Which scanner is right for you?

For archivists who need multiple file versions

You want to create an editable file from a black-and-white negative, plus a smaller version to share. Epson Germany lists TIFF and JPEG as output formats for the Perfection V600 Photo, while Hamrick Software’s VueScan guide explains how to save multiple files from a single scan.

For owners of mixed-size negatives

You may have, for example, 35 mm and 120 film, and need to check that the scanning area and holders suit your negatives. reflecta lists several film sizes for the x66-Scan, while Plustek specifies holders for 35 mm and 120 formats for the OpticFilm 120 Pro.

For people with large archives of film strips

You want to scan lots of compatible strips and are mindful of the effort involved in loading and operating the scanner. reflecta lists automatic film transport for suitable 35 mm strips on the RPS 10S.

What should you look for when buying?

Flatbed scanner with transparency unit

A good fit if: You need to scan 35 mm and 120/220 negatives and want TIFF and JPEG output. Epson Germany lists these formats for the V600 Photo.

Bear in mind: Your computer, software and compatible holders are all part of the workflow. Epson Germany lists the V600 Photo as discontinued.

Computer-connected 35 mm film scanner

A good fit if: Your negatives are in a compatible 35 mm format and you want a DNG workflow with automatic film transport. reflecta lists these features for the RPS 10S.

Bear in mind: The stated scanning area is no more than 24.3 × 36.5 mm, so this device is not suitable for 120 negatives. Check that the software supports any other export formats you need.

Standalone multi-format scanner

A good fit if: JPEG is enough for viewing and sharing, and you want to scan without a computer. reflecta lists 35 mm, Type 127 and 120 film up to 6 × 9 cm for the x66-Scan, with storage on an SD card.

Bear in mind: JPEG is the stated output format. For the x66-Scan, reflecta distinguishes between a 14 MP sensor resolution and 22 MP interpolated output.

Scanner for 35 mm and larger 120 formats

A good fit if: You need to scan 120 negatives up to 6 × 12 cm. Plustek lists suitable holders for 35 mm and these 120 formats for the OpticFilm 120 Pro.

Bear in mind: Before buying, check which output files the specific software version supports and whether it works with your computer.

Buying priority What to check before buying Who this matters most to
File versions Check that the scanner and the software you’ll actually use can output TIFF and JPEG. Converting to JPEG later does not prove that the scanner can create a TIFF scan. Epson Germany lists both formats for the V600 Photo, and Hamrick Software describes multiple-file output with VueScan. If I need an editable archive file as well as a smaller file to share, exporting both versions is essential. Around 31% of consumers have this as their main priority.
Film size and holders Compare your negatives’ dimensions with the scanning area and the holder supplied. reflecta lists 120 formats up to 6 × 9 cm for the x66-Scan; Plustek lists formats up to 6 × 12 cm for the OpticFilm 120 Pro. If my collection includes negatives in different physical sizes, each format must actually fit in the scanner. Around 25% of consumers have film compatibility as their main priority.
Dust and scratches Check the film type, and plan to clean it and retouch the scan if needed when working with traditional silver-based black-and-white film. According to Hamrick Software, infrared dust removal does not work with this film type. If I want to keep dust and scratches on black-and-white negatives under control, I shouldn’t rely on an IR feature alone. Around 19% of consumers need this kind of retouching.
Lots of film strips Check that the transport function and scanner are suitable for the format and condition of your strips. reflecta lists automatic transport for suitable 35 mm strips with 3 to 40 frames on the RPS 10S. If I want to scan lots of suitable strips, the amount of manual positioning the workflow requires matters to me. Around 13% of consumers prioritise throughput.
Viewing without a computer Check the output format and storage workflow. reflecta lists JPEG storage on an SD card for the x66-Scan; TIFF output is not specified. If I want to view negatives without a computer and save JPEG files, a standalone workflow is useful. Around 12% of consumers make simple viewing their main priority.

Common buying mistakes

  • Confusing interpolated megapixels with sensor resolution

    For the reflecta x66-Scan, the manufacturer lists a 14 MP sensor resolution and 22 MP interpolated output. The higher output figure does not mean that more detail has been captured from the film.

    Compare sensor or optical specifications separately from interpolated output sizes.

  • Assuming infrared correction works with every black-and-white negative

    According to Hamrick Software, infrared dust removal does not work with traditional silver-based black-and-white film.

    Check the film type and don’t judge a scanner solely by its IR feature.

  • Assuming JPEG output is the same as a TIFF archive workflow

    reflecta describes the x66-Scan as saving files directly as JPEGs. Converting one of these files later does not prove that the scanner can create a TIFF master.

    If you need TIFF, confirm that the specific scanning workflow supports TIFF export before you buy.

  • Assuming a manufacturer’s product page means it is still available to buy new

    Epson Germany lists technical specifications for the V600 Photo and V850 Pro, but marks both models as discontinued.

    Use older model specifications for reference, and check the seller and what’s included when considering a specific listing.

Key brands to consider

reflecta

The x66-Scan and RPS 10S are designed for different workflows: scanning multiple film sizes and saving JPEGs to an SD card, or scanning suitable 35 mm strips on a computer with DNG output.

  • reflecta lists 35 mm, Type 127 and 120 film up to 6 × 9 cm for the x66-Scan. The RPS 10S is specified with DNG output and automatic transport for suitable 35 mm strips.
  • The models are not interchangeable: according to the manufacturer, the x66-Scan saves files as JPEG, while the RPS 10S has a maximum scanning area of 24.3 × 36.5 mm. Source: reflecta.

Epson

The Perfection V600 Photo is documented as a flatbed scanner with a transparency unit for film. Epson Germany lists 35 mm and 120/220 film up to 6 × 22 cm, as well as JPEG and TIFF output.

  • The V600 Photo specifications cover several film formats and multiple file formats. Source: Epson Germany.
  • Epson Germany lists the V600 Photo and V850 Pro as discontinued. Their historical specifications do not confirm current availability or that older software will work with a current computer.

Plustek

The OpticFilm 120 Pro is an option if you need to scan both 35 mm and larger 120 image formats.

  • Plustek lists supplied holders for 35 mm and 120 roll film from 6 × 4.5 cm to 6 × 12 cm.
  • Before buying, check the export formats you need and whether the specific software version is compatible with your computer. The format and holder specifications apply to the OpticFilm 120 Pro. Source: Plustek.

Rollei

According to Rollei, the DF-S 310 SE is designed to digitise and view slides and negatives using its display and internal memory or an SD card.

  • Rollei lists support for Pocket film and Super 8, along with a capture resolution of 14 MP and up to 24 MP through interpolation.
  • These specifications do not confirm TIFF output or suitability as an editable archive master. Check that the file format you need is supported before buying. Source: Rollei.

Suitable products at Joybuy

Suitable products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can I get both TIFF and JPEG from one scan?

Yes, if your scanner and software support both output formats. Epson Germany lists TIFF and JPEG for the Perfection V600 Photo, while Hamrick Software’s VueScan guide explains how to save multiple files from a single scan. Check compatibility with your specific scanner and computer.

Which setting matters for a traditional black-and-white negative?

Select black-and-white negative as the media type in suitable scanning software. Hamrick Software notes that infrared dust removal does not work with traditional silver-based black-and-white film. Clean the film carefully and check the scan for any remaining flaws.

Who can help if my scanner develops a fault after purchase?

According to Your Europe, if you buy as a consumer from a trader in the EU, you have a legal guarantee of at least two years from the date you receive the goods. The seller is responsible for providing the legal remedies in the first instance. This is separate from any voluntary manufacturer’s guarantee. Your Europe notes that the EU rules do not apply to purchases from private individuals.

How should I dispose of an old scanner in Germany?

Electrical and electronic waste must not go in your household rubbish. The German Environment Agency recommends disposing of it separately, for example at a recycling centre or through a suitable retailer take-back scheme. The take-back arrangements that must be offered in each case depend on the legal requirements.