First, check which directional and action inputs your shoot-’em-up requires, and whether the exact stick variant works with your PC or console. Then choose between a compact design, different connection options and, where available, controls described as quiet. The dimensions of the casing alone won’t tell you how much room you’ll need for your hands and cables, or how loud the stick will be in your room.
Which stick is right for you?
Shoot-’em-up players with a specific system
If you want to use a joystick and action buttons for a particular game, check that the inputs you need and the stick’s mode match your exact PC or console model. MAYFLASH and 8BitDo describe different input modes and platforms for their models.
Players with a small desk
If you want to put the stick away after playing, compare the casing dimensions and allow extra room for your hands, joystick movement and cables. HORI lists the Fighting Stick Mini SPF-038U as having a casing footprint of around 8 × 6 inches.
Players in a shared living space
If noise could disturb others in the room, check the features of the exact variant. QANBA advertises certain Q8 versions with a joystick and buttons described as “Silent”, but that label doesn’t provide a comparable noise level.
What to look for when buying
| Priority |
What to check when buying |
Who this matters most to |
| Controls that suit your game |
Check the game’s input list, the directional controls you need and the button layout. |
If I need specific directional and action inputs for my shoot-’em-up, I need to be able to map them to the stick. Around 29% of shoppers say game controls are their top priority. |
| System compatibility |
Check the full model name, the PC or console version, and whether any additional devices are needed. |
If I want to use the stick with my existing console or PC, compatibility with the exact variant is essential. Around 29% of shoppers put their system first. |
| Desk space and storage |
Compare the casing dimensions with your available desk space, and allow room for use and cables. |
If my desk is short on space and I want to put the stick away after playing, I need to consider both its footprint and the extra room needed to use it. Around 24% of shoppers put space first. |
| Noise in a shared space |
Look for components described as quiet on the exact variant; don’t assume “Silent” means noiseless. |
If I play in a shared room, I want to minimise the chance of disturbing others. Around 18% of shoppers say noise is their top priority. |
How to avoid common buying mistakes
-
Buying based on “arcade stick” alone, rather than the exact variant
Models with similar names may support different systems. According to the manufacturer, the standard 8BitDo Arcade Stick isn’t intended for PlayStation or Xbox consoles. Certain console connections for the MAYFLASH F300 require a wired controller.
Before buying, check the model name, platform and connection requirements separately.
A wired controller may also be needed for certain connections.
-
Confusing casing dimensions with the total space required
Your hands, joystick movement and cables also need room. A small casing may also offer less surface area to rest on.
Measure the space available on your desk and allow extra room to use the stick when comparing models.
-
Assuming “Silent” means noiseless
QANBA describes certain Q8 components as “Silent”, but the label doesn’t tell you how loud the stick will actually be in your room.
Check the features of the exact variant and don’t equate “Silent” with noiselessness.
-
Assuming the MAYFLASH F300 and F300 Elite are the same
MAYFLASH says the F300 is compatible with Sanwa buttons and joystick, while the F300 Elite comes with Sanwa components, according to the manufacturer.
Before buying, distinguish between the option to replace the components and the parts actually fitted.
Key brands at a glance
HORI
The Fighting Stick Mini SPF-038U is a compact option for compatible PlayStation and Windows setups. The separate Mini version for Switch is a different variant.
- HORI lists the SPF-038U as having a casing footprint of around 8 × 6 inches and eight buttons.
- The compact dimensions don’t guarantee enough room for every hand or low noise levels. Check the console variant.
MAYFLASH
The F101 is described as suitable for wired Windows and Switch setups. The F300 has different connection requirements and can be used with compatible components.
- For the F101, MAYFLASH lists the PC input modes XInput and DInput, and dimensions of 27,8 × 19,8 cm.
- For PS4 and certain Xbox systems, the manufacturer says a wired controller must be connected to the F300. Compatibility with Sanwa components doesn’t mean they’re already fitted to the F300.
8BitDo
The standard Arcade Stick is described as suitable for compatible Switch and Windows setups. There’s also a separate Xbox version.
- 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2,4 GHz and USB-C as connection options for the standard Arcade Stick.
- According to the manufacturer, the standard version doesn’t support PlayStation or Xbox consoles. The Xbox version is a different model.
QANBA
The Q8 is a PC option if you’re looking for controls specifically described as “Silent”. The Drone 2 is a separate model for PlayStation and PC.
- QANBA advertises certain Q8 variants with a quiet joystick and quiet buttons.
- The label isn’t a comparable noise measurement. The Drone 2’s compatibility, as listed by the manufacturer, doesn’t automatically apply to the Q8.
Joybuy products for this topic
The Joybuy option listed here is a leverless all-button controller. It may suit you if you’re looking for controls without a traditional joystick and use one of the systems named in the product title.
No image available
BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller
The all-button hitbox design is worth considering if you don’t want a traditional joystick. If you specifically want a joystick, choose a different design.
Systems named in the product title: Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android.
Connections named in the product title: Bluetooth, 2,4 GHz and wired.
Features named in the product title: hot-swappable fast-trigger switches and RGB.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Will any arcade stick work with any shoot-’em-up?
No, you can’t tell from the platform list alone. Compare the directional and action inputs required by your specific game with the input mode and buttons on the exact stick variant.
How do I set up the standard 8BitDo Arcade Stick on Windows using a cable?
For a wired Windows connection, 8BitDo’s instructions say to set the mode switch to X and connect via USB-C. Wait for Windows to recognise the stick, then check the button mapping in your game. These steps don’t necessarily apply to the separate Xbox version.
What should I bear in mind when maintaining or modifying it?
Keep the controls clean and check the instructions for the exact model and hardware version before making any changes. MAYFLASH warns against installing older firmware on a newer F101 board version.
What are my return and faulty goods rights when buying online in Germany?
For a typical online purchase from a trader, you generally have 14 days from delivery to cancel; exceptions and conditions apply, and you may have to pay the return postage when you cancel. Separately, if goods are faulty, you have statutory claims against the seller for at least two years. The EU’s Your Europe portal distinguishes these rights from any additional manufacturer’s guarantee, which doesn’t replace your statutory rights.