanwa components and a switchable directional mode. The F700 offers several connection options.
  • For the F300 Elite on PS5, MAYFLASH specifies MagicBoots-S5 and firmware V1.15. For the F700 Elite, the manufacturer warns that PS5 game types other than fighting games are not supported.

HORI

The Fighting Stick α SPF-013U is a documented PlayStation and Windows variant.

  • HORI says it has a hinged case for maintenance and customisation, as well as HAYABUSA stick and buttons.
  • These model specifications do not guarantee long-term comfort or Xbox compatibility.

Qanba

The manufacturer lists the Drone 2 as compatible with PS5, PS4 and PC.

  • Qanba lists a platform switch, a touchpad and 30 mm buttons.
  • The manufacturer’s view on whether it suits people with larger hands is not an independent ergonomics test, and says nothing about availability in Germany.

Speedlink

According to the manufacturer, the COMPETITION PRO EXTRA USB is a retro joystick for Windows games with suitable controls.

  • Speedlink lists DirectInput and four fire buttons.
  • The manufacturer describes the microswitches as loud and clicky. Four fire buttons may not be enough for games that require more actions.

Joybuy products

A Joybuy product option for leverless button control instead of a stick.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller for Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller (Switch 2/Switch/PC/iOS/Android)

This all-button hitbox design could suit you if you want to practise using buttons rather than moving a stick; it isn’t suitable for focused stick training.

The product title lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and wired connectivity, as well as hot-swappable fast-trigger mechanical switches and RGB lighting.

View on Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can an arcade stick replace my gamepad for every platform game?

No, you can’t tell from the product category alone. Compare the directional, analogue and action inputs you need to use at the same time with the exact model and its button mapping. The switch between D-pad and X/Y axis modes listed by MAYFLASH for the F500 Elite does not prove that it can replace two analogue sticks used simultaneously.

How do I connect a stick to a Switch or PS5?

The steps depend on the exact model. The 8BitDo instructions explain how to pair its arcade stick with the Switch via Bluetooth. For a documented PS5 setup with the MAYFLASH F300 Elite, the manufacturer specifies MagicBoots-S5 and firmware V1.15. These requirements do not automatically apply to other sticks.

What can I do if I feel discomfort during long practice sessions?

Product dimensions are not a guarantee of health or comfort. The NHS lists pain or tingling as possible symptoms of repetitive movements and recommends seeking medical advice if symptoms do not go away or get worse. This is general health information, not a test of an arcade stick.

Who is responsible if a product is faulty: the retailer or a voluntary guarantor?

For a consumer purchase, your statutory rights are generally against the seller. According to information from the European Union, the minimum guarantee period is two years from the date you receive the goods. A voluntary guarantee is separate. For online purchases, you generally have 14 days from delivery to cancel, subject to legal exceptions; return costs may apply.