Which scanning option is right for you?

Black-and-white photographers with an editing workflow

If you want to control tonal values on your computer and retouch images precisely, check the output format, greyscale bit depth and compatible scanning software for the specific model. Plustek lists 8- or 16-bit greyscale output for the OpticFilm 8300i SE; that alone does not confirm support for a particular TIFF export.

Owners of larger collections of 35mm negatives

If you want to scan lots of 35mm negatives without fuss and are happy to work with JPEGs, consider a stand-alone scanner with an SD card. reflecta describes the x33-Scan and x44-Scan as saving JPEG files directly to an SD card.

Owners of mixed film formats

If you have medium-format film as well as 35mm, first check which formats are supported and which film holders are compatible. Epson lists 35mm and 120/220 film for the Perfection V600 Photo; the model is marked as discontinued on the German manufacturer’s website.

What should you look for when buying?

Buying criterion What to check Who is this important to?
Files you can edit locally Check the file format, greyscale output, operating system and transfer method for the exact model and software. Plustek lists 8-/16-bit greyscale output for the OpticFilm 8300i SE; reflecta describes JPEG files saved to an SD card for the x44-Scan. If I want to edit tonal values locally, I need a confirmed file workflow that works with my software. Around 36% of consumers rank editable files as their main criterion.
Dust and scratches With traditional silver-based black-and-white film, don’t rely on infrared-based iSRD correction: LaserSoft Imaging explains that it cannot be used with this film. Instead, check which manual or software-based retouching tools are available. If I want to deal with dust and scratches on black-and-white negatives, the retouching options actually available matter to me. For around 29% of consumers, this is their top priority.
Film format and holder Check that the film size and strip format match the formats and holders supported by the specific model. Epson lists 35mm and 120/220 film for the Perfection V600 Photo; the model is marked as discontinued on the German manufacturer’s website. If I want to archive different film sizes, the scanner and holder need to fit each original. Around 21% of consumers put format compatibility first.
Scanning lots of negatives Check whether a computer or SD card workflow suits the way you work, and whether a card and film-strip holder are included. reflecta’s JPEG specifications do not confirm TIFF output. If I want to scan lots of negatives, an easy workflow matters, but I still want to keep control and file transfer in mind. Around 14% of consumers prioritise scanning quickly.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming infrared dust removal works on every black-and-white negative

    According to LaserSoft Imaging, infrared-based iSRD cannot be used with traditional silver-based black-and-white film. So a logo for this feature won’t solve the dust problem with this type of film.

    Check your film type and the retouching tools available rather than basing your decision on the infrared channel alone.

    Allow time to clean the original or retouch it using a suitable method.

  • Confusing JPEG storage with a confirmed higher-bit TIFF workflow

    reflecta lists JPEG files saved to an SD card for the x33-Scan and x44-Scan. This does not confirm TIFF export; a stated greyscale bit depth alone does not confirm the file format you want either.

    Ask for confirmation of the output format and greyscale bit depth for the exact model and its software.

  • Buying a film scanner without checking the size of your negatives

    A device designed for 35mm film won’t automatically support medium format. Epson’s specifications for the Perfection V600 Photo also list 120/220 film, but the model is marked as discontinued on the German manufacturer’s website.

    Sort your negatives by format and check the holders included with the specific product. You may need a different device or suitable holders for other formats.

Brands to consider

Plustek

The OpticFilm range is worth considering for PC-connected scans of 35mm film and slides.

  • Plustek lists 8-/16-bit greyscale output for the OpticFilm 8300i SE.
  • The stated bit depth does not automatically confirm a particular TIFF export. LaserSoft Imaging notes that infrared-based iSRD correction cannot be used with traditional silver-based black-and-white film.

reflecta

The x33-Scan and x44-Scan offer a stand-alone option with JPEG files saved to an SD card; the CrystalScan 7200 is a PC-connected 35mm model.

  • The manufacturer clearly distinguishes between direct JPEG storage on an SD card and a PC connection.
  • The x models’ JPEG specifications do not confirm a TIFF workflow. reflecta’s advertised infrared-based ICE function does not overcome the limitations of black-and-white film.

Epson

The Perfection V600 Photo is an example of a flatbed scanner that supports 35mm and 120/220 film.

  • Epson’s German product page lists compatible film formats and TIFF output.
  • The German product page marks the Perfection V600 Photo as discontinued, so its specifications do not confirm current availability as a new product.

Kodak Photo Plus

The Slide N Scan, described on the European product page, is a stand-alone option for black-and-white negatives in the formats listed there.

  • Kodak Photo Plus lists 135, 110 and 126 formats, as well as storage on an SD card.
  • According to the supplier, an SD card is required to use the device and is not included. The product description does not confirm higher-bit TIFF output.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Is a stand-alone scanner enough if I want to edit the images locally later?

Yes, as long as the files from the specific device are suitable for your editing needs: reflecta lists JPEG files saved to an SD card for the x33-Scan and x44-Scan. If you need a different file format or a particular output bit depth, check these requirements for the model and software before buying.

How should I deal with dust on silver-based black-and-white film?

Don’t rely on infrared-based iSRD correction: LaserSoft Imaging explains that it cannot be used with traditional silver-based black-and-white film. Instead, check how to clean the original and which software-based or manual retouching options are actually available. LaserSoft Imaging lists SRDx as a software option for black-and-white film.

Can I scan someone else’s negatives for my personal archive and publish the files?

Under certain conditions, § 53 UrhG allows individuals to make individual copies for private, non-commercial use. It does not allow you to distribute or publicly share those private copies simply because they are for personal use. This does not provide a blanket answer on whether a specific image belonging to someone else can be published; check your rights or get the appropriate permission.

Where should you take an old scanner in Germany?

According to the Federal Ministry for the Environment, old electrical equipment must be collected separately and handed over to an authorised operator, such as a local collection point or a retailer, provided the relevant take-back conditions are met. Do not put the scanner in your household rubbish.