35 mm photographers planning to edit their scans
If you scan 35 mm negatives and want to edit tonal values in files saved locally, compare greyscale output, file formats and scanning software rather than focusing on the stated resolution alone.
Choose a film scanner based first on the negative format and the type of file you need to save locally. For 35 mm film, consider computer-connected models with greyscale output or DNG; for 120-format negatives, look for explicit format and holder compatibility, as Plustek specifies for the OpticFilm 120 Pro. If you want more scope to edit tonal values later, check for TIFF or DNG output and compatible software. According to LaserSoft Imaging, the infrared channel is not a reliable way to remove dust from silver-based black-and-white film.
If you scan 35 mm negatives and want to edit tonal values in files saved locally, compare greyscale output, file formats and scanning software rather than focusing on the stated resolution alone.
If you have 120-format negatives as well as 35 mm film, support for the exact frame size and compatible holders are important factors to consider.
If you want to review or capture lots of images, weigh up the film-transport and SD card workflow against the flexibility to edit your scans later. reflecta specifies DNG output for the RPS 10S and JPEG storage on an SD card for the x33-Scan.
First, decide which film format you have and what kind of file you want for editing later. Then consider whether detail work or a quicker workflow for reviewing scans matters more to you.
| Buying criterion | What to check | Who is it most relevant to? |
|---|---|---|
| Files you can edit locally | Check the output format, selectable greyscale bit depth and the requirements of the software you need. reflecta specifies DNG for the RPS 10S and JPEG for the x33-Scan. | If I want to edit tonal values locally later, I need a suitable file rather than just a quick way to save scans. Around 36 % of consumers prioritise files for local editing. |
| Detail and dust work on 35 mm film | Compare the stated resolution and greyscale output. LaserSoft Imaging notes that infrared correction does not work on silver-based black-and-white film in the same way as it does on colour negatives. | For individual 35 mm negatives, I want to assess detail and deal with visible flaws where needed. Around 29 % of consumers prioritise detail and dust work on 35 mm film. |
| Support for different film formats | Check that the negative size and holder you need match the specifications for the exact model. Plustek specifies 35 mm film for the OpticFilm 8300i SE, and 120 formats too for the OpticFilm 120 Pro. | If I want to scan formats other than 35 mm, the frame size and holder need to be compatible. Around 21 % of consumers prioritise support for different formats. |
| Reviewing lots of negatives | Check that the film transport suits your strips, and whether you need JPEG files saved to an SD card or files for later editing. reflecta specifies compatible strips with 3 to 40 frames for the RPS 10S, and JPEG output to an SD card for the x33-Scan. | If I want to review a large collection quickly, the process for loading and saving scans matters to me. Around 14 % of consumers prioritise capturing and sorting a large number of originals. |
According to LaserSoft Imaging, infrared correction does not work on conventional silver-based black-and-white film in the same way as it does on colour film. So, the presence of this feature alone is no guarantee that you will need to do less retouching.
Check the black-and-white workflow and suitable software features separately from the advertised infrared hardware.
Manufacturers distinguish between scanners for 35 mm film and models that also support specific 120 formats.
First, identify your film and frame size, then check both against the model specifications and the compatible holders.
The documented file formats vary: reflecta specifies JPEG for the x33-Scan and DNG for the RPS 10S, while Plustek specifies JPEG, TIFF and PSD for the OpticFilm 120 Pro.
Before you buy, decide which files you want to edit and keep locally.
The models listed cover a computer-connected workflow for 35 mm film and a solution for 35 mm film as well as certain 120 formats.
The RPS 10S offers a computer-connected workflow for 35 mm film, while the x33-Scan lets you scan directly to an SD card.
The Perfection V600 Photo and V850 Pro are examples of flatbed scanning workflows with film holders and TIFF output.
The DF-S 310 SE is described as a standalone slide and negative scanner with internal storage and an SD/SDHC card slot.
It is not a reliable solution for conventional silver-based black-and-white film: according to LaserSoft Imaging, the silver layer prevents the infrared light from passing through as required. LaserSoft Imaging describes SRDx as a software-based alternative; check that the feature is available in the specific version of the software you use.
Check that your computer meets the operating system, connection and bundled software requirements. For the OpticFilm 8300i SE, Plustek specifies USB 2.0 Type B, SilverFast SE Plus 9 and QuickScan Plus. Do not assume these specifications apply to other variants.
Use a holder designed for your specific film format and check the original for dust before scanning. With silver-based black-and-white film, allow for possible retouching rather than relying on an infrared feature alone.
No. The Verbraucherzentrale distinguishes between your statutory rights against the seller if goods are faulty and a voluntary guarantee with its own terms and conditions. Also check which software and service commitments the relevant provider offers.
According to information from the Federal Ministry for the Environment, old electrical equipment must be handed in at an authorised collection point, such as a local authority collection centre, the manufacturer or, under certain conditions, a retailer. Retailers’ take-back obligations depend on factors including the type of retailer and the device.