For scanning black and white negatives on a home computer, choose a scanner to suit your film format, preferred editing workflow and volume of negatives. For individual 35mm frames that you want to edit on your PC, consider a computer-connected 35mm film scanner; for larger numbers of compatible strips, a model with automatic feed may be a better fit. If you also want to scan 120 or 127 film, check the supported formats and file transfer options carefully. With classic silver-based black and white film, infrared dust correction is not a reliable advantage.
Which workflow is right for you?
35mm photographers who want to edit their scans
If you scan black and white 35mm negatives on your computer and want to adjust tones or retouch imperfections, make sure the film format, scanning software and greyscale output work well together. Plustek lists these features for the OpticFilm 8300i SE. LaserSoft Imaging notes that iSRD infrared correction cannot be used on classic silver-based black and white film in the same way as it can on colour film.
Owners of lots of 35mm film strips
If you have a large number of compatible 35mm negatives to digitise, a film holder with automatic strip feed could suit your workflow. reflecta lists the RPS 10S as a model with automatic feed, though its suitability also depends on the strips you have.
Collectors with different film formats
If you own formats beyond 35mm, first check that the scanner and supplied holders can accommodate those exact negatives. reflecta lists 120, 135 and 127 formats for the x66-Scan; Epson describes film holders for 35mm and 120/220 film with the V600 Photo and V850 Pro models.
What should you look for when choosing?
Start by checking your film format and holder, then consider how you want to edit your scans and how many negatives you have. This will help you decide whether a scanner for individual frames, one with automatic strip feed or a model that saves directly to a memory card is best suited to your workspace.
| What matters to you |
What to check before buying |
Who should pay particular attention? |
| Film format and holder |
Identify the film type and frame format from the original, then check the supported formats and supplied holders for the specific model. |
If your negatives come in different formats, first make sure they can be scanned with the holder provided. Around 33% of consumers put format compatibility first. |
| Tones and dust |
Check the greyscale output and software edition. Don’t assume infrared correction will remove dust from classic silver-based black and white film as it does from colour film; LaserSoft Imaging outlines this limitation for iSRD. |
If you want to adjust your black and white scans on your computer, a suitable file and retouching workflow is important. Around 25% of consumers prioritise being able to edit their scans afterwards. |
| Large numbers of negatives |
Check the length and condition of your strips against the feed specifications. Treat loading, scanning and post-processing as separate steps. |
If you have lots of compatible 35mm negatives to process, you’ll want to spend less time changing individual frames. Around 25% of consumers focus on throughput. |
| Connecting to your computer |
Check the operating system, connection, software requirements and file output for the specific model. If you choose a scanner with an SD card, plan how you’ll transfer the files afterwards. |
If you want to edit scans directly on your home computer, the file transfer workflow should suit your setup. Around 17% of consumers focus mainly on computer integration. |
Which assumptions should you avoid?
-
Assuming an infrared channel will automatically retouch all black and white film
Infrared correction designed for colour film does not work in the same way on classic silver-based black and white emulsion. So an infrared channel won’t automatically replace the need to inspect and retouch your negatives.
Check the film type and assess software-based retouching separately from the scanner’s infrared features. Gently remove any visible dust before scanning.
Cleaning and manual or software-based retouching can take extra time.
-
Confusing interpolated output size with sensor resolution
For the reflecta x66-Scan, the manufacturer lists a 14 MP sensor and 22 MP interpolated output. The larger file resolution does not represent the sensor resolution.
Compare the sensor or optical resolution separately from interpolated file sizes.
-
Assuming a 35mm scanner can handle every negative format
Supported film formats vary by model. A scanner for 35mm film won’t necessarily take 120 or 127 negatives.
Check the dimensions of your negatives, along with the formats and holders supported by the specific device.
If a suitable holder isn’t included, you may need to buy another compatible holder or choose a different device.
-
Assuming a discontinued Epson model is currently available
Epson Germany lists the Perfection V600 Photo and V850 Pro as no longer available. The product details describe the models but don’t confirm that they’re currently on sale.
Use them as examples of flatbed scanners with film holders, and check the condition and availability of any specific listing.
Finding a suitable alternative or used device may take extra effort.
Brands to consider
Plustek
The OpticFilm 8300i SE and 135i models illustrate computer-connected 35mm scanning. The 135i is a separate model with a multi-frame holder.
- For the OpticFilm 8300i SE, Plustek lists SilverFast SE Plus 9, QuickScan Plus and 8- or 16-bit greyscale output.
- The 8300i SE specifications don’t confirm automatic strip feed. Infrared correction is not a reliable reason to choose a scanner for classic silver-based black and white film.
reflecta
The RPS 10S is designed to feed compatible 35mm strips while connected to a computer; according to the manufacturer, the x66-Scan supports several film formats and saves scans to an SD card.
- reflecta specifies strips with 3 to 40 frames for the RPS 10S. The x66-Scan is listed as supporting 120, 135 and 127 film.
- The x66-Scan saves JPEG files to an SD card. reflecta lists a 14 MP sensor; 22 MP is interpolated and should not be confused with the sensor resolution.
Epson
The Perfection V600 Photo and V850 Pro are examples of flatbed scanners with film holders for 35mm and 120/220 film, as well as other originals.
- Epson Germany documents the film holders supplied with both models.
- Epson lists both models as no longer available. The specifications don’t confirm current availability or software compatibility for a specific device.
Rollei
The DF-S 180 is described as a USB-connected slide and negative scanner that saves images to a PC.
- Rollei lists supplied software and image output of up to 18 MP.
- The manufacturer’s specifications are not an independent assessment of image quality and don’t confirm suitability for every film format.
KODAK Photo Plus
According to the supplier, the Slide N Scan is a standalone device for black and white negatives in 135, 110 and 126 formats.
- KODAK Photo Plus lists SD card storage and a 14 MP sensor.
- The stated 22 MP output is interpolated. The model specifications are not an independent quality assessment.
Suitable products at Joybuy
Suitable products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Does automatic infrared dust removal work on black and white negatives?
It doesn’t work on classic silver-based black and white film in the same way as it does on colour film. LaserSoft Imaging explains that the silver layer interferes with infrared detection, so check what software-based retouching is available in the specific software edition.
What should I check before connecting a film scanner to my home computer?
Check the operating system, connection and software requirements for the specific model against your computer. Plustek lists USB connectivity and Windows and Mac support for the OpticFilm 8300i SE; the reflecta x66-Scan scans independently of a computer and saves to an SD card.
How should I deal with dust on black and white film?
Check your negatives and holder for visible dust before scanning, then decide whether manual or suitable software-based retouching is needed. Don’t choose an infrared channel solely on the assumption that it will automatically correct classic silver-based film.
How many frames can a scanner with automatic strip feed handle?
It depends on the specific model and the compatible film strips. reflecta lists the RPS 10S as feeding strips with 3 to 40 frames; this refers to the strips, not the total time needed for scanning and post-processing.