Which film scanner is right for you?

Teams sharing a scanning workstation

If several people use the same computer, the operating system, connection and scanning software should all suit your shared workflow. LaserSoft Imaging says a SilverFast 9 licence allows the software to be used on one computer at a time.

Black-and-white photographers

If you want to adjust tonal values and retouch your scans yourself, check the output options and the correction methods available. LaserSoft Imaging explains that its infrared method cannot be used with conventional silver-based black-and-white film.

Managers of mixed film archives

If your archive contains different film formats, make sure the holders are compatible and that the scanner supports the area you need to scan. Information from manufacturers about batch feed or SD card operation can also help you assess how a model will fit into a shared workflow.

What should you look for when buying?

Start by checking the film format and holder, then the computer, operating system and software licence. After that, you can decide whether batch feed or scanning without a PC is a better fit for your workflow.

Priority What to check before buying Who should consider this?
Shared workstation Operating system and drivers; software licence for the planned simultaneous use. If I scan using a shared computer, the connection and software need to work with our setup. Around 29% of consumers put this setup requirement first.
Editable black-and-white scans Greyscale output and suitable retouching tools; don’t rely on infrared correction to remove dust from silver-based film. If you want to adjust tonal values and retouch dust yourself, look closely at the available scanning and retouching options. Around 23% of consumers prioritise editable black-and-white scans.
Film formats and holders Film format and strip dimensions; suitable holders, either included or available separately. If you have a mixed archive, you’ll want to know in advance whether your negatives will actually fit the holders. Around 18% of consumers put format compatibility first.
Large numbers of negative strips Frames supported per pass; compatible strips and feed mechanism. If you regularly have lots of compatible strips to scan, reducing the amount of manual loading is important to me. Around 18% of consumers prioritise throughput.
Scanning without a PC SD card requirements and output format; transferring files to the shared computer. If you want to keep the workstation free while scanning, look for a model that saves scans directly to a memory card. Around 12% of consumers prioritise being able to scan without a PC.

Pitfalls to avoid when buying a black-and-white film scanner

  • Choosing a scanner mainly for infrared dust removal

    Don’t rely on infrared correction to remove dust from conventional silver-based black-and-white film. LaserSoft Imaging explains this limitation of its infrared method.

    Instead, look for a suitable black-and-white workflow and software-based retouching you can control. You may still need to clean the film and retouch the scans afterwards.

  • Choosing a photo or document scanner based on dpi alone

    A high dpi figure on its own doesn’t confirm that a scanner can scan film. Epson describes the V39II as a photo and document scanner, while film scanning is specifically listed for the V600 Photo and V850 Pro.

    Ask the manufacturer to confirm that the exact model has a transparency or film-scanning function and compatible holders.

    If the scanner isn’t equipped for film, you may need to buy an additional film-capable model.

  • Assuming a PC-free scanner offers the same workflow as a full PC-based scan

    An SD card scanner can keep the shared computer free while you scan, but you’ll need to transfer the files afterwards. Kodak Photo Plus notes that the SD card required to use the Slide N Scan is not included.

    Check the output format you need and how you’ll transfer the files before buying.

    With the Kodak Slide N Scan, you’ll need to allow for a compatible memory card and arrange how you’ll transfer the files afterwards.

Relevant brands and model ranges

Plustek

The OpticFilm 8300i SE and OpticFilm 135i ranges are examples of computer-connected 35mm film scanners.

  • Plustek specifies 16-bit greyscale input and 8- or 16-bit output for the 8300i SE. For the 135i, the manufacturer says you can batch-scan up to six frames from a film strip.
  • These specifications apply to the individual models and don’t constitute an independent assessment of image quality. For conventional silver-based black-and-white film, the infrared function isn’t a key reason to choose a scanner for dust correction.

reflecta

The RPS 10S and x33-Scan offer different workflows: automatic strip feed or saving scans to an SD card.

  • reflecta specifies automatic feed for strips with 3 to 40 frames for the RPS 10S, and JPEG output to an SD card for the x33-Scan.
  • These model specifications aren’t a quality comparison of the brand as a whole. The benefits of automatic feed depend on having compatible strips and holders.

Kodak Photo Plus

The Slide N Scan RODFS50 is a standalone option for the film formats listed on the EU product page.

  • Kodak Photo Plus lists adapters for 135, 110 and 126 formats, as well as saving scans to an SD card.
  • According to the supplier, an SD card is required to use the scanner and isn’t included. The image quality claims on the product page aren’t based on independent measurements.

Epson

The Perfection V600 Photo and V850 Pro are examples of film-capable flatbed scanners for a range of originals, including medium format.

  • Epson Germany lists film holders and formats for each model. These may be relevant if you already own a suitable scanner.
  • Epson Germany marks both models as discontinued. Their specifications shouldn’t therefore be taken as a recommendation for new models currently available to buy from the manufacturer.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions about film scanners

Can I use SilverFast on several scanning workstations at the same time?

No. According to LaserSoft Imaging, a SilverFast 9 licence allows the software to be used on one computer at a time. You can install the software on several workstations, but you’ll need additional licences to use it simultaneously. Also check the licence for the software actually supplied with your scanner.

What should the team set up before the first scan?

First, make sure the scanner, operating system and required drivers are all set up to work together. LaserSoft Imaging’s installation guide recommends connecting the scanner directly to the computer rather than through a USB hub. A shared system for storing and naming files will then make it easier to hand them over within the team.

Does an infrared function remove dust from black-and-white negatives?

Don’t rely on infrared correction to remove dust from conventional silver-based black-and-white film: LaserSoft Imaging explains that the method can’t be used with this type of film. The supplier also describes software-based SRDx retouching for black-and-white images. Check the results on each scan.

What extra item might you need to scan without a PC?

According to Kodak Photo Plus, the Kodak Slide N Scan requires an SD card to operate, and one isn’t included. reflecta says the x33-Scan can save JPEG files directly to an SD card. Check the card requirements and the file format you need before buying.

What rights do you have when buying a new scanner in Germany?

If a product is faulty, the seller is responsible for putting it right, as explained by the Verbraucherzentrale. For a typical online consumer purchase, you generally have a 14-day right to cancel. This is separate from the process for dealing with faulty goods. A voluntary manufacturer’s warranty is different again from these rights.