Those caring for fragile local history books
If a volume is bound or damaged, the cradle you choose needs to suit its condition. The Badische Landesbibliothek makes digitisation dependent on the item’s condition.
For fragile local history books, or ones that can only be opened a little, an overhead scanner with a suitable book cradle is an obvious option. Check how it handles the specific volume, as the Badische Landesbibliothek makes digitisation dependent on the item’s condition. For sturdy, easy-to-handle volumes, a flatbed scanner with a book-edge design may be suitable. For maps and wide inserts, consider the scanning area and check the actual image quality with a test scan. OCR results for historical typefaces also need to be checked. Choosing a device does not settle the question of usage rights or whether scans can be published.
If a volume is bound or damaged, the cradle you choose needs to suit its condition. The Badische Landesbibliothek makes digitisation dependent on the item’s condition.
If you want to find names and places using search later, check the OCR results against the original pages. OCR-D notes that historical printed material and Fraktur require suitable recognition models.
If books include large-format maps or inserts, remember to plan for the scanning area, complete page capture and storage of image files. The Badische Landesbibliothek describes colour images and redundant storage as part of its own digitisation practice.
First, check how far you can open the most fragile volumes. Then use a test scan to assess the format, text search and workflow for everyone involved.
| What matters | What to check before buying | Who will find this most important? |
|---|---|---|
| Protecting the binding and paper | Test the opening angle, book cradle and ability to capture right up to the spine using a suitable volume. | If I’m scanning fragile or tightly bound originals, the cradle needs to suit their condition. Around 33% of consumers put protecting originals first. |
| Finding historical texts again | Create a searchable PDF using typical names and typefaces; check the page image and the recognised text separately. | If I want to search for place and personal names later, I need to test OCR on actual pages from the book. Around 25% of consumers prioritise full-text search. |
| Formats and image coverage | Measure the largest book page and any inserts; check small print, margins and complete pages in a test scan. | If I’m scanning maps or wide inserts as well as local history books, the scanning area needs to be suitable. For around 25% of consumers, capturing a range of different materials is a priority. |
| Workflow for volunteers | Run through page-turning, file names, page order, export and corrections together on the computer you’ll be using. | If several volunteers will be scanning and filing pages regularly, the team needs a workflow everyone can follow. Around 17% of consumers look first at how easy a scanner is to use as a team. |
Even with an overhead scanner, the book needs to be opened and supported appropriately. Scanning from above alone doesn’t show whether the binding and pages are being protected sufficiently.
Check fragile originals first, then try the intended cradle with a suitable volume. A digitisation service may be an alternative for books that need special care; the Badische Landesbibliothek takes an item’s condition into account.
Fragile volumes may need to be assessed with a digitisation service.
According to the manufacturer, the VIISAN S21’s advertised output of up to 600 dpi uses software interpolation, rather than optical resolution.
Assess small print and details near the edges using a scan of an actual page from your book.
If the test scan isn’t good enough, you may need to rescan or carry out additional image checks.
Historical typefaces need suitable OCR models; having a recognition feature doesn’t by itself prove that names will be easy to find. A quoted scan time also won’t necessarily include the full checking and file-organising process.
Work through a short, complete sample chapter – from scanning to a checked, searchable file.
Your team should allow time for recognition, corrections and filing the images.
What the law allows depends, among other things, on the purpose and type of organisation. Permission to make a copy doesn’t automatically mean that scans can be made available to the public.
Record the rights and intended use for each title before scanning or publishing it. The relevant conditions are set out in legislation including the Copyright Act (Urheberrechtsgesetz).
The ET series includes overhead scanners for bound books, including the ET24 Pro and other models.
The OpticBook 4800 is designed for bound books placed on the scanner, with a book-edge design.
According to the manufacturer, the S21 is an overhead scanner for materials up to A2, which may make it suitable for books with large-format inserts.
The ScanSnap SV600 is an overhead option for bound and fragile materials.
The IRIScan Desk 6 Pro is an A3 document camera with various export formats, including searchable PDFs.
A searchable PDF makes it easier to find text, but it shouldn’t replace the whole archival workflow. Also plan for clearly organised image files, reliable links between files and originals, and backup copies. The Badische Landesbibliothek describes colour images and redundant storage as its own practice, not as a blanket requirement for societies.
Scan representative pages and compare important names with the page images. OCR-D describes different models for historical printed material and Fraktur; a general OCR feature doesn’t prove it will be accurate enough for your book.
For books that need special care, a digitisation service may be an alternative to scanning them yourself. The Badische Landesbibliothek bases reproductions on the item’s condition and the technical options available, so check in advance whether the specific book can be handled.
There’s no single answer that applies in every case. Section 53 of the Copyright Act (UrhG) sets conditions for making copies; copies made under this section must not be made available to the public. The special provisions in Sections 60e and 60f of the UrhG apply to certain institutions and purposes. Before scanning or publishing, check which rules apply to your group, the title in question and the intended use.
No. Section 64 of the UrhG generally sets the end of copyright at 70 years after the author’s death; it doesn’t depend on the book’s age alone. Check who created the specific work and whether it contains contributions by other authors.
The General Data Protection Regulation also governs how societies process personal data. Before creating a collection that others can access, check what personal information it contains and the basis on which it will be processed and shared. Buying a scanner won’t resolve these questions.