If your client needs files they can continue to edit, consider a computer-connected scanner whose actual output formats meet the requirements of the job. If you’ve agreed to supply JPEG images for quick viewing, a standalone device such as the reflecta x66-Scan could be suitable; according to the manufacturer, it doesn’t offer TIFF output. Also check the film format and holder: infrared dust correction isn’t a reliable solution for traditional silver-based black-and-white film.
Who this guide is for
Photographers delivering files clients can edit
Before you buy, decide whether your client expects an editable file as well as a viewing copy. The Library of Congress distinguishes preservation files from alternative representations, which are generally of secondary importance.
Studios working with different negative formats
If you work with medium-format film as well as 35 mm, the supported formats and supplied holders need to accommodate the actual image size. Plustek lists 35 mm and 120 formats up to 6 × 12 cm for the OpticFilm 120 Pro; Epson describes film holders for the V850 Pro, which the company now lists as discontinued.
Photographers processing large volumes of 35 mm film
When you have lots of compatible 35 mm strips to scan, feeding and the time needed for cleaning and checking each frame are part of the workflow. reflecta lists automatic feeding for suitable strips with 3 to 40 frames on the RPS 10S.
What to consider when choosing
First decide which files your client should receive. Then match the film format, correction work and job size to the workflow you have in mind.
| Requirement |
What to check before buying |
Who it matters most to |
| Files for delivery |
Check the file formats supported by the specific device and software version; agree the resolution and file size with your client. |
If you need to deliver an editable file rather than just a viewing copy, the output needs to suit the job. Around 31% of consumers prioritise the agreed file format. |
| Film format and holder |
Check that 135, 127 or 120/220 film, along with the specific image size, is compatible with the model’s supported formats and holders. |
If your job includes different film sizes, the scanner must be able to accommodate every format you need. Around 25% of consumers put format compatibility first. |
| Dust and scratches |
Identify the film type and check defect correction on a test scan; allow for the amount of manual retouching required. |
If you’re scanning traditional silver-based black-and-white negatives, include cleaning and careful retouching in your workflow. Around 25% of consumers prioritise defect correction. |
| Throughput for large volumes of negatives |
Check strip compatibility, feeding limits and computer requirements; allow time for a test run and visual checks. |
If you have lots of suitable 35 mm strips to scan, feeding and repeated loading can affect your workflow. Around 19% of consumers focus particularly on job throughput. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Assuming infrared dust correction works on all black-and-white film
The detection required for infrared correction doesn’t work reliably with traditional silver-based black-and-white film. So the presence of this feature alone tells you little about the correction work you’ll need to do.
Identify the film type and check the results with a test scan before settling on your workflow.
Cleaning, visual checks and retouching can all add to the time required.
-
Assuming a JPEG viewing copy is the same as an agreed editing file
According to the manufacturer, the reflecta x66-Scan saves files as JPEG. This doesn’t automatically mean it creates a separate TIFF file for further editing.
Agree the file format and delivery requirements before buying, and check the output on the specific model.
-
Confusing interpolated megapixels with sensor resolution
For the reflecta x66-Scan, the manufacturer distinguishes between a 14 MP sensor and an interpolated 22 MP output.
Keep sensor and output figures separate, and check a test scan against the intended use.
Key brands at a glance
Plustek
According to Plustek, the OpticFilm range includes a 35 mm model and a model for 35 mm film and certain 120 formats.
- Plustek lists 35 mm film and the supplied SilverFast SE Plus 9 and QuickScan Plus software for the OpticFilm 8300i SE.
- Don’t rely on the advertised infrared correction to remove defects from traditional silver-based black-and-white film.
reflecta
The models listed suit different workflows: computer-connected feeding of suitable 35 mm strips, or standalone output to an SD card.
- reflecta lists automatic feeding for suitable 35 mm strips with 3 to 40 frames on the RPS 10S; the x66-Scan saves JPEG files to an SD card.
- According to reflecta, the x66-Scan’s 22 MP output is interpolated; its stated sensor resolution is 14 MP. The manufacturer’s specifications aren’t a comparative real-world test.
Epson
The Perfection V850 Pro is described as a flatbed workflow with film holders for 35 mm and medium-format film, and TIFF output.
- Epson Germany lists film holders and TIFF output for the V850 Pro.
- Epson Germany lists the model as discontinued, so its specifications don’t confirm that it’s currently available to buy.
Suitable products at Joybuy
Similar products will be available soon.
Frequently asked questions
Is an SD card scanner enough for delivering files to a client?
If you’ve agreed to supply JPEG files, the reflecta x66-Scan’s documented JPEG output could be suitable. If you need a separate file that can be edited further, check that your workflow supports the format you’ve agreed; reflecta doesn’t list TIFF output for the x66-Scan.
Does an infrared channel remove dust from traditional black-and-white negatives?
Infrared correction isn’t reliably suitable for traditional silver-based black-and-white film. LaserSoft Imaging describes SRDx as software-based correction for black-and-white film; check its effect on each individual image.
What should I check in a scanner for large film jobs?
First, check your film strips and holders against the model’s specifications. reflecta lists automatic feeding for suitable 35 mm strips with 3 to 40 frames on the RPS 10S; you should also allow time for a test run and visual checks.
What data protection rules apply when handing over scanned client negatives?
If the files contain personal data, check the applicable data protection requirements and identify a lawful basis for processing. Whether the specific job involves processing on behalf of a client depends, according to the Data Protection Conference in particular, on who decides the purposes of processing; calling it a “client job” doesn’t settle the question on its own.