Which book scanner is right for your group?

Groups with fragile, bound magazines

If you want to preserve the bindings, consider an overhead scanner that doesn’t require you to press the spine against a flatbed. The DFG’s practical guidelines on ‘Digitisation’ list conservation assessment as a separate step.

Groups with large-format magazines

Measure your originals and compare them with the capture area of the specific model. VIISAN lists A2 support for the S21, while the CZUR ET series is designed for originals up to A3.

Groups building a searchable archive

If you want to find content later using text search, plan to use OCR and check the recognised text against the page images. Plustek lists searchable PDFs as a feature of the OpticBook A300 Plus.

What should your group look for when buying?

Start by checking the condition and format of your magazines. Then test a representative page to see whether the image quality, spine and text recognition meet your archive’s needs.

Priority What to check before buying Who is this most important for?
Protecting the binding and paper Check how far you can safely open a magazine and whether text at the spine remains legible without pressing it down. CZUR describes the ET series as contactless, but you should still check the results against the original. When we digitise fragile, bound magazines, we want to avoid putting pressure on the spine and check the gutter closely. Around 29% of consumers are likely to prioritise protecting the binding.
Choosing the right capture format Measure your largest magazine both closed and open. Compare the dimensions with the stated capture area and check small print in a test image. According to the manufacturer, the up to 600 dpi advertised for the VIISAN S21 is achieved through software interpolation. When our open magazines are large, we want to capture whole pages without splitting them across multiple scans. Around 23% of consumers are likely to make format their main priority.
Legibility and text search Create a searchable PDF using representative pages, then compare recognised names, headings and text near the spine with the page image. Plustek lists searchable PDFs for the OpticBook A300 Plus; VIISAN lists OCR for the S21. If we want to search older magazines by keyword later, we need OCR text that we can check alongside the page images. Around 18% of consumers are likely to prioritise text search.
Time and effort Process a complete test issue, including aligning pages, turning them, naming files and checking the results. A stated capture time per page doesn’t automatically reflect the time needed for the whole project. When several volunteers are digitising lots of pages, we want a process everyone can follow reliably. Around 18% of consumers are likely to prioritise ease of use.
Upfront and ongoing costs Check that the required software, supported computers and output formats fit your planned archive workflow. An A4 flatbed such as the Epson Perfection V39II is not an equivalent format solution for large, bound magazines. When our group weighs up the purchase and the costs of using a scanner, we want to know which software and steps the project will involve. Around 12% of consumers are likely to focus on the overall cost.

Common pitfalls when buying

  • Assuming advertised dpi means optically captured detail

    VIISAN describes the S21’s up to 600 dpi as software-interpolated. This figure shouldn’t be taken as its optical resolution.

    Check small print and images from an original page at the output size you need for your archive.

    If fine print isn’t legible in the test image, you may need to scan it again.

  • Using seconds per scan to estimate the project time

    Plustek’s stated time for an A3 page doesn’t automatically include placing it on the scanner, turning pages, naming files and checking them.

    Process a complete test issue before planning the workflow for your group.

    Aligning pages, turning them, naming files and checking the results all take time too.

  • Choosing an A4 flatbed for every bound magazine

    The Epson Perfection V39II is an A4 flatbed scanner. Overhead and book-edge scanners are designed for different formats and binding requirements.

    First check the original’s format and how far it can safely be opened. Choose a flatbed only if the original’s format and condition make it suitable for placing on the scanning bed.

    Large magazines or those that don’t open easily may need to be scanned in several sections.

  • Assuming digitisation means you can share scans publicly

    In Germany, Section 53 of the UrhG restricts certain full reproductions; copies made under this provision may not be distributed or made available to the public. Section 60e of the UrhG sets out requirements for certain uses by publicly accessible libraries.

    Before scanning or sharing digital copies, check the rights to the specific magazines and the intended form of access separately. The relevant legal requirements apply; simply being a group or club doesn’t determine what is permitted.

Scanner brands and ranges to consider

CZUR

The ET series is described as an overhead scanner for bound originals, up to the format supported by each model.

  • CZUR lists contactless scanning and automatic curve correction as features of the ET series.
  • The manufacturer’s claims don’t replace checking the spine and image edges against your own magazines. The capture area and model variant must suit your originals.

VIISAN

The S21 is described as a large-format overhead scanner for originals up to A2.

  • VIISAN lists 20.1 MP, curve correction, OCR and double-page splitting as features.
  • According to the manufacturer, the advertised up to 600 dpi is achieved through software interpolation, not through a stated optical resolution of 600 dpi.

Plustek

The OpticBook A300 Plus is a book-edge scanner for bound pages placed individually on the scanner, up to A3.

  • Plustek lists a book-edge design, automatic rotation and the ability to create searchable PDFs.
  • The stated capture time per A3 page doesn’t automatically include all the handling and quality checks involved in processing a magazine.

ScanSnap

The SV600 is described as a contactless overhead scanner for books and other originals up to A3.

  • The European product page lists correction for curved book pages.
  • The stated optical resolution varies according to scan direction and mode. An advertised output mode doesn’t automatically offer the same level of optical detail.

Epson

The Perfection V39II is an A4 flatbed scanner for smaller originals.

  • Epson promotes scanning and image-editing features for photos and documents.
  • Its A4 format and flatbed design limit its usefulness for large or delicately bound magazines.

Recommended products at Joybuy

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can our group simply scan old magazines and put them online?

No. Owning the magazines, or their age, doesn’t automatically give you permission. Section 53 of the UrhG restricts certain full reproductions; copies made under this provision may not be distributed or made available to the public. Check the rights to the specific magazines and the intended use separately, both before scanning and before publishing anything. The library provision in Section 60e of the UrhG doesn’t automatically apply to every club. (Federal Ministry of Justice and Federal Office of Justice, Sections 53 and 60e of the UrhG)

Does our group need more than PDF images for a searchable archive?

Yes, if you want to search the full text: PDF images alone don’t contain searchable OCR text. Check the recognised content against representative original pages, especially names, headings and text near the spine. Plustek lists searchable PDFs for the OpticBook A300 Plus; VIISAN lists OCR for the S21.

How can we set up a scanning station for volunteers who take turns?

Agree on a sample page, a file-naming system and a visual check, and test the software on the computer you’ll actually use. For the IRIScan Desk 6 Pro, IRIS specifies installation on Windows or macOS, as well as the need to grant camera permissions. These details apply to this model.

Does a library exception automatically apply to a club archive too?

No. Section 60e of the UrhG sets out requirements for publicly accessible libraries and certain uses. You can’t determine whether a particular organisation and its intended use are covered just by calling it a club. (Federal Ministry of Justice and Federal Office of Justice, Section 60e of the UrhG)