Which scanner is right for you?

For those preserving delicate volumes

If you want to put as little strain as possible on a book’s cover and pages when digitising it, compare the benefits of non-contact overhead scanning with the opening angle the book needs. CZUR, Ricoh and VIISAN describe features on certain models for scanning bound books and correcting curved pages.

For local archive researchers

If you want to find names, places and passages later, check not only that the page images are clear, but also that searchable files are available and OCR works well with your own material. VIISAN notes that text recognition depends on the quality and layout of the original.

For digitising large numbers of pages

When you have lots of book pages to scan, the scanning area, the capture process and the time needed to check the images afterwards all matter. Ricoh and VIISAN describe page-turn detection features; test how well they fit your own workflow.

What should you look for when buying?

When scanning bound local history books, start by considering how gently the volume can be scanned. Then look at how clearly text is captured at the spine, how easy it is to search and the effort involved in repeated scans.

Overhead scanner with book correction

A good fit if: you want to preserve the binding or the book shouldn’t be pressed flat against a glass surface.

Consider: checking the spine, lighting and software correction. Automatic flattening doesn’t guarantee an error-free archive image.

Book-edge flatbed scanner

A good fit if: the volume is sturdy and opens without needing to be pressed hard, and capturing close to the spine is important.

Consider: each page must be positioned correctly, which may not suit fragile bindings. Plustek specifies a 2 mm book-edge design for the OpticBook 4800.

Compact A4 flatbed scanner

A good fit if: you mainly scan loose pages, photos or sturdy books that open easily, and have limited desk space.

Consider: the A4 format limits the size of material you can scan, and doesn’t automatically make the scanner suitable for large or delicate volumes.

Buying priority What to check Who cares most about it?
Protecting original material The book’s condition and opening angle; a suitable support and book correction. When I digitise bound originals, I want to handle them as gently as possible. Around 33% of consumers place the greatest importance on protecting original material.
Finding passages again Searchable PDF and suitable OCR language; test a challenging sample page, including the spine. If I want to search for names and places later, I need clear images and text recognition I can check. Around 27% of consumers put searchability first.
Scanning lots of pages Page-turn detection or timed capture; check that the book format fits the scanning area. When I’m working with a substantial volume, I want to reduce repetitive steps without skipping quality checks. Around 20% of consumers place particular importance on a manageable workflow.
Saving space in a home office Measure the available work surface with the book open; check the operating system and required software. If space is limited, the scanner and the book being scanned both need to fit on my desk. Around 20% of consumers put space requirements and ongoing costs first.

Each percentage represents consumers for whom the priority listed is their most important consideration when buying.

Common buying and scanning mistakes

  • Assuming a private archive means you can make complete copies of any book

    Section 53 UrhG distinguishes between private copies and the substantially complete reproduction of a book; the latter is subject to specific conditions.

    Before scanning an entire copyright-protected volume, check whether a specific legal exception applies or permission is required. Check publication rights separately.

  • Assuming advertised OCR or book flattening will produce error-free archive files

    VIISAN says that OCR recognition depends on the quality and layout of the original. Automatic correction doesn’t replace checking the spine and page edges.

    Start by scanning a challenging sample page with a spine, an illustration and small print. Compare the image with the recognised text.

    Allow extra time to check the images and correct recognised text.

  • Focusing only on dpi or megapixel figures

    A resolution figure alone doesn’t tell you whether an open book will fit on the scanning area or can be scanned without unwanted pressure.

    First compare the book’s size and condition, then the scanner’s design and scanning area. After that, check the image and text on a typical page.

  • Choosing a standard document feeder for bound books

    A feeder is designed for loose sheets. Bound books need to be scanned without being fed through rollers or cut apart to do so.

    If you want to preserve the binding, consider an overhead scanner or a suitable flatbed.

    If you don’t have a suitable scanner, you may need to use another digitisation method.

Brands to consider

CZUR

Worth considering if you’re looking for an overhead scanner for bound material, with features to correct curved pages.

  • CZUR describes the Aura Pro as offering A3 capture and curve flattening, and the ET series as offering non-contact scanning.
  • These are manufacturer claims; they don’t prove that spine correction or OCR will be error-free. Features vary by model.

Ricoh ScanSnap

The SV600 is an overhead scanner for bound books and material up to A3 size.

  • Ricoh lists book correction, page-turn detection and a timed mode.
  • The maximum document thickness of 30 mm specified by the manufacturer applies to the SV600; it isn’t a general claim about thick historical books.

VIISAN

The VK16 is an overhead scanner with an A3 scanning area, book mode and OCR.

  • VIISAN lists curve correction, page separation and searchable file formats.
  • According to the manufacturer, OCR recognition depends on the quality and layout of the original; check the recognised text against your own pages.

Plustek

The OpticBook 4800 is a flatbed scanner designed for books, suitable for volumes that open easily.

  • Plustek describes a 2 mm book edge and the option to create searchable PDFs.
  • The book is placed on a flat surface and needs to be opened to the right position; check that this is suitable for the specific binding.

Epson

The Perfection V39II is a compact A4 flatbed scanner for individual documents, images and suitable sturdy books.

  • Epson lists a stand and a resolution of 4,800 dpi for the V39II.
  • The A4 format still limits the size of material you can scan; the stated resolution doesn’t prove that delicate bindings can be scanned gently.

Recommended products on Joybuy

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can I scan an entire copyright-protected local history book for my private archive?

Not simply because you intend to keep the copy private. Under Section 53(4) UrhG, the substantially complete reproduction of a book is generally permitted only with consent. The provision sets out exceptions, including certain conditions for making a copy for your own archive under Section 53(2), sentence 1, no. 2, as well as certain works that have been out of print for at least two years, for your own use. You’ll need to check separately whether an exception applies to the specific book and intended use. The legislation is published by the Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice on the Laws on the Internet website.

Does an old publication date mean a work is in the public domain?

No. Section 64 UrhG bases the general term of copyright protection on the author’s death; copyright expires 70 years afterwards. For a specific volume, you should also check the rights to any contributions and illustrations it contains. The legislation is published by the Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice on the Laws on the Internet website.

Can I put my scans online or share them with others?

Permission to make a copy for private or other personal use doesn’t give you blanket permission to publish it. Section 53(6) UrhG generally prohibits distributing or publicly communicating copies made under this provision. Check the rights to the specific material before publishing it. The legislation is published by the Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice on the Laws on the Internet website.

How do I set up an overhead scanner for book pages?

Position the open book within the stated scanning area. Before starting a longer scan, check the spine, page edges, reflections and the separation of the two pages in the preview. VIISAN describes how to align, correct and check scanned pages with the VK16.

What should I check about the software and operating system?

Check that the operating system, drivers and OCR software are compatible with your computer, and confirm what’s included with the specific offer. Plustek lists separate software and driver packages for the OpticBook 4800; you’ll need to choose the version that works with your system.